Originally published 2022-05-16.

On 16 May 2022, the UK Home Office minister Rachel Maclean told Sky News that, over the long term, people could protect themselves from the cost-of-living crisis by taking on more hours or moving to a better paid job
. The remark, made as energy bills and food prices were rising faster than they had in decades, set off a wave of criticism from opposition MPs, charities and viewers who said it showed how out of touch the government was with families already working as hard as they could.
Below is what she actually said, why it caused such anger, what the crisis looked like in numbers, and whether "more hours or a better job" is realistic advice for households under pressure.
What Rachel Maclean said
Maclean, the Conservative MP for Redditch, was then Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Safeguarding at the Home Office. She was doing the government's morning media round and was asked by the presenter Kay Burley how ordinary people should cope with soaring bills.
Her answer had two parts. First, she said the government's long-term focus was on growing the economy, and that people could better protect themselves by working extra hours or moving into better-paid work. Second, when pressed, she accepted that this would not suit every family. She pointed to job centres and work coaches as the support available to help people find more hours or better jobs, and she acknowledged that the advice would not work for someone already holding down three jobs.
Burley's challenge was the one many viewers shared: some people were already working every hour they could and still relying on food banks.
Rachel Maclean: People can protect themselves better from the cost of living crisis "by taking on more hours or moving to a better job"#KayBurley: Some people are working 3 jobs, they're working every hour they can... but they're still having to go to food banks#BBCBreakfast pic.twitter.com/CP5dslPHK9
— Haggis_UK 🇬🇧 🇪🇺 (@Haggis_UK) May 16, 2022
Why the remarks caused anger
Critics said the comments put the burden of a national crisis on individual workers. Many of the households hardest hit were already in work, often in low-paid jobs with little control over their hours, and a significant share of people using food banks were employed.
Labour's Peter Kyle, then a shadow minister, argued that telling families to work longer meant less time with their children and missed the point of government. He called the advice just disconnected from the realities of people's lives
and said ministers should be fixing the economic problems behind the crisis rather than urging people to seek promotions.
The interview also came during a run of similar comments from Conservative politicians that spring, which reinforced the impression, fairly or not, that ministers did not grasp what households were going through. Maclean's defenders said her words had been taken out of context, since she had explicitly said the advice was not for everyone.
The cost-of-living crisis in numbers
The anger made more sense against the background. From 1 April 2022, the energy regulator Ofgem raised the household energy price cap by 54%, to about £1,971 a year for a typical home. Consumer price inflation was 7% in March 2022, climbed to 9% in April and eventually peaked at 11.1% in October 2022, the highest rate in about 40 years. Forecasts at the time suggested a typical energy bill could reach £3,549 a year from October.
The effects on food and heating were severe. A Food Foundation survey in early 2022 found that one million adults in the UK had gone a whole day without eating in the previous month because they could not afford food. The Joseph Rowntree Foundation later estimated that more than three million low-income households could not afford to heat their homes. Most economists, including the Bank of England governor Andrew Bailey, said the bulk of the inflation came from global forces such as energy prices after Russia's invasion of Ukraine, though domestic factors played a part too.
What the government did next
Ten days after the interview, the Chancellor, Rishi Sunak, announced a £15 billion support package, partly funded by a £5 billion windfall tax on energy companies. It included a £400 discount on every household's energy bills, a £150 council tax rebate, and a £650 payment to around eight million of the lowest-income households.
In September 2022, under Liz Truss, the government introduced the Energy Price Guarantee, which limited a typical household's annual energy bill to about £2,500. Jeremy Hunt later extended it to April 2023. These measures did not end the crisis, but they marked a clear shift from telling people to earn more towards direct help with bills.
Is "more hours or a better job" realistic?
For some people, yes. Someone on a part-time contract who wants more hours, or a worker whose skills are in demand, may be able to raise their income by moving job, and free advice from a job centre work coach or the National Careers Service can help. In 2022 there were many vacancies in the UK, and wages in some sectors were rising.
For many others, the advice runs into hard limits:
- Childcare and caring: extra hours often mean extra childcare costs, which in the UK are among the highest in Europe.
- Health and disability: people with long-term illness or disabilities may not be able to work longer.
- Benefit withdrawal: for workers on Universal Credit, each extra pound earned above the work allowance reduces the benefit by 55p, so the gain from more hours is smaller than it looks.
- Timing: a better job takes time to find, while energy and food bills arrive every month.
That is why the wording "over the long term" mattered. As a long-term goal, higher productivity and better-paid work are what most economists would recommend. As an answer to a family struggling with this month's bills, it sounded dismissive.
If you are struggling with living costs, Citizens Advice, StepChange and your local council can help check which benefits, grants and payment plans you may be entitled to.
What happened to Rachel Maclean afterwards
Maclean resigned from her Home Office post on 6 July 2022, one of the many ministers who quit in the final days of Boris Johnson's government. She returned under Liz Truss as Minister of State for Victims and Vulnerability, became a Conservative Party vice-chair, and served as Minister of State for Housing and Planning from February to November 2023. Her time as MP for Redditch ended at the 2024 general election, and in February 2025 she became a life peer as Baroness Maclean of Redditch.
Her Sky News answer remains one of the most remembered moments of the 2022 cost-of-living debate, largely because it captured a disagreement that ran through that whole period: whether rising prices were a problem for individuals to solve through their own effort, or one that required governments to step in.
Sources: Based on reporting by Sky News; background from Wikipedia on Rachel Maclean and the UK cost-of-living crisis.

COMMENTS