Trophy Hunters Kill Two of Africa's Biggest Tuskers in Botswana

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2022-04-21.

Trophy Hunters Kill Two of Africa’s Largest Tuskers in Botswana

In the spring of 2022, two of the biggest-tusked bull elephants left in Africa were shot by licensed trophy hunters in northern Botswana. One was a so-called "100-pounder", an elephant whose tusks each weigh around 100 lb (45 kg) or more; the other carried tusks of roughly 90 lb. The hunts were legal under Botswana's hunting rules, so this was not poaching, but they triggered sharp criticism from conservationists who say the last great tuskers are worth far more alive.

This article explains who killed the elephants, how big they really were, why their deaths mattered beyond two individual animals, and how Botswana came to allow elephant hunting again.

What happened in northern Botswana

The news broke on 13 April 2022, when Africa Geographic, a conservation and safari travel company, reported that both bulls had been killed in the preceding weeks. The 100-pounder was taken in hunting concession NG13, guided by professional hunter Leon Kachelhoffer. The second bull was hunted by the outfitter Johan Calitz Safaris; no concession was named for that hunt.

The identity and nationality of the paying clients were not made public. When Africa Geographic contacted Kachelhoffer, he reportedly said he was too busy to talk and gave no further comment.

How big were the tusks?

For the larger bull, Africa Geographic published precise measurements:

  • First tusk: about 105.6 lb (48 kg), 238.8 cm long, 49.5 cm around at the base;
  • Second tusk: about 95.7 lb (43.5 kg), 223.5 cm long, also 49.5 cm around;
  • Combined ivory: roughly 201 lb (91.5 kg).

The weight of the second elephant's tusks, around 90 lb each, was an estimate shared on the hunters' forum AfricaHunting.com rather than a verified measurement.

The same forum's contributors described the 100-pounder as the largest elephant known to have been hunted since 1996. That claim comes from the hunting community itself and has not been independently confirmed, but it gives a sense of how rare such animals have become.

A tusk is an elongated incisor tooth made mostly of dentine, a hard mix of collagen and mineral. Tusk size is partly inherited, which is why biologists worry when the biggest-tusked males are removed before or during their prime breeding years.

Why one hunt location drew particular anger

Concession NG13 lies inside a migration corridor of the Kavango-Zambezi Transfrontier Conservation Area (KAZA), a five-country conservation zone shared by Angola, Botswana, Namibia, Zambia and Zimbabwe. The idea behind KAZA is to keep routes open so that elephants can spread out from crowded northern Botswana into the large areas of good habitat in Angola and Zambia, easing pressure on Botswana's farmers and ecosystems.

Africa Geographic CEO Simon Espley argued that hunting inside the corridor turns it into what researchers call a "fear zone", a place elephants learn to avoid. If elephants stop using the corridor, they stay in Botswana, which works against the very goal of reducing human-elephant conflict. In his words, the location "pegs NG13 as a 'fear zone'" for elephants.

Espley also questioned the population argument often made for hunting. Botswana issues licences for only a few hundred elephants a year at most, a tiny fraction of the population. Taking such a small number does nothing to thin the herds, he said, but choosing the biggest tuskers as trophies is likely "to hasten the disappearance of tuskers from the African landscape."

Trophy hunting is not poaching

Early headlines about these deaths spoke of "ivory poachers", which was wrong. Poaching is illegal killing, usually to sell ivory on the black market. Trophy hunting is a licensed activity in which a foreign client pays large sums, often tens of thousands of dollars, to shoot an animal under a government quota and, where import rules allow, take the tusks home.

The distinction matters because the two raise different questions. Poaching is a crime problem tied to organised trafficking. Trophy hunting is a policy choice that governments defend on economic and community grounds and that critics oppose on ethical and ecological ones.

International commercial trade in African elephant ivory has been banned under the CITES convention since 1990, after the continent's elephant population fell from about 1.3 million to roughly 600,000 in a decade of intense poaching. Illegal demand, much of it historically from East Asian markets, has kept poaching going; studies found the annual poaching death rate peaked above 10% around 2011 before falling below 4% by 2017.

Why Botswana allows elephant hunting again

Botswana holds the largest elephant population in the world. Aerial counts put northern Botswana's elephants at about 80,000 in 1996 and around 129,000 by 2014. The country is also known for strong anti-poaching work, with armed rangers and the military protecting wildlife areas, although poaching has not been eliminated.

In 2014 then-President Ian Khama suspended trophy hunting on public land, citing declining wildlife numbers. His successor, Mokgweetsi Masisi, ordered a review, and in May 2019 the government lifted the suspension. Officials pointed to growing elephant numbers and rising conflict with people: elephants trample crops, damage water points and occasionally kill villagers. The government said it would issue fewer than 400 elephant hunting licences a year, build fences and pay more compensation for wildlife damage.

The decision divided opinion sharply. Kenyan conservationist Paula Kahumbu called it horrific, and European wildlife groups condemned it, while hunting organisations such as Safari Club International welcomed it. Many rural communities in Botswana supported the change, arguing that hunting revenue and meat help people who live alongside dangerous animals.

What the loss of big tuskers means

Elephants with 100-lb tusks were once fairly common; today only a small number are thought to survive across the continent, mainly in protected areas such as Kenya's Tsavo ecosystem. Older bulls are not just trophies. They often lead younger males, help keep their behaviour in check and pass on genes for large tusks.

Supporters of regulated hunting say well-managed quotas fund conservation and give communities a reason to tolerate elephants. Critics answer that photographic tourism can earn more from a living tusker over many years than a single hunt does, and that the deliberate targeting of the biggest males is a form of selection that may, over time, shrink tusk size in the population.

For anyone wanting to help, the practical options are straightforward: support credible conservation groups that work with local communities, choose responsible wildlife tourism, and never buy ivory, antique or otherwise, which keeps demand alive.

Sources: Africa Geographic, 13 April 2022: Trophy hunters kill two of Africa's biggest elephants in Botswana; NPR, 23 May 2019: Botswana lifts its ban on elephant hunting; Wikipedia: Elephant ivory.

COMMENTS