Families of Russian Soldiers Demand Answers About Missing Relatives

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2022-07-27.

Russian Military Families' Demands for Information in 2022

On 26 July 2022, relatives of Russian soldiers who had gone missing in Ukraine brought a collective appeal to the public reception office of the Russian president in Moscow. The letter, signed by 106 people, asked the state to find their sons and husbands, to record them as prisoners of war rather than simply "missing," and to help bring them home. Five months into the full-scale invasion, they said the military had told them almost nothing.

The appeal was small in number but unusual for Russia, where public criticism of the war carried real legal risk. It showed how the official silence about losses was being felt inside ordinary families.

What the families asked for

The petition was reported by Sever.Realii, a project of Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, which obtained a copy. Its central demand was simple: "We demand to find our loved ones, to add them to the lists of prisoners of war who have gone missing."

The status matters. A soldier listed as captured can be included in prisoner exchanges; one listed as missing may simply disappear from view. According to Ukrainska Pravda's summary of the letter, the families said the Defence Ministry had blocked such status changes for more than five months. They also asked for:

  • help centres across Russia where relatives could get information;
  • efforts to return prisoners held by Ukraine;
  • DNA testing where a soldier might have been buried.

Notably, the letter did not call for an end to the war. It was a plea for information and help, not a political protest, and the women who delivered it framed it that way.

Some headlines at the time called it a protest at the Kremlin. Contemporary reports describe it more precisely as relatives handing in a written appeal at the presidential reception office in central Moscow.

Two women's stories

Anna Danilova told Radio Free Europe that her husband, Alexander Yaroslavtsev, had been sent to Ukraine with his brigade. In early April 2022 she received a message from the Ukrainian side saying he had been killed. When she called his military base she was first reassured, then told a day later by an officer that he had burned to death and there was nothing left to recover. Months on, she was still being told by officials that it was up to her to prove whether he was alive.

Irina Chistyakova said her son, reported to be 19, had been sent across the border under false pretences, when soldiers had been told they would stay on the Russian side. In June, she said, the Defence Ministry informed Russia's human rights commissioner, Tatyana Moskalkova, that her son was alive and held by Ukraine, yet she received no further detail. She went on to set up online chats for soldiers' mothers that, according to Ukrainska Pravda, grew to about 25,000 relatives.

Chistyakova also described being threatened. She told reporters that a colonel had warned her that pressing the issue could end badly for her, which she took as a threat to her life. Her account could not be independently verified, but it matched a wider pattern of pressure on families who spoke out.

Why information was so hard to get

Military casualty figures are treated as state secrets in Russia. In early June 2022, a court in Kaliningrad ruled that a published list of killed Russian soldiers was classified, and that publishing it could be a criminal offence. New laws passed after the invasion also punished spreading what the authorities called false information about the armed forces.

Families also described a practical problem. Soldiers often went into combat without phones or documents, which made identification difficult when they were killed or captured. Danilova later said officials made her sign a warning that contacting the Ukrainian side could lead to a prison sentence of up to seven years, even though that was the only place she could get news.

How many Russian soldiers had died by mid-2022?

No one outside the Russian government knew for certain. At the Aspen Security Forum on 20 July 2022, CIA Director William Burns said US intelligence put Russian losses "in the vicinity of 15,000 killed," with perhaps three times that number wounded. He added that Ukraine had also suffered significant casualties.

Russia's own figures were far lower. The Defence Ministry confirmed 5,937 soldiers killed in September 2022, and it rarely published new figures. Independent researchers took a different route: the outlet Mediazona and the BBC Russian Service began counting the dead name by name, using obituaries, social media posts and local reports. Their tally grew steadily as the war went on and has always run well ahead of official totals.

Who bears the cost

Analysts have repeatedly noted that a large share of the dead came from Russia's poorer regions, such as Buryatia and Dagestan, rather than from Moscow or St Petersburg. Contract soldiers from these places were often attracted by pay far above local wages. For the Kremlin, that kept the war at a distance from the big cities where public opinion matters most.

That is part of why the appearance of these families in central Moscow mattered. Their demands were modest, but they brought the human cost of the war into the capital, in their own words.

Where families can turn

For relatives on any side of a conflict who are searching for a missing soldier, the International Committee of the Red Cross runs a tracing service through its Central Tracing Agency. It works with both Russia and Ukraine to register prisoners of war and pass on news to families. Ukrainian authorities also set up channels for Russian families to ask about captured servicemen, although using them could carry legal risk inside Russia.

More than four years later, many of these families are still waiting. The story of the 106 signatures is a reminder that behind every casualty estimate there are parents, partners and children who simply want to know what happened.

Sources: Ukrainska Pravda, 26 July 2022; Radio Svoboda (RFE/RL); The Defense Post, 22 July 2022; Wikipedia: Casualties of the Russo-Ukrainian war.

COMMENTS