Surgeon Sex and Patient Outcomes: What the JAMA Surgery Study Found

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2022-01-12.

Study Linked Patient-Surgeon Sex Concordance With Surgical Outcomes

Does the sex of your surgeon affect how you recover? A large Canadian study published in JAMA Surgery in December 2021 found that women operated on by male surgeons had somewhat worse results than women operated on by female surgeons, including 32% higher odds of dying within 30 days. Men did equally well with surgeons of either sex. The study shows an association, not proof of cause, and the absolute differences for any single patient are small.

Here is what the researchers measured, how to read the numbers, what might explain the gap, and what it means if you are facing an operation.

What the study looked at

The paper, titled "Association of Surgeon-Patient Sex Concordance With Postoperative Outcomes", was led by urologic surgeon Christopher Wallis and anaesthesiologist Angela Jerath, with colleagues at Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre, the University Health Network and the University of Toronto.

They used Ontario's health records to follow 1,320,108 adults treated by 2,937 surgeons between 2007 and 2019. Each patient had one of 21 common operations spread across a range of surgical specialties, and the list included both planned and emergency procedures.

The researchers compared patients whose surgeon was the same sex as them ("concordant") with patients whose surgeon was the opposite sex ("discordant"). They then tracked whether patients died, were readmitted or had complications within 30 days, adjusting for factors such as age, other illnesses, the hospital and the individual surgeon.

The main findings

Across the whole group, about 14.9% of patients had at least one of the three adverse outcomes. When patient and surgeon were of different sexes, the adjusted odds of a bad outcome were 7% higher overall.

The gap came almost entirely from one combination:

  • Women treated by male surgeons had 15% higher odds of the combined adverse outcome than women treated by female surgeons, and, according to the research team, 32% higher odds of death within 30 days. Complications were also more common.
  • Men treated by female surgeons showed no meaningful difference compared with men treated by male surgeons.

Some early news reports attributed the study to two University of Florida surgeons, Amalia Cochran and Andrea Riner. In fact they wrote an invited commentary that JAMA Surgery published alongside the paper; the research itself was carried out by the Ontario team.

How to read "32% more likely to die"

Percentages like this sound alarming, so context helps. A relative increase tells you how much higher one risk is compared with another, not how high the risk is to begin with.

Death within 30 days of the common operations in the study is rare. If a baseline risk were, say, 1 in 200, a 32% relative increase would raise it to roughly 1 in 150. That difference matters a great deal across a whole health system with millions of operations, yet it is still a small change for one person.

The design also matters. This was an observational study using existing records, not a trial in which patients were randomly assigned to surgeons. Researchers adjusted for many factors, but unmeasured differences between patients or cases could still influence the results.

Why might the gap exist?

The authors were clear that they did not know the cause. Wallis said a difference in technical skill was unlikely, since male and female surgeons receive the same training. The possibilities they and other experts raised include:

  • Implicit bias. Unconscious assumptions can shape how seriously symptoms are taken.
  • Communication and trust. Patients may share worries more openly with some doctors than others, and doctors may explain risks differently.
  • Clinical judgement. Decisions about when to operate, how to manage pain or when to investigate a new symptom can vary between doctors.
  • Missed early warning signs. Wallis suggested that symptoms reported by women might be under-appreciated, allowing complications to become more serious before they are treated.

In their commentary, Cochran and Riner argued that hospitals should look at outcomes by patient identity: "Metrics of surgeon outcomes with regard to patient identity should be developed and incorporated into performance reviews." They also noted that the experience of transgender and gender-nonconforming patients has barely been studied.

Earlier research points the same way

This was not the first study to find such a pattern. In 2018, researchers Brad Greenwood, Seth Carnahan and Laura Huang published a study in PNAS of heart attack patients admitted to Florida hospitals. Women treated by male emergency doctors were less likely to survive than women treated by female doctors, while men's survival was similar either way. The gap shrank when male doctors worked alongside more female colleagues or had treated more female patients, which suggests that experience and team culture can help.

Patterns like these are one reason medical schools now put more emphasis on communication, sex and gender differences in disease, and recognising bias.

Women in surgery today

The make-up of the profession is changing. According to the Canadian Institute for Health Information, about 51% of family physicians and 41% of specialists in Canada were women in 2024. Surgery remains one of the fields where women are less well represented, especially in senior roles and certain specialties.

A more mixed workforce is not only a fairness issue. The Florida findings suggest that working in diverse teams may improve care for everyone.

What this means for patients

The study is not a reason to refuse a surgeon because of his or her sex. Experience with your specific procedure, the hospital's results and a good working relationship all matter far more for an individual outcome, and in many places patients cannot choose a surgeon at all.

The researchers' practical advice was simple: build a trusting relationship with your surgeon and feel free to raise questions and concerns before and after the operation. If something feels wrong during recovery, say so clearly and ask for it to be checked. If you have questions about a planned operation, talk to your doctor.

Sources: Wallis et al., JAMA Surgery (2021/2022); Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre: Behind the research; Greenwood, Carnahan and Huang, PNAS (2018); CIHI: Physicians in Canada.

COMMENTS