Putin's Health Rumours of 2022: The 'Two to Three Years' Claim

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2022-05-30.

A 2022 Anonymous Claim About Putin's Life Expectancy

In late May 2022 the British tabloid the Sunday Mirror published claims from an anonymous source, described as an officer of Russia's FSB security service, that Vladimir Putin had a fast-moving cancer and only two to three years to live. The claim was never backed by medical evidence, the Kremlin denied it, and Western intelligence chiefs said they saw no sign of serious illness. In May 2024, close to the end of that predicted window, Putin was sworn in for a fifth term as president.

The episode is a useful case study in how health rumours about secretive leaders spread, why they are so hard to check and how readers can judge them. Here is what was claimed, who said what, and what actually happened next.

What the anonymous source claimed

According to the Sunday Mirror, the source said Putin was suffering from a severe and rapidly progressing cancer. The report added that he had frequent headaches, that his eyesight was failing so badly that he needed prompts written in very large letters to read on television, and that his limbs shook uncontrollably. The source suggested his declining health could eventually see him eased out of power.

None of this came with documents, names or medical records. The newspaper relied entirely on the word of one unnamed person, whose position and access could not be checked independently. That does not prove the claims false, but it means they carry very little weight on their own.

A wave of rumours in spring 2022

The Mirror story was one of many. After Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, speculation about Putin's health exploded across Western and Ukrainian media.

  • Christopher Steele, the former British intelligence officer best known for the 2016 "Steele dossier", told reporters he had heard that Putin was seriously ill and that he was constantly accompanied by doctors. He speculated that people around Putin might move him into a sanatorium rather than risk an open coup.
  • Kyrylo Budanov, head of Ukraine's military intelligence, claimed in May 2022 that Putin had several serious illnesses, including cancer. As an official of a country at war with Russia, his statements also had obvious propaganda value.
  • Viewers pointed to video clips in which Putin appeared to grip a table, rock his foot or seem bloated, and some commentators suggested Parkinson's disease. A strict distancing regime during the pandemic, including the famously long table used for meetings with foreign leaders, was read by some as a sign of a weakened immune system.
  • Tabloids went further still, with one speculating that Putin might already have died and been replaced by a double.

Each new claim was quoted by other outlets, so a handful of unverified sources ended up looking like a chorus.

What the Kremlin and Western intelligence said

Russian officials flatly rejected the stories. Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov said there was no sign of illness, and Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov repeatedly denied that Putin had any medical problems.

More telling was the reaction of Russia's adversaries. US officials said they had no evidence that Putin was dying. CIA director William Burns remarked that, as far as the agency could tell, Putin was "entirely too healthy". Richard Moore, head of Britain's MI6, likewise said there was no evidence of serious illness. These agencies had every reason to welcome signs of weakness in the Kremlin, so their scepticism was significant.

What actually happened next

The prediction did not come true in the period given. Putin remained in office throughout the war, travelled abroad, held long televised press events and stood in the March 2024 presidential election. That election was tightly controlled: two anti-war candidates were barred on technical grounds, and he won by a landslide.

On 7 May 2024, he was sworn in at the Grand Kremlin Palace for a new six-year term, his fifth as president. He has served as either president or prime minister since 1999, making him Russia's longest-serving leader since Joseph Stalin. Rumours did not stop entirely; in October 2023, for example, a Telegram channel claimed he had died, which proved baseless.

Did illness drive the invasion of Ukraine?

Some commentators in 2022 argued that Putin launched the invasion because he knew he was dying and wanted to secure his legacy by taking the Donbas or more of eastern Ukraine. It is an interesting theory, but there is no evidence for it.

Historians and analysts more often point to factors that can be documented: Putin's long-stated view of Ukraine as part of Russia's historical sphere, his 2021 essay on the "historical unity" of Russians and Ukrainians, the annexation of Crimea in 2014 and the war in Donbas that followed, and his hostility to NATO and EU ties with Kyiv. Explaining a war through a secret diagnosis is tempting because it is simple, but the documented record is far richer.

Why leaders' health is so hard to verify

Authoritarian governments treat a leader's health as a state secret, because any sign of weakness can unsettle elites and invite rivals. Soviet leaders including Leonid Brezhnev, Yuri Andropov and Konstantin Chernenko were seriously ill long before the public was told. That history makes rumours believable, but it also means anyone can make claims that are impossible to disprove in the short term.

Video "evidence" adds another layer. Body language read from a few seconds of footage can be explained by posture, camera angles, medication for minor conditions or simply age. Doctors generally avoid diagnosing someone they have never examined, and for good reason.

How to read a health rumour about a world leader

  • Count the real sources. Ten articles quoting the same anonymous person are still one source.
  • Look at who benefits. Wartime governments, opposition groups and tabloids all have reasons to amplify such stories.
  • Check for specifics that can be tested. Precise dates of surgery, named hospitals or named doctors can later be confirmed or refuted; vague claims cannot.
  • Note what intelligence services say on record. They will not reveal everything, but outright scepticism from a hostile agency is meaningful.
  • Revisit predictions later. The "two to three years" forecast is a reminder that dramatic claims are rarely followed up when they fail.

Sources: Wikipedia: Health of Vladimir Putin; Al Jazeera, 7 May 2024: Russia's Vladimir Putin sworn in as president for record fifth term. Original claims reported by the Sunday Mirror and The Independent, May 2022.

COMMENTS