Originally published 2022-03-28.
In late March 2022, a month into Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine, Japan sharply protested a Russian military exercise on the Kuril Islands, including the four southern islands that Japan claims as its Northern Territories. Russia's Eastern Military District said more than 3,000 troops and hundreds of pieces of equipment took part; one report put the number at close to 3,500. Tokyo called the build-up unacceptable. The drills came just days after Moscow walked out of decades-long peace treaty talks with Japan in retaliation for Japanese sanctions, and they fed a wider debate in Japan about how to defend itself in an increasingly tense neighbourhood.

The drills and Japan's response
Russia announced the exercise on Friday 25 March 2022. According to the Interfax news agency, the troops practised repelling an amphibious landing, shooting down aircraft carrying enemy forces and testing fire control for anti-tank guided missiles. The equipment reported by IBTimes included Su-35 fighter jets, Mi-8 helicopters, T-72B3 tanks, Orlan-10 drones and the Bastion-P coastal missile system. The district did not say exactly where on the island chain the drills took place, but Japanese media reported that they included territory claimed by Tokyo.
Japan's Chief Cabinet Secretary, Hirokazu Matsuno, the government's chief spokesperson, responded on Monday 28 March. He said:
"Russia's military expansion in the Northern Territories is unacceptable."
Earlier that month, Defence Minister Nobuo Kishi had already voiced concern that Russian forces were becoming more active around Japan while the war in Ukraine continued, and said Tokyo would keep a close and tense watch. Japanese defence officials had been tracking Russian warships passing through straits near Japan in the preceding weeks; some analysts suggested at the time that certain vessels might be heading towards the Ukraine theatre, though that was not confirmed.
Which islands are disputed?
The Kurils are a volcanic chain stretching about 1,200 kilometres from Hokkaido, Japan's northernmost main island, to Russia's Kamchatka Peninsula. The dispute concerns only the southernmost part. From largest to smallest, the islands are:
- Etorofu (Iturup in Russian)
- Kunashiri (Kunashir)
- Shikotan
- the Habomai islets
Russia administers them as part of Sakhalin region and calls them the Southern Kurils. Japan calls them the Northern Territories and regards them as illegally occupied. The closest, the Habomai group, lies only a few kilometres off the coast of Hokkaido.
How the dispute began
The roots go back to the 19th century. The 1855 Treaty of Shimoda drew the border between Etorofu and the neighbouring island of Urup, leaving the four southern islands with Japan and the islands further north with Russia.
That changed at the end of the Second World War. The Soviet Union declared war on Japan in August 1945 and seized the Kurils between 18 August and 3 September, after Japan had announced its surrender on 15 August and around the time it formally signed it on 2 September. The roughly 17,000 Japanese residents of the southern islands were expelled over the following years.
The two countries never signed a peace treaty. In the 1956 Soviet–Japanese Joint Declaration they ended the state of war, and Moscow agreed to hand over Shikotan and the Habomai islets once a treaty was concluded. Each side has interpreted that promise differently ever since, and the fate of the two larger islands was left open. Talks have come and gone for decades, with periods of real optimism, notably during Shinzo Abe's many meetings with Vladimir Putin, but no deal.
Why March 2022 was a turning point
After Russia invaded Ukraine on 24 February 2022, Japan joined the United States and the European Union in imposing sweeping sanctions, including freezing central bank assets and targeting Russian banks and officials. Moscow responded by putting Japan on its list of "unfriendly" countries.
On 21 March 2022 Russia's Foreign Ministry announced that it was pulling out of peace treaty negotiations with Japan and freezing joint economic projects on the islands, explicitly citing the sanctions. Japan's government reacted angrily. The drills that followed four days later were widely read in Tokyo as a deliberate signal. As James Brown, a Temple University specialist on Russia–Japan relations, told IBTimes, Russia has limited economic tools to hit back, so it uses military ones instead.
Russia had already been strengthening its forces on the islands for several years, deploying coastal missile systems and building barracks and other infrastructure. The 2022 exercise underlined that, whatever happens at the negotiating table, Moscow intends to keep the islands firmly under its control.
Japan's tough neighbourhood and the nuclear debate
The episode also highlighted a broader security problem for Japan. It sits close to three nuclear-armed states it has difficult relations with: Russia; China, with which it has its own territorial dispute over the Senkaku Islands and which declined to condemn the invasion of Ukraine; and North Korea, which regularly fires missiles into the seas around Japan.
On 27 February 2022 former prime minister Shinzo Abe said on television that Japan should not treat discussion of "nuclear sharing" as taboo. Under such arrangements, used by several NATO members, US nuclear weapons are stationed on an ally's territory and can be delivered by that ally's aircraft in wartime. Some members of the governing Liberal Democratic Party took up the idea. The next day, Prime Minister Fumio Kishida rejected it in parliament as unacceptable, citing Japan's three non-nuclear principles.
Law or policy? A clarification
It is often said that Japan has "outlawed" nuclear weapons. Strictly, the three non-nuclear principles, not producing, not possessing and not allowing nuclear weapons onto Japanese territory, are a government policy adopted in the late 1960s and endorsed by parliament, not a law. Japan is also bound by the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty, and Article 9 of its post-war constitution renounces war as a means of settling disputes. As the only country ever attacked with atomic bombs, at Hiroshima and Nagasaki in August 1945, Japan has deep public opposition to nuclear weapons, which is why Abe's comments caused such a stir.
What it means
The March 2022 drills did not change who controls the islands; Russia has held them since 1945. What they changed was the mood. The hope, kept alive for decades, that a peace treaty might bring at least two islands back to Japan faded sharply, and Japan moved further towards building up its own defences, including a commitment later in 2022 to raise defence spending significantly. For former island residents and their descendants, many now elderly, the freeze also ended visa-free visits and grave-visiting trips that had been possible under earlier agreements.
Sources: IBTimes (28 March 2022); Cyprus Mail / Reuters (26 March 2022); Wikipedia: Kuril Islands dispute; Anadolu Agency (28 February 2022).

COMMENTS