Does Your Life Flash Before Your Eyes When You Die? The EEG Study

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2022-02-23.

A 2022 Case Report of Brain Activity Around Death

Does your life really flash before your eyes when you die? Science cannot say for sure, but a 2022 case report gave researchers a rare look at what one human brain was doing in the moments around death. An 87-year-old patient happened to be wired to an EEG when his heart stopped, and the recording showed a burst of brain rhythms, especially gamma waves, that in healthy people are linked to memory, dreaming and focused attention. The authors suggested this might reflect a last replay of memories. They were also clear that it comes from a single, very ill patient and cannot tell us what he actually experienced.

Here is what was recorded, how to read it, and how it fits with what is known about near-death experiences.

The patient and the accidental recording

The study, titled "Enhanced Interplay of Neuronal Coherence and Coupling in the Dying Human Brain", was published on 22 February 2022 in Frontiers in Aging Neuroscience. It was led by neurosurgeon Ajmal Zemmar, then at the University of Louisville, with Raul Vicente of the University of Tartu in Estonia and an international team.

The patient was an 87-year-old man who had fallen and suffered bleeding on both sides of the brain (bilateral subdural haematomas). He had surgery to relieve pressure, then developed seizures. Doctors placed him on continuous electroencephalography (EEG), the cap of electrodes that records the brain's electrical activity, to track the seizures and guide treatment with anti-seizure drugs.

During that monitoring his heart went into a dangerous rhythm and then stopped. He had a do-not-resuscitate order, so no attempt was made to restart it. Because the EEG was still running, the team had about 900 seconds, or 15 minutes, of brain activity around the time of death. They looked most closely at the half-minute on either side of the moment his heart stopped.

Earlier retellings said the man was being monitored "for his epilepsy" and "died of a heart attack". More precisely, the seizures followed his head injury and surgery, and he died of cardiac arrest after his heart rhythm failed.

What the brain waves showed

Brain activity is often described in frequency bands: slow delta and theta waves, alpha and beta in the middle, and fast gamma waves. In the final recording the researchers saw changes in all of them. The most talked-about finding was in gamma, which became relatively stronger around the time of death and stayed higher after the heart stopped than it had been earlier in the recording.

They also found that gamma activity was coordinated with slower alpha and theta rhythms, a pattern called cross-frequency coupling. In healthy brains, that kind of coupling is linked to processes such as memory retrieval, dreaming and meditation.

Zemmar offered an interpretation that made headlines: "Through generating oscillations involved in memory retrieval, the brain may be playing a last recall of important life events just before we die." He added that the findings raise questions about exactly when life ends, which matters for decisions such as the timing of organ donation.

Why one recording cannot prove a life review

The authors listed the limits themselves, and they are important:

  • One patient. A single case cannot be generalised to everyone who dies.
  • An injured brain. The man had bleeding, swelling and repeated seizures, and he was taking anti-seizure medication. Any of these could affect the EEG.
  • No normal baseline. As the paper puts it, "no normal activity was recorded with the EEG that can serve as a true baseline for comparison."
  • No report from the patient. Gamma waves are associated with memory, but they also appear in many other kinds of brain activity. Without the person describing what he experienced, the link to a life review is a hypothesis.

So the fair summary is "a brain pattern consistent with memory recall was seen in one dying patient", not "science proves your life flashes before your eyes".

How it fits with near-death experiences

The idea of a "life review" did not start with this study. In his 1975 book Life After Life, psychiatrist Raymond Moody listed a panoramic review of one's life among the common features people described after coming close to death. Many later accounts include it, although far from all.

Near-death experiences themselves are less common than popular culture suggests. In the AWARE study led by Sam Parnia, published in 2014, researchers followed more than 2,000 cardiac arrests in hospitals. Of the 101 survivors who completed detailed interviews, about 9 percent had experiences that met the criteria for a near-death experience.

Scientists have proposed several explanations, from lack of oxygen and changes in brain chemistry to the "dying brain" hypothesis, which holds that the experiences are produced by a brain under extreme stress. The 2022 recording fits more easily with that last group of ideas, because it suggests the brain can stay organised and active for a short time as circulation fails.

Other research on the dying brain

Similar surges of gamma activity had been reported earlier in rats observed under controlled conditions around cardiac arrest, which led the 2022 authors to suggest the response may be shared across species. In 2023, a University of Michigan team led by Jimo Borjigin published a study in PNAS on patients who died in hospital. They reported that gamma activity rose in areas at the back of the brain linked to conscious visual experience, and that these areas became more connected with frontal regions as death approached.

Together, these studies have changed how researchers think about the last minutes of life. The brain does not simply switch off the moment the heart stops. There can be a brief, organised burst of activity. What that activity feels like from the inside is still unknown.

What it might mean for families

Zemmar spoke about one comforting possibility: that a loved one whose eyes are closed may be replaying some of the best moments of their life. Nobody can promise that, and it would be wrong to present it as fact. But the research does gently support something many hospice workers already encourage: speaking to, touching and staying with a dying person, because parts of the brain may remain active for longer than we assumed.

If you have questions about end-of-life care for someone close to you, the best people to ask are their doctors and the palliative care team. For now, the honest scientific answer to whether our life flashes before our eyes is: possibly, for some people, and researchers are only beginning to measure it.

Sources: Vicente, Zemmar et al. (2022), Frontiers in Aging Neuroscience; Scimex: Does our life flash before our eyes during death?; Wikipedia: Near-death experience. This story was first reported in English by Futurism.

COMMENTS