Originally published 2022-07-18.

In July 2022 a Scottish newspaper reported that 90% of the plankton in the Atlantic Ocean had disappeared since the 1940s, a claim that spread quickly across social media. The figure came from the Edinburgh-based Global Oceanic Environmental Survey (GOES) Foundation. Plankton scientists rejected it: the work was an unreviewed preprint, it used a home-made sampling method, and its samples covered only part of the equatorial Atlantic. Long-running plankton surveys show no sign of a collapse on that scale. What they do show is real and worrying in a different way: plankton populations are shifting, many of them in response to ocean warming.
Here is what the foundation claimed, why experts were unconvinced, and what reliable monitoring actually tells us about the ocean's smallest organisms.
What the GOES Foundation claimed
The Sunday Post published the story on 17 July 2022. According to the foundation, its own yacht had spent two years sampling seawater, first along the coasts of France and Portugal and then across the Atlantic to the Caribbean, while 13 volunteer vessels collected around 500 further samples. Comparing these with older records, the group concluded that plankton levels had fallen by about 90% since the 1940s.
The foundation blamed chemical pollution, including plastics, agricultural fertilisers and pharmaceutical residues, and said climate change could be a further factor. Its report ended with a stark warning: "It is our view that humanity will not survive the extinction of most marine plants and animals."
Environmental campaigners, including Greenpeace UK, responded by urging governments to act faster on ocean protection, and accounts with large followings shared the 90% figure as established fact.
Why scientists did not accept the 90% figure
Within days, plankton researchers pointed out several problems, summarised in a PBS fact-check:
- No peer review. The study was a preprint that had not been checked by independent experts or published in a scientific journal.
- Non-standard equipment. The foundation designed its own filter instead of using established plankton nets or recorders, which makes comparison with historical data unreliable.
- Suspiciously uniform results. All 13 vessels reportedly returned the same result, which can point to a flaw in the method rather than a real pattern across a huge area.
- Missing details. The preprint did not state when samples were collected or what microscope magnification was used to count organisms.
- Limited coverage. The samples came from a restricted part of the equatorial Atlantic, not the whole ocean.
David Johns, who leads the Continuous Plankton Recorder Survey, called the foundation's 500 data points "a literal drop in the ocean" and said that a 90% loss would be "catastrophic and instantly noticeable". The Sunday Post later changed its headline to refer only to the equatorial Atlantic, and at least one widely shared social-media post repeating the claim was deleted.
How plankton are really monitored
The best long-term record comes from the Continuous Plankton Recorder (CPR) Survey, begun in 1931 by the marine biologist Sir Alister Hardy and now run by the Marine Biological Association in Plymouth. A torpedo-shaped device is towed about 10 metres below the surface behind ordinary merchant ships on their normal routes. Plankton are caught on a slowly moving band of silk, which is later cut into samples, each representing about 10 nautical miles of ocean, and examined under a microscope.
The method has stayed essentially the same since 1948, which is what makes decades of data comparable. By the end of 2020, 278 ships had towed the recorder more than 7 million nautical miles, and the survey had collected well over 265,000 samples. Nearly 800 types of plankton have been identified. Satellites add another view by measuring the green pigment chlorophyll at the sea surface, which tracks phytoplankton over the whole globe.
A claimed 90% collapse would show up clearly in both records. It does not.
What the evidence does show
The real picture is change rather than disappearance. CPR data show that warm-water plankton species in the northeast Atlantic have been moving north at roughly 23 km a year, with some shifting about 1,000 km over five decades. Cold-water species have not been replaced in equal measure, which matters for the fish and seabirds that depend on them. Some populations are rising, others falling.
The survey has also recorded a Pacific diatom in the North Atlantic, absent there for hundreds of thousands of years, which may have travelled through the increasingly ice-free Arctic. And microplastics in its samples have increased significantly in recent decades.
Global trends are harder to pin down. A 2010 study in Nature suggested a large global decline in phytoplankton over the previous century, but other researchers questioned its methods and data, and some studies point to increases in certain regions. Scientists generally agree that a warming, more stratified ocean is likely to reduce productivity in many tropical and subtropical waters, while the details are still being measured.
Why plankton matter so much
Plankton are the drifting organisms of the sea. Phytoplankton are tiny plant-like cells that photosynthesise; zooplankton are the small animals, from copepods to fish larvae, that graze on them. Together they form the base of almost every marine food chain, feeding everything from krill and sardines to whales.
Phytoplankton make up only about 1% of the world's plant biomass, yet they carry out roughly half of all photosynthesis on Earth and produce about half the oxygen. They also take in large amounts of carbon dioxide, and when they die and sink they carry carbon into the deep ocean, a process known as the biological carbon pump that moves around 10 billion tonnes of carbon a year.
That is exactly why a genuine collapse could not go unnoticed: fisheries, seabird colonies and ocean chemistry would all change dramatically and quickly.
How to judge alarming ocean headlines
The plankton story is a good case study. Before sharing a dramatic environmental statistic, a few questions help:
- Has the study been peer reviewed and published, or is it a preprint or a press release?
- Does the headline match the area actually studied, or has a regional result been stretched to a whole ocean?
- What do the long-running monitoring programmes in that field say?
- Have independent specialists commented?
Rejecting an exaggerated number is not the same as saying the ocean is fine. Warming, pollution, plastics and overfishing are well documented pressures on marine life. Getting the evidence right makes the case for protecting the ocean stronger, not weaker.
Sources: PBS Peril and Promise, July 2022: If 90% of the Atlantic Ocean's plankton were gone, we would know about it; Wikipedia: Continuous Plankton Recorder; Wikipedia: Phytoplankton. Original report: The Sunday Post, 17 July 2022, on the GOES Foundation preprint.

COMMENTS