How San Francisco Moved the 139-Year-Old Englander House

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2022-09-27.

Moving a Victorian House Through San Francisco

On Sunday 21 February 2021, a two-storey Victorian house built in 1882 left its lot at 807 Franklin Street in San Francisco and travelled on hydraulic dollies to a new foundation at 635 Fulton Street, about seven blocks away. The trip took most of a day, drew hundreds of onlookers and cost its owner roughly $400,000. It was done so the old house could survive while a new apartment building rose on its former site.

What happened on moving day

City transport crews arrived around 4 a.m. to clear the way, and the move itself got under way at about 7 a.m. The house, known locally as the Englander House, rolled north on Franklin, swung past Opera Plaza at Golden Gate Avenue, turned onto Laguna Street and crossed McAllister Street before reaching Fulton Street before noon.

Getting it there was slow work. Top speed was about one mile per hour. Around 40 tyres fitted with hydraulic lifts carried the weight, and at the end the building was transferred from the truck's wheels onto another set of rollers, then pushed and pulled into position. It was finally slid onto its new foundation at around 5:30 p.m.

The tightest moment came early, when one corner of the house caught on a light pole as the crew tried to turn off Franklin Street. Workers had to free it before the convoy could go on.


Why the owner moved the house instead of demolishing it

The building belongs to Tim Brown, a San Francisco property broker who reportedly bought it in 2013 for about $2.6 million. His Franklin Street lot was approved for a 48-unit, eight-storey apartment building, and the roughly 5,170-square-foot Victorian stood in the way.

Rather than tear it down, Brown chose to relocate it to a vacant spot on Fulton Street next to a historic former mortuary. Before the move, later additions that had no historic value, including a garage, were demolished so only the original structure travelled. At the new address, the Victorian and the mortuary building are being converted into 17 homes, according to Hoodline. Some earlier reports gave a figure of seven units for the house alone.

The result is that one plot gains dozens of new flats, while the old house is reused for housing too. In a city with severe housing shortages and strong attachment to its historic streetscape, that combination helped the plan win support.

What it takes to move a whole building through a city

Lifting a house is only part of the job. The San Francisco Chronicle reported that about $200,000 of the cost went on permits and city fees, and another $200,000 on the physical move. Veteran house mover Phil Joy told the paper that more than a dozen city departments had to sign off. His summary of the trade was short: "Move a house, save a tree."

Along the route, crews:

  • removed parking meters and relocated street signs and traffic lights;
  • trimmed a street tree so the roofline could pass;
  • took down overhead wires used by Muni buses on McAllister Street and set up detours;
  • timed the work for an early Sunday, when traffic is lightest.

The downhill start on Franklin Street was a particular worry, because a heavy load on a slope is hard to control. That is why years of planning, surveys and engineering went into a trip that lasted a single day.

San Francisco's long habit of moving houses

Relocating buildings is not new in San Francisco. In the 1970s, dozens of Victorians were trucked out of the Western Addition during redevelopment, and many still stand on new lots across the city. Large moves became rare after that, and the Englander House trip was described in coverage at the time as the first of its kind in roughly half a century.

Preservation groups welcomed the decision. Fiona McDougall of the Victorian Alliance of San Francisco told the Chronicle that these homes "are part of the fabric of San Francisco." Her group argues that saving old buildings keeps the character of neighbourhoods while still allowing growth around them.

The San Francisco Historical Society filmed the day and has been turning the footage into a short documentary, so future residents can see how the house came to sit on Fulton Street.

How people reacted

Clips of a full-sized Victorian gliding past office blocks spread quickly on social media. Most of the reactions were light-hearted. One widely shared comment wondered: "I wonder what the ghosts are thinking." Others joked about San Francisco crime or grumbled about road closures on the way to work. For many viewers, the scene was a reminder of how unusual it is to see a city reshape itself in such a literal way.

Is moving a historic house worth it?

A move like this is expensive, and it is not right for every building. It tends to make sense when:

  • the house has historic or architectural value that would be lost if it were demolished;
  • there is a suitable site nearby, ideally on a flat, wide route;
  • the land it leaves can be used for something more valuable, such as new housing;
  • the owner has time to gather permits and coordinate with utilities and transport agencies.

Brick or stone buildings are far harder to move than wooden ones, which is one reason timber Victorians are relocated more often. For the Englander House, the numbers worked: a historic home was saved, and the city gained room for more housing on the old lot.

Sources: Hoodline: House parade, moving day for the Englander House (February 2021); San Francisco Chronicle: A 139-year-old S.F. Victorian is getting moved; reader comments as collected by Positive Outlooks; video via YouTube.

COMMENTS