Sumela Monastery DJ Video: Why Greece Protested in 2022

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2022-02-11.

Greece's 2022 Objection to Filming at Sumela Monastery

In early February 2022, a video filmed inside the Sumela Monastery, the cliffside Orthodox Christian monastery of Panagia Soumela near Trabzon in northeastern Turkey, showed a DJ playing electronic music while a small group danced in its courtyard. On 7 February 2022, Greece's Ministry of Foreign Affairs formally objected, calling the footage "a desecration of this Monument" and asking Turkish authorities to stop anything similar from happening again. The people behind the video said it was a tourism promotion shot with official permission. Here is what happened, why it touched such a nerve, and what the monastery means to Greeks and Orthodox Christians.

What the video showed and who made it

The clip circulated on social media and showed a DJ set and dancing in the stone courtyard beneath the monastery's frescoed walls. Turkish outlet Duvar English named DJ Ahmet Şenterzi as the performer and reported, citing a Turkish news post, that a crew of around 30 people had filmed a promotional film while the site was closed to visitors. According to that reporting, the shoot was approved by the Trabzon Governor's Office and the provincial culture and tourism directorate.

Euronews reported that the makers defended the video, saying it was meant to promote Sumela as a destination and that the authorities had given permission. Turkish officials were not immediately available for comment when the story broke, and no formal Turkish government reply was reported in the coverage we reviewed.

Greece's objection in its own words

The Greek Foreign Ministry's statement made three main points. First, it described the images as offensive and a desecration of the monument. Second, it questioned why permission had been given at all, saying that, in its view, the monastery opens only for pilgrims. Its words were: "It is surprising that the permit was given to the band, as the Monastery of Panagia Soumela opens only for pilgrims."

Third, the ministry linked the episode to what it called a wider series of actions by Turkish authorities affecting heritage sites, without listing specific examples in the statement. It urged Ankara "to do their utmost to prevent such acts from being repeated." The statement was reported by Reuters, Euronews, Duvar English and Greek media.

The ministry's description of access is its own position. In practice Sumela functions as a state museum that admits tourists, and Orthodox services there require special permission. That tension, between a sacred place for one community and a visitor attraction run by the state, is at the heart of the dispute.

A monastery carved into a cliff

Sumela sits roughly 1,200 metres above sea level on a sheer rock face in the Pontic Mountains, overlooking the forested Altındere valley in the Maçka district of Trabzon Province, inside what is now Altındere National Park. Its exact founding date is unknown. Turkey's Ministry of Culture and Tourism places its origins around AD 386, in the reign of the Byzantine emperor Theodosius I.

Tradition holds that two monks from Athens, Barnabas and Sophronios, founded it after finding an icon of the Virgin Mary said to have been painted by the Apostle Luke. That icon, known as the Panagia Soumela, made the monastery one of the most important pilgrimage centres of the Black Sea Greeks for many centuries. The name is often explained as coming from the Greek for "black mountain", though other origins have been suggested.

Why Sumela matters so much to Pontic Greeks

The monastery's emotional weight comes from history. Greeks lived along Turkey's Black Sea coast, the region known as Pontus, for well over two thousand years. Between 1912 and 1923, Ottoman Greeks, including the Pontic Greeks, were subjected to deportations, death marches and massacres now recognised by Greece and by many historians as the Greek genocide. Estimates of Greek deaths in Pontus alone range from about 300,000 to 360,000. Greece's parliament recognised the genocide in Pontus in 1994 and set 19 May as a day of remembrance.

The 1923 population exchange between Greece and Turkey, agreed at Lausanne, formalised the departure of the surviving Orthodox population. The monks left Sumela, and the monastery was abandoned. In 1930, refugees founded a new Panagia Soumela monastery on Mount Vermion near Kastania, close to Veria in northern Greece, and some of the original treasures were taken there. It remains a major pilgrimage site for families with Pontic roots.

For many of those families, the original Sumela is not simply a beautiful ruin. It is a link to ancestral homes they were forced to leave, which is why a dance video there was received so differently in Greece than it may have been intended in Trabzon.

Museum, restoration and the return of the liturgy

Today Sumela is a museum overseen by Turkey's Culture Ministry, and the Turkish government has funded restoration work. The site was closed on 22 September 2015 because of rock falls and safety concerns, and it reopened to visitors on 18 May 2019 after major repairs.

Since 15 August 2010, Turkey has allowed an Orthodox Divine Liturgy at the monastery on the Feast of the Dormition of the Virgin Mary, the first regular services there since 1923. Attendance on that day is limited and requires a special pass arranged through the Ecumenical Patriarchate. The liturgy was also held in 2020 and 2021. Sumela has been on UNESCO's World Heritage Tentative List since 2000, which means it has been put forward as a candidate but has not been inscribed.

Reading the 2022 dispute in context

Three separate questions are easy to blur together. One is the site's legal status: a state museum and a candidate for World Heritage listing. Another is the question of who gave permission for the filming and on what basis, which Turkish reporting attributed to provincial authorities. The third is whether such use is appropriate at a place that is sacred to Orthodox Christians, which is what the Greek objection was really about.

The episode came at a time when the conversion of Hagia Sophia in Istanbul from a museum back into a mosque in 2020 had already sharpened Greek and Orthodox concern about how former Christian sites in Turkey are treated. Whatever one thinks of the intentions behind the video, the reaction shows how much meaning a single place can carry for people whose families once prayed there.

If you plan to visit, check opening times in advance, dress modestly, and remember that for many visitors this is a place of worship and memory as well as a spectacular view.

Sources: Euronews: Greece decries Turkey for allowing DJ performance at sacred Sumela monastery; Duvar English: Greece protests to Turkey over DJ performance at Sümela Monastery; Wikipedia: Sumela Monastery; Wikipedia: Greek genocide. Originally reported by Reuters.

COMMENTS