LHCb's Three Exotic Particles: A Pentaquark and Two Tetraquarks

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2022-07-12.

CERN's 2022 LHCb Announcement of Three Exotic Particles

In July 2022 the LHCb collaboration at CERN announced three hadrons that had never been observed before: a pentaquark made of five quarks and a pair of tetraquarks made of four. They are not new fundamental particles. They are new ways of binding familiar quarks together, and each one gives physicists a fresh test of how the strong force works.

The results were presented at a CERN seminar on 5 July 2022, the same day the upgraded Large Hadron Collider began its third run of physics at a record collision energy. That timing helped the story travel, but the discoveries themselves came from data recorded in earlier years.

What LHCb actually found

Ordinary matter is built from hadrons, particles held together by the strong force. Almost all of them come in two familiar types: baryons, such as protons and neutrons, contain three quarks, while mesons contain a quark and an antiquark. Anything outside those two patterns is called an "exotic" hadron.

According to CERN's own announcement, the three new states were:

  • A strange pentaquark, made of a charm quark, a charm antiquark, and an up, a down and a strange quark. It was seen in the decays of negatively charged B mesons with a statistical significance of 15 standard deviations. It is the first pentaquark known to contain a strange quark.
  • A doubly charged tetraquark, made of a charm quark, a strange antiquark, an up quark and a down antiquark, observed at 6.5 standard deviations.
  • Its neutral partner, made of a charm quark, a strange antiquark, an up antiquark and a down quark, observed at 8 standard deviations.

The two tetraquarks appeared together in decays of positively charged and neutral B mesons. CERN described them as the first pair of tetraquarks ever observed.

For comparison, particle physicists usually treat five standard deviations as the threshold for claiming a discovery. All three results cleared that bar, the pentaquark by a very wide margin.

Why exotic hadrons matter

The idea that quarks could combine in groups of four or five is almost as old as the quark model itself. Murray Gell-Mann and George Zweig both allowed for it in the 1960s. Proving that such states really exist took decades, because they are short-lived, rare and hidden among enormous numbers of ordinary decays.

The first convincing candidates appeared in the 2000s, and LHCb reported its first pentaquarks in 2015. Since then the list has grown quickly. The collaboration's physics coordinator, Niels Tuning, summed up the trend when the 2022 results were released:

"The more analyses we perform, the more kinds of exotic hadrons we find."

Tuning compared the moment to the 1950s, when a flood of new hadrons eventually led physicists to the quark model, and joked that LHCb was building a "particle zoo 2.0". The LHCb spokesperson, Chris Parkes, said the new states should help theorists develop a unified model of exotic hadrons and also better understand conventional ones.

That is the real value here. The strong force is notoriously hard to calculate at low energies, so every new combination of quarks is a data point that theories must explain. A key open question is how these objects are built: are the quarks tightly bound in one compact particle, or are they loosely stuck pairs of ordinary mesons and baryons, like a tiny molecule? Different arrangements predict different masses and decay patterns, and only measurements like these can tell them apart.

Do they break the Standard Model?

No. This is one of the most common misunderstandings around stories like this one. Tetraquarks and pentaquarks are allowed by quantum chromodynamics, the part of the Standard Model that describes the strong force. Finding them confirms that quarks can arrange themselves in more ways than textbooks once emphasised, but it does not point to new forces or new fundamental particles.

It also has no direct connection with dark matter or dark energy. Those remain open puzzles, and the hope is that other measurements at the LHC, or elsewhere, will eventually reveal physics beyond the Standard Model. The exotic hadrons are a story about understanding known physics better, which is less dramatic but genuinely useful.

The collider behind the discovery

The Large Hadron Collider sits in a ring-shaped tunnel about 27 kilometres (roughly 16.6 miles) around, buried 50 to 175 metres below the border between France and Switzerland near Geneva. Two beams of protons travel in opposite directions inside it, steered by superconducting magnets chilled to 1.9 kelvin, colder than outer space. Where the beams cross, detectors record the debris of the collisions.

LHCb is one of the four main experiments. Its speciality is particles containing bottom and charm quarks, which is exactly why it is so good at spotting exotic hadrons: many of them show up in the decays of B mesons.

The collider was switched off in December 2018 for a long upgrade, known as Long Shutdown 2, and returned to operation in April 2022. On 5 July 2022 it began Run 3, colliding protons at 13.6 tera-electronvolts, slightly more than in Run 2. CERN Director-General Fabiola Gianotti described each new energy as "always uncharted territory and always a big emotion", according to CERN Courier.

LHCb itself was rebuilt during the shutdown and expected to collect around three times more data in Run 3 than before, which should make further discoveries of rare states more likely.

Higgs, then and now

The 2022 announcement came almost exactly ten years after the LHC's most famous result. On 4 July 2012 the ATLAS and CMS experiments announced a new particle consistent with the Higgs boson, the particle linked to the field that gives other fundamental particles their mass. Peter Higgs and François Englert, who had predicted the mechanism in the 1960s, shared the 2013 Nobel Prize in Physics. Higgs died in April 2024, aged 94.

The Higgs boson is an elementary particle. The new pentaquark and tetraquarks are composite ones. Both kinds of result matter, but they answer different questions: the Higgs confirmed a missing piece of the Standard Model, while exotic hadrons test how its strong-force rules play out in practice.

Key points to remember

  • LHCb announced one pentaquark and two tetraquarks on 5 July 2022.
  • They are new combinations of known quarks, not new fundamental particles.
  • The pentaquark is the first one found to contain a strange quark; the tetraquarks are the first pair ever seen.
  • The results fit the Standard Model and do not, by themselves, say anything about dark matter.
  • Run 3 of the LHC started the same day at 13.6 TeV, promising far more data for similar searches.

Each new hadron is a small piece of a large jigsaw. Physicists still cannot predict exactly which quark combinations nature allows and how they hold together. With more data arriving, the "particle zoo" is likely to keep growing.

Sources: CERN: LHCb discovers three new exotic particles; CERN Courier: Run 3 physics gets under way; Wikipedia: Large Hadron Collider; Royal Society: Peter Higgs obituary. Earlier coverage of this story appeared on ScienceAlert.

COMMENTS