Veteran Abortion-Rights Activists React to the Roe v. Wade Leak

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2022-05-08.

Abortion-Rights Campaigners From the 1970s Respond in 2022

In May 2022, after Politico published a leaked draft opinion showing that the US Supreme Court was preparing to overturn Roe v. Wade, some of the loudest warnings came from women who had campaigned for legal abortion before 1973. Speaking to The Guardian, veterans such as Frances Beal, then 82, described what life looked like before Roe: friends lost to illegal procedures, unequal access depending on money and race, and fear. Their message was that the country risked returning to that era. Seven weeks later, the Court's final ruling confirmed the draft.

Here is who these campaigners are, what they said, and what has happened since.

The leak that set off the reaction

On 2 May 2022, Politico published a draft majority opinion by Justice Samuel Alito in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization, a case about a Mississippi law banning most abortions after 15 weeks. The draft argued that Roe had been "egregiously wrong" and that abortion should be left to the states. The next day the Court confirmed that the document was authentic, while stressing that it was not final.

The leak was without modern precedent at the Court. An internal investigation later reported, in January 2023, that it could not identify who was responsible. Politically, the effect was immediate: protests began outside the Court within hours, and organisers called for demonstrations across the country.

At the time, campaign groups estimated that tens of millions of women of reproductive age lived in states likely to ban or severely restrict abortion if Roe fell. Planned Parenthood's widely quoted figure was around 36 million.

Frances Beal: from SNCC to reproductive justice

Frances "Fran" Beal was born in 1940 in Binghamton, New York. In 1968 she co-founded the Black Women's Liberation Committee within the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee (SNCC), a civil-rights organisation where women often did the work while men took the leadership roles. The committee grew into the Third World Women's Alliance in 1969 after Puerto Rican activists joined.

Beal is best known for her 1969 essay Double Jeopardy: To Be Black and Female, which argued that Black women faced combined discrimination by race, sex and class. The essay became a foundation text of Black feminism and is often cited as a forerunner of the idea of intersectionality.

Her commitment to abortion rights was personal. A high-school friend died in 1958 after a back-street abortion. Beal told The Guardian that the death of her friend, and the many women like her, was what drove her campaigning. She also fought forced sterilisation of poor women of colour, a reminder that for many activists "choice" meant the right to have children as well as the right not to.

In 2022 she warned that overturning Roe would cost women's lives, and that the US often sets a pattern that other countries follow. She also noted that even legal abortion had been unevenly available, depending on class and race. Her call was for people across generations to stand together, as she and others had done in the 1970s.

Nori Rost and the wider fear

The Guardian also spoke to Dr Nori Rost, a minister and leader at the New York Society for Ethical Culture and a long-time supporter of abortion rights. She described a feeling of being thrown back to 1972, half a century later, with the same panic and uncertainty. She called it a very helpless feeling that five justices could decide how millions of women access healthcare.

Rost also warned that the legal reasoning used against Roe could later be turned against same-sex marriage. That fear was not imaginary: in his concurring opinion in the final ruling, Justice Clarence Thomas wrote that the Court should reconsider other precedents based on the same constitutional reasoning, naming Obergefell (same-sex marriage), Lawrence (private sexual conduct) and Griswold (contraception). The majority opinion said its ruling applied only to abortion. In late 2022, Congress passed the Respect for Marriage Act to give same-sex marriages federal recognition as a safeguard.

What abortion was like before Roe

To understand why these women spoke with such urgency, it helps to remember the situation before 22 January 1973, when the Court decided Roe by seven votes to two. At that point, 30 states banned abortion in all circumstances. Sixteen allowed it only in narrow cases, and only a handful, including New York, allowed it more generally.

Women with money could travel to a state or country where abortion was legal, or find a doctor willing to help discreetly. Women without those resources often turned to unqualified providers or tried to end pregnancies themselves. Infections and haemorrhage from unsafe procedures killed women every year; individual cases such as Gerri Santoro, who died in Connecticut in 1964, became symbols for the movement.

Roe established a constitutional right to abortion before viability. In 1992, Planned Parenthood v. Casey kept that core right but replaced the original trimester framework with an "undue burden" test, giving states more room to regulate.

What the final ruling did

On 24 June 2022, the Supreme Court issued its decision in Dobbs. It upheld Mississippi's law by six votes to three, and by five votes to four overturned both Roe and Casey, ruling that the Constitution does not confer a right to abortion. Chief Justice John Roberts agreed with upholding the Mississippi law but would not have gone as far as overturning Roe.

Thirteen states had "trigger laws" ready to ban abortion as soon as Roe fell. Others revived old bans or passed new restrictions. Within a few years, around a dozen or more states were enforcing near-total bans, mostly in the South and Midwest.

The years since: courts, ballots and pills

The campaigners' warnings came partly true and partly ran into a strong counter-reaction:

  • Voters pushed back. In August 2022, voters in conservative Kansas rejected a constitutional amendment that would have removed abortion protections. Measures protecting abortion rights later passed in states including Michigan, California, Vermont and Ohio, and Kentucky and Montana voters also rejected restrictions.
  • Travel and telehealth grew. As before 1973, many women crossed state lines. Medication abortion, often prescribed by telehealth, made up 63% of US abortions by 2023.
  • Medical risk became a central issue. Reports of women in states with bans facing delayed care during pregnancy complications, including deaths in Texas investigated by journalists, became part of the national debate.
  • Public opinion shifted. National polls showed support for legal abortion rising in the year after the ruling.

Why their voices still matter

The women who fought in the 1960s and 1970s are living witnesses to a time that most Americans under 60 have never known. Whatever one's view of abortion, their accounts are a valuable historical record of what the law meant in practice, especially for poorer women and women of colour, who had the fewest options. Beal's argument in 2022 was the same one she made in 1969: that reproductive rights cannot be separated from questions of race and class.

Sources: Wikipedia: Frances M. Beal; Wikipedia: Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization; Wikipedia: Roe v. Wade; Wikipedia: Abortion in the United States. Interviews originally reported by The Guardian (8 May 2022).

COMMENTS