The Unburnable Handmaid's Tale: Atwood's Fireproof Book Against Bans

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2022-05-24.

Margaret Atwood's 'Unburnable' Handmaid's Tale Edition Protested Censorship

In May 2022, Penguin Random House and Margaret Atwood unveiled a one-off, fireproof edition of The Handmaid's Tale, built to survive the flames as a protest against book bans. In the promotional video, Atwood, then 82, turns a flamethrower on the book and fails to burn it. The single copy sold at Sotheby's in New York on 7 June 2022 for $130,000, and the money went to PEN America's work against book censorship.

The stunt was short, but it landed at a moment when school book removals in the United States were rising fast and the Supreme Court was about to overturn Roe v. Wade. Here is how the book was made, why this novel was chosen, and what the numbers on book bans actually show.

How do you make a book that will not burn?

The edition looks and opens like an ordinary hardback, but almost nothing in it is paper. According to its designers, the pages are made of heat-resistant aluminium, the binding is stitched with nickel wire, and the covers use stainless steel of the kind used in aerospace manufacturing. The text is printed with special inks said to withstand temperatures up to about 1,200°C (2,200°F). A Sotheby's spokesperson remarked that, despite all that metal, it still feels like a regular book in the hand.

The publisher presented the object as a symbol: a copy of a frequently challenged book designed to protect the story and stand against censorship. Atwood joked in the video that she never expected to try to burn one of her own books, and to fail.

It is worth being clear about what the stunt does and does not prove. A book that survives a flamethrower is a piece of theatre, not a solution; most banned books are never burned at all. They are quietly removed from school shelves or reading lists. The fireproof copy works because it makes that quieter process visible.

Why The Handmaid's Tale?

Atwood's novel was first published in Canada in April 1985, which made it 37 years old at the time of the auction. It is narrated by Offred, a woman in the Republic of Gilead, a theocratic dictatorship that has replaced the United States. In Gilead, women are forbidden to read, and fertile women are assigned to the households of powerful Commanders to bear children for their wives. “Offred” is not her real name but a label meaning she belongs to a man called Fred.

The book won Canada's Governor General's Award in 1985 and was the first winner of the Arthur C. Clarke Award in 1987. Interest surged again with the Hulu television series starring Elisabeth Moss, which premiered in 2017 and won eight Emmy Awards in its first season, and with Atwood's sequel, The Testaments, which shared the 2019 Booker Prize.

It has also been challenged for decades. The American Library Association ranked it 37th among the most frequently challenged books of 1990–2000, and seventh in 2019. Complaints usually cite sexual content, profanity or hostility to religion. Atwood has rejected the religion argument: reportedly responding to one challenge, she noted that “nowhere in the book is the regime identified as Christian,” and added that her novel is much less interested in sex than parts of the Bible.

What the book-ban numbers showed in 2022

The edition appeared weeks after PEN America published its report Banned in the USA, covering July 2021 to March 2022. In those nine months the organisation counted 1,586 individual book bans affecting 1,145 different titles, in 86 school districts across 26 states, with more than two million students enrolled in the affected schools.

Two patterns stood out. About a third of the banned titles had LGBTQ+ themes or characters, and around 41 percent featured protagonists or major characters of colour. And 41 percent of the bans were linked to directives from state officials or elected lawmakers, rather than to an individual parent's complaint going through the normal review process. Organised “parents' rights” groups also pushed for removals in many districts.

PEN America stressed that its figures only include cases reported to it or covered in the media, so the real number is likely higher. Its later counts suggest the trend accelerated in the following school years.

A practical point: “ban” covers several different things. A book may be challenged (someone asks for removal), restricted (kept but limited to certain ages), removed pending review, or removed outright. The US Constitution's First Amendment limits government censorship, and in Board of Education v. Pico (1982) a plurality of the Supreme Court said school boards may not remove library books simply because they dislike the ideas in them, but the rules in practice vary widely from district to district.

Atwood, Roe v. Wade and the novel's new relevance

The auction came between two political shocks. In early May 2022 a leaked draft opinion showed the Supreme Court was preparing to overturn Roe v. Wade, the 1973 ruling that had protected abortion rights nationwide. The final decision, Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization, followed on 24 June 2022.

Atwood responded with an essay in The Atlantic in May 2022, under the headline that she had invented Gilead and the Supreme Court was making it real. She noted that the Constitution also does not mention women, who could not vote nationally until 1920, and argued that if the state controls a woman's reproduction, her body in effect belongs to the state. She also recalled Buck v. Bell (1927), the ruling that allowed forced sterilisation, as a reminder that state power over reproduction can cut both ways.

Whatever one's view on abortion, the timing explains why a forty-year-old novel suddenly read like commentary on the news, and why its publisher chose it for the fireproof edition.

Other books caught in the debate

The Handmaid's Tale was not alone. Lists of titles removed from American schools in 2021–2022 included classics such as Toni Morrison's The Bluest Eye, and an illustrated adaptation of The Diary of Anne Frank, the record of a Jewish girl hiding from the Nazis, was later pulled from some school libraries as well. Supporters of removals say they are protecting children from age-inappropriate material; opponents argue that parents can already opt their own children out, and that removing a book for everyone takes the choice away from other families.

For readers, the useful takeaway is simple: if you want to know whether a book was banned, look for the specific action, the place and the reason. A challenge in one district is very different from a statewide prohibition.

What the auction achieved

Sotheby's had estimated the book at around $100,000. It sold for $130,000, with the proceeds going to PEN America's campaigns. PEN's chief executive, Suzanne Nossel, described the book as an emblem of shared resolve to protect books, stories and ideas.

The money was modest by publishing standards, but the image of an author unable to burn her own novel travelled worldwide. Its message was the one Atwood has made for years: stories can outlast the people who try to destroy them, as long as readers keep finding and sharing them.

Sources: NPR via GPB, 7 June 2022: fireproof copy auctioned for $130,000; PEN America: Banned in the USA; Wikipedia: The Handmaid's Tale; Margaret Atwood's Atlantic essay, republished by History News Network; original report by The Guardian, 24 May 2022.

COMMENTS