Originally published 2022-02-02.
On the afternoon of Thursday 27 January 2022, Landon Eastep, a 37-year-old Nashville man, was shot dead on the shoulder of Interstate 65 after a standoff of about 30 minutes with police. He had been holding a box cutter. When he pulled a shiny metal cylinder from his pocket and took what police described as a shooting stance, nine officers opened fire. The object was not a gun. In September 2022 the local district attorney ruled the shooting legally justified, and no officer was charged.
Body-camera footage released by Metro Nashville Police within hours made the case widely known and fiercely debated. Early reports, including the original version of this story, said twelve officers had fired; official accounts settled on nine officers, who between them struck Eastep twelve times.
How the standoff began
According to the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation (TBI), the encounter started around 2pm, when a Tennessee Highway Patrol trooper noticed Eastep on the shoulder of the northbound interstate near mile marker 76, in the south of Nashville. Other reports say he was sitting on a guardrail and that the trooper stopped to offer him a ride.
The conversation turned tense and Eastep produced a box cutter. The trooper called for help. An off-duty officer from the Mount Juliet Police Department, on his way home, stopped to assist, and officers from the Metropolitan Nashville Police Department (MNPD) and more state troopers followed. Traffic was halted in both directions and a police helicopter circled overhead.
Thirty minutes of negotiation
For about half an hour, officers tried to talk Eastep into putting the blade down. He held the box cutter in his left hand and kept his right hand in his pocket. The off-duty Mount Juliet officer did much of the talking. On the body-camera audio he can be heard telling Eastep, "Whatever you're worried about, we can fix it," urging him to accept help and to go home safely that day. He also pointed out that he had stopped without even wearing a protective vest.
By then a ring of officers had surrounded Eastep with weapons drawn. The appeals continued, but he did not drop the box cutter or show his right hand.
The final seconds
Police say Eastep shifted his stance, then pulled a silver, cylindrical object from his pocket and pointed it towards officers. MNPD spokesman Don Aaron said nine officers fired "after Eastep took a stance as if he had a firearm." Eastep died at the scene. No officers were hurt.
Six of the officers who fired were from Metro Nashville police; the others were state troopers and the Mount Juliet officer. The MNPD officers were placed on routine administrative assignment while investigations ran. Nashville's then mayor, John Cooper, said he was disturbed by the shooting.
Warning: the two videos below contain graphic footage of the shooting.
The investigation and the decision not to charge
At the request of District Attorney General Glenn Funk, the TBI opened an independent investigation, interviewing witnesses, gathering evidence and passing its findings to his office. An autopsy released in July 2022 found that Eastep had been hit by twelve shots.
On 16 September 2022, Funk announced that none of the officers would face criminal charges. After reviewing the TBI file and the body-camera footage, he concluded that Eastep's actions "were designed to cause officers to perceive an immediate threat," that the officers reasonably believed they were in danger, and that every shot fired was legally justified.
Eastep's family disagreed. Their lawyer, David McKenzie, argued that excessive force had been used, that some shots came after a cease-fire was called, and that department policies were not followed. Another attorney for the family had compared the shooting to a firing squad soon after it happened. The family continued pressing for records through the courts.
Why the case divided opinion
Supporters of the officers point to the facts that shaped the decision: Eastep was armed with a blade, refused repeated commands for half an hour, kept one hand hidden and then produced a metal object and pointed it as if it were a gun. Officers in that moment have a fraction of a second to decide, and the law judges their actions by what a reasonable officer would perceive at the time, not by what is learned later.
Critics focus on other aspects. Eastep was standing some distance from officers and was not advancing on anyone. Nine officers fired, which many viewers saw as out of proportion. And to many, the behaviour on the tape, sitting by a highway with a blade, ignoring offers of help, then mimicking a gun, looked like a person in crisis. Some experts call this pattern "suicide by cop", where a distressed person deliberately provokes officers into using lethal force; whether that applied here cannot be known for certain.
Police, crisis and de-escalation
The Eastep case is part of a wider US debate about how police respond to people in mental or emotional crisis. Several things have shifted in recent years:
- Crisis lines. In July 2022, six months after this shooting, the United States launched 988, a three-digit number for suicide and mental-health crises, intended partly to route such calls to trained counsellors rather than armed officers.
- Co-responder teams. Many cities, Nashville among them, have experimented with pairing mental-health clinicians with police on calls involving people in distress.
- De-escalation training. Departments increasingly train officers to slow encounters down, create distance and use time, as the Mount Juliet officer tried to do here.
- "Contagious fire". When one officer fires, others often fire too. Researchers and police trainers have studied this effect as a factor in shootings involving many officers and many rounds.
None of these changes guarantee a different outcome when someone is armed and unresponsive. But the case shows how even a long, patient attempt to talk someone down can end in seconds.
If you or someone you know is in crisis
If you are in the United States and you or someone close to you is struggling, you can call or text 988 to reach the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline at any time. Elsewhere, local emergency services or a doctor can help find support.
Sources: TBI Newsroom, 27 January 2022; FOX6 News, January 2022; WSMV, 16 September 2022. Body-camera footage released by the Metropolitan Nashville Police Department.

COMMENTS