Rogozin vs Musk: The 2022 Starlink Threat Explained

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2022-05-09.

Roscosmos Chief Rogozin Threatens Elon Musk Over Starlink in Ukraine

In early May 2022, Dmitry Rogozin, then head of Russia's space agency Roscosmos, publicly accused Elon Musk of supplying Starlink satellite internet equipment to Ukrainian fighters, including the Azov regiment, during the siege of Mariupol. In a social media post he warned Musk that he would have to answer for it. Musk replied on Twitter with a dark joke about dying "under mysterious circumstances", and the exchange went viral around the world.

Behind the war of words sat a real story: how a private satellite network became one of Ukraine's most important tools for staying connected under Russian attack.

What Rogozin claimed

Rogozin based his accusation on what he said was the testimony of a captured Ukrainian officer, the chief of staff of the 36th Marine Brigade. According to Rogozin, the officer said Starlink ground terminals had been flown into besieged Mariupol by military helicopters and handed to Azov fighters and Ukrainian marines.

From there he argued that Musk was helping arm what he called "fascist forces" with military communications. He ended with a personal warning that Musk would have to answer in an adult way for this. The testimony of a prisoner held by the other side cannot be independently checked, and Rogozin offered no further evidence; his post documents his position rather than proving how the equipment was used.

Musk's response

Musk answered on Twitter, a company he had agreed to buy in April 2022 and took over that October. He first wrote that the word "Nazi" did not mean what Rogozin seemed to think. Shortly afterwards he added a tweet that drew far more attention: If I die under mysterious circumstances, it's been nice knowin' ya.

The line was read by many as a joke, by others as a pointed reference to the deaths of several Russian business figures in unexplained circumstances that spring. Musk's mother, Maye Musk, publicly told him off for it, and he replied that he would do his best to stay alive.

The two men already had a history. In 2014, when the US was still paying Russia to fly its astronauts to the International Space Station, Rogozin mocked the idea that America could find another way and suggested it try a trampoline. After SpaceX's first crewed flight in 2020, Musk quipped that "the trampoline is working".

How Starlink reached Ukraine

Starlink is SpaceX's network of thousands of satellites in low Earth orbit. Users connect through a flat, pizza-box-sized dish that can be set up anywhere with a clear view of the sky, which makes it hard for an attacker to cut off by destroying cables or phone masts.

Two days after the invasion began in February 2022, Ukraine's digital minister, Mykhailo Fedorov, appealed to Musk on Twitter, and Musk switched the service on for Ukraine within hours. Terminals soon followed. By April 2022 about 5,000 had been delivered, some funded by SpaceX and some through the US aid agency USAID, and many more arrived later. Musk said his engineers had fought off Russian attempts to jam the signal.

Starlink quickly became vital for Ukraine's government, hospitals, energy companies and armed forces, who use it for communications and to coordinate drones and artillery. It also became a source of friction. In late 2022 Musk complained that the service was costing SpaceX about $20 million a month, and SpaceX restricted its use for some offensive weapons. In June 2023 the US Department of Defense signed a contract to pay for Starlink services in Ukraine.

Azov and the battle for Mariupol

The Azov unit began in May 2014 as a volunteer battalion fighting Russian-backed separatists in Donbas. Its founders had ties to far-right groups, and those origins remain controversial. In November 2014 it was brought under state control as part of Ukraine's National Guard, and some analysts say it has since moved away from its political roots, while critics argue the links persist. Russian officials routinely use its history to justify describing the invasion as a fight against "Nazis".

In spring 2022 Azov was at the heart of the defence of Mariupol and made a final stand in the vast Azovstal steelworks. Shortly after Rogozin's post, in mid-May, the remaining defenders surrendered on orders from Kyiv. In 2024 the US State Department said it had found no evidence of rights violations by the unit and lifted a ban on it receiving US weapons.

Rogozin's other warnings

Rogozin was known for provocative statements long before the war. A Russian nationalist politician, he had served as ambassador to NATO from 2008 to 2011 and as deputy prime minister for the defence industry before taking over Roscosmos in 2018. He had been under Western sanctions since 2014.

Around the same time as the Musk exchange, he claimed Russia could destroy NATO countries within half an hour in a nuclear war, called the conflict a war for the right of Russia to exist, and described Ukrainian soldiers as NATO's "expendable cannon fodder". These statements echoed official Kremlin messaging rather than revealing new facts.

What happened next

Rogozin did not stay in charge of Russia's space programme for long. On 15 July 2022, two months after the exchange, President Vladimir Putin dismissed him and appointed Yuri Borisov, a deputy prime minister and former deputy defence minister, to lead Roscosmos. His tenure had been marked by threats to pull out of the International Space Station and by an ISS propaganda stunt that drew condemnation shortly before his removal.

In December 2022 Rogozin was wounded by shelling in occupied Donetsk, and in September 2023 he was appointed a senator representing the Russian-occupied part of Zaporizhzhia region. Musk, for his part, is very much alive, and Starlink remains in heavy use across Ukraine.

Sources: Daily Mail (May 2022); Wikipedia, Dmitry Rogozin; Wikipedia, Starlink; Wikipedia, Azov Brigade; Space.com, Russia dismisses space agency chief (15 July 2022).

COMMENTS