Originally published 2022-06-26.

On 24 June 2022 the US Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, the 1973 decision that had recognised a constitutional right to abortion. The ruling, in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, handed the question back to each state. Within weeks, abortion was banned or heavily restricted across much of the South and Midwest.
The reaction was immediate and loud. Critics pointed out that polls consistently showed most Americans wanted abortion to stay legal in at least most cases, and argued that an unelected court had overridden majority opinion. Supporters of the ruling replied that the decision did the opposite: it took the issue away from nine judges and gave it to voters and their elected legislatures. Both arguments shaped what followed.
What the Supreme Court decided
The case concerned a Mississippi law banning most abortions after 15 weeks of pregnancy. The court upheld that law by six votes to three. A narrower majority of five went further and overruled both Roe and the 1992 case Planned Parenthood v. Casey, holding that the Constitution does not protect a right to abortion.
Justice Samuel Alito wrote the majority opinion, joined by Justices Clarence Thomas, Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett. Chief Justice John Roberts agreed that the Mississippi law could stand but would not have overturned Roe entirely, warning that doing so was a serious jolt to the legal system.
The three liberal justices, Stephen Breyer, Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan, wrote a rare joint dissent. It closed by saying they dissented “with sorrow” for the court and for the millions of American women who had lost what they called a fundamental constitutional protection. President Joe Biden, who had opposed overturning Roe, called on Congress to restore its protections in federal law, which did not happen.
What the polls actually showed
The figure most often quoted came from the Pew Research Center. In a survey of more than 10,000 adults in March 2022, 61% said abortion should be legal in all or most cases and 37% said it should be illegal in all or most cases.
That headline hides a lot of nuance. Only 19% wanted abortion legal in every case with no exceptions, and 8% wanted it illegal in every case. Most people sat somewhere in between. More than half said the stage of pregnancy should matter: support for legal abortion was much higher at six weeks than at 24 weeks. About seven in ten said it should be legal when a pregnancy results from rape, and 73% when the woman’s life or health is at risk.
Pew’s question asked about abortion in general, not about Roe itself, though earlier surveys had found most Americans did not want Roe completely overturned. A poll reflects public opinion on a question; it is not a legal argument, and the court’s majority said its task was to read the Constitution rather than follow polls.
Why critics called it undemocratic
For opponents, the gap between public opinion and the result was the heart of the problem. The Guardian gathered a range of these voices two days after the ruling. The British historian Simon Schama argued that American democracy could not survive “if the constitution is manipulated to impose minority rule.”
Edward Fallone, an associate professor at Marquette University Law School in Milwaukee, described the court as the least democratic branch of government rolling back a popular liberty, and predicted demonstrations and political turmoil. Cristina Tzintzún Ramirez, president of the progressive youth group NextGen America, saw the decision as the start of a wider push against gains for women, LGBTQ people and people of colour.
Critics also noted the structural side: four of the five justices who voted to overrule Roe were appointed by presidents who first won the White House while losing the national popular vote. Defenders of the court answered that this is how the constitutional system is designed, and that returning abortion to state legislatures was itself a democratic outcome.
Trust in the court and fears for other rights
Confidence in the Supreme Court was already falling before the ruling. A Gallup poll conducted from 1 to 20 June 2022 found only 25% of Americans had a great deal or quite a lot of confidence in it, down from 36% a year earlier and the lowest in Gallup’s records going back to 1973.
Concern spread beyond abortion because of a separate opinion by Justice Thomas. He wrote that the court should reconsider other rulings based on the same legal reasoning, naming the cases protecting contraception (Griswold), private sexual conduct between adults (Lawrence) and same-sex marriage (Obergefell). The majority opinion said its reasoning applied only to abortion, and no other justice joined Thomas on that point.
Congress responded on marriage. The Respect for Marriage Act, signed by President Biden on 13 December 2022 with votes from both parties, requires the federal government and every state to recognise same-sex and interracial marriages performed legally elsewhere, even if Obergefell were ever overturned.
What has happened since
The first test at the ballot box came in Kansas, a Republican-leaning state, on 2 August 2022. Voters rejected a constitutional amendment that would have removed abortion protections, by 59% to 41%, on a record turnout for a primary. In November 2022, voters in California, Michigan and Vermont added abortion rights to their state constitutions. By 2025, referendums on abortion had been held in 16 states, with abortion-rights supporters winning most of them.
At the same time, many states enforced bans or strict limits. As of 2026, 21 states ban or restrict abortion earlier than the old Roe standard allowed, and many of the bans have no exception for rape or incest. Doctors in those states have described confusion over when the medical exceptions apply, and people seeking abortions travel long distances or order medication by post. Anyone facing a pregnancy decision or a complication should talk to a doctor or a clinic they trust about what is legally and medically available where they live.
Common misunderstandings
“The ruling banned abortion across the US.” It did not. It ended the federal constitutional right, leaving each state to decide. Abortion remains legal in many states.
“Most Americans want abortion legal with no limits.” Polls show majority support for legal abortion in most cases, but also wide support for some limits later in pregnancy.
“Same-sex marriage was overturned too.” No. Obergefell still stands, and the 2022 Respect for Marriage Act adds a federal guarantee of recognition.
Sources: The Guardian, 26 June 2022; Ballotpedia News, 24 June 2022; Wikipedia: Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization; Pew Research Center: America’s Abortion Quandary; Gallup, June 2022; Wikipedia: 2022 Kansas abortion referendum; Wikipedia: Respect for Marriage Act.

COMMENTS