Originally published 2022-05-05.
On the evening of 2 May 2022, Politico published something that had almost never happened in the modern history of the US Supreme Court: a full draft of a majority opinion before the case was decided. Written by Justice Samuel Alito and circulated among the justices in February, the draft argued that Roe v. Wade had been wrong from the start and should be overturned, handing abortion policy back to the states.
The short answer to what happened next: the leak was real, the outcome it predicted came true, and the person who leaked it has never been publicly identified. On 24 June 2022 the Court issued its final ruling in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, ending the federal constitutional right to abortion that had stood for almost half a century.

What the leaked draft said
The case before the Court concerned Mississippi’s 2018 Gestational Age Act, which banned most abortions after 15 weeks of pregnancy. It allowed exceptions for medical emergencies and severe fetal abnormalities, but none for rape or incest. Under Roe and the later Planned Parenthood v. Casey ruling, a ban that early should have been struck down.
Alito’s draft went much further than simply upholding Mississippi’s law. It concluded that the Constitution says nothing about abortion, that no such right is deeply rooted in the nation’s history and traditions, and that both Roe and Casey should be overruled in full. In practice, that meant each state would decide for itself whether abortion was legal.
The day after publication, the Court confirmed that the document was authentic, while stressing that it was not a final decision and that votes can shift before an opinion is released. Chief Justice John Roberts called the leak a betrayal and said, “The work of the Court will not be affected in any way.”
Why Roe v. Wade mattered for so long
Roe v. Wade was decided on 22 January 1973 by a 7–2 vote, with Justice Harry Blackmun writing for the majority. The plaintiff, known as “Jane Roe”, was Norma McCorvey, a Texas woman challenging her state’s near-total ban.
One common misunderstanding is worth correcting: Roe was never a federal law passed by Congress. It was a court ruling that read a right to privacy into the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, and held that this privacy covered a woman’s decision to end a pregnancy. The right was not absolute. Roe set out a trimester framework, and in 1992 Casey replaced it with a test asking whether a law placed an undue burden on access before fetal viability, around 24 weeks.
Because the right rested on a court interpretation rather than legislation, a later Court with a different majority could reverse it. That is exactly what the leaked draft proposed.
How the Court’s majority changed
Justices serve for life, so the balance of the Court shifts only when a seat opens. Between 2017 and 2020 President Donald Trump appointed three justices: Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett. Barrett’s appointment followed the death of liberal Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg in September 2020, and it gave conservatives a 6–3 majority.
The final vote in Dobbs reflected that new balance. The judgment upholding Mississippi’s law was 6–3. On the bigger question of overturning Roe, five justices joined Alito’s opinion: Clarence Thomas, Gorsuch, Kavanaugh and Barrett. Roberts agreed with upholding the 15-week ban but did not join the decision to overturn Roe entirely. Justices Stephen Breyer, Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan dissented together.
So the leaked draft’s headline count, five votes to end Roe, turned out to be accurate.
Trigger laws and what changed for women
Thirteen states had already passed so-called trigger laws, written to ban most abortions automatically, or soon after, once Roe fell. Others had older bans still on the books, or new restrictions waiting in the courts. At the time of the leak, Planned Parenthood estimated that around 36 million women of reproductive age lived in states likely to ban abortion if Roe were overturned. That was an advocacy group’s projection rather than an official count, but it gave a sense of the scale.
The projection proved broadly right. Within months of Dobbs, most of the trigger bans were in force, and clinics in much of the South and Midwest closed or moved across state lines. By 2026, 21 states ban abortion or restrict it earlier than the Roe standard allowed. As of April 2023, the Kaiser Family Foundation counted 15 states with early bans that had no exception for rape or incest.
The picture is not one-directional. Several states, through legislation or ballot measures, have moved to protect abortion access, and the issue has become a central question in state and federal elections. If you are trying to understand what applies where you live, the most reliable route is your state health department or a local clinic, since laws and court rulings continue to change.
How political leaders reacted
President Joe Biden responded to the leak by warning that the reasoning in the draft could reach beyond abortion. Speaking to reporters on 4 May, he argued that other rights built on the same idea of privacy, including same-sex marriage, could be questioned next. He also described Trump-aligned Republicans in blunt terms, saying “this Maga crowd is really the most extreme political organization that exists in American history”, as reported by the Guardian.
Vice President Kamala Harris spoke the same week at an event for EMILY’s List, a group that backs Democratic women candidates. Her remarks framed the issue as one of personal freedom: “How dare they tell a woman what she can do and cannot do with her own body?”
Biden’s concern was not invented. In his own concurring opinion in Dobbs, Justice Thomas wrote that the Court should reconsider other precedents built on the same reasoning. Alito’s majority opinion, by contrast, said that nothing in the ruling should be read to cast doubt on precedents that do not involve abortion. Congress later passed the Respect for Marriage Act in December 2022, giving same-sex marriage protection in federal law.
Was the leaker ever found?
No. Roberts ordered the Court’s Marshal, Gail Curley, to investigate. Her report, released on 19 January 2023, said investigators could not identify the person responsible to the standard of more likely than not. At least 91 people had access to the draft: 82 staff members and the nine justices. Investigators interviewed at least 97 Court employees.
The inquiry drew criticism of its own. Former Justice Department inspector general Glenn Fine and others questioned whether a Court official could investigate independently, and whether the justices themselves faced the same scrutiny as their clerks and staff.
Why the leak still matters
The leak changed how Americans experienced a major ruling. Instead of waking up to a decision in June, the public had seven weeks to react, protest and organise. Some legal scholars argued that the leak damaged trust inside the Court; others felt it gave voters advance notice of a decision that would reshape their lives.
For anyone looking back, the key facts are simple. The draft was genuine, its conclusion became law on 24 June 2022, and abortion in the United States is now governed state by state.
Sources: Original reporting by BBC News and Politico; Wikipedia: Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization; Wikipedia: Roe v. Wade; Ballotpedia News, 24 June 2022; and The Guardian (4 May 2022), which first reported the Biden remarks quoted above.

COMMENTS