First published January 27, 2022.
On Sunday, 23 January 2022, a 29-year-old tourist from the Netherlands was detained at the former Auschwitz concentration camp in southern Poland after making a Nazi salute beneath the camp's "Arbeit macht frei" gate while her husband photographed her. Museum guards stopped the couple, police took them to a station in Oświęcim, and prosecutors fined the woman the same afternoon after she pleaded guilty.
The case drew attention far beyond Poland because it happened just days before International Holocaust Remembrance Day, and at a time when Holocaust comparisons were appearing in arguments over Covid-19 rules. This page explains what happened, why the gesture is a crime in Poland, what the gate represents, and how visitors can approach the memorial with the respect it demands.
What happened at the gate
According to Bartosz Izdebski, a police spokesman for the Małopolska region, guards from the Auschwitz-Birkenau Memorial spotted the woman raising her arm in a Hitler salute at the entrance while her 30-year-old husband took the picture. Both were taken to the police station. The husband was questioned as a witness, and the case went straight to prosecutors in Oświęcim.
The woman admitted the act and accepted a fine. The spokesman said she explained her behaviour as a stupid joke
and denied holding Nazi sympathies. The amount of the fine was not made public. The regional police announced the detention on social media, and the story was carried by the Polish news agency PAP, Polish Radio and the Associated Press.
Why a gesture is a crime in Poland
Polish law makes public promotion of fascism or another totalitarian system an offence punishable by a fine, restriction of liberty or up to two years in prison. Performing a Nazi salute at Auschwitz, in public and in front of a camera, falls squarely within that rule, which is why a confession and fine could follow within hours.
This was not the first case of its kind. In 2013 two Turkish students received a suspended sentence and a fine for making the same gesture at the same gate. Several other European countries, notably Germany and Austria, also restrict Nazi symbols and gestures, although the exact laws and penalties differ from country to country.
What the "Arbeit macht frei" gate stands for
The words above the gate mean "work sets you free". For prisoners arriving at Auschwitz I, they were a cruel lie, and the entrance became known as the Gate of Death. Nazi Germany set up the camp in 1940 in occupied Poland and expanded it into a complex that included the extermination camp at Birkenau.
Of roughly 1.3 million people deported to Auschwitz, at least 1.1 million were murdered. Historians estimate the victims included about 960,000 Jews, most of them killed in gas chambers on arrival, around 74,000 non-Jewish Poles, about 21,000 Roma, some 15,000 Soviet prisoners of war and up to 15,000 others.
Soviet troops liberated the camp on 27 January 1945. That date has been marked since 2005 as International Holocaust Remembrance Day. Poland opened the Auschwitz-Birkenau State Museum on the site in 1947, and UNESCO added it to the World Heritage List in 1979.
Holocaust comparisons in the pandemic debate
The incident came amid months of public statements from the Auschwitz Memorial objecting to people who compared vaccine passes and Covid restrictions to the persecution of Jews under Nazism. Badges shaped like yellow stars at anti-lockdown protests were among the examples criticised.
One high-profile case involved Warren Davidson, a Republican congressman from Ohio. On 12 January 2022 he shared an image he described as a Nazi-era health pass with the words This has been done before.
and the hashtag #DoNotComply. He followed up by listing the stages by which the Nazis moved from dehumanising Jewish people to murdering them, presenting the history as a warning about pandemic rules.
This has been done before. #DoNotComply https://t.co/6rnI83Ioga pic.twitter.com/pHeeNPVhlP
— Warren Davidson (@WarrenDavidson) January 12, 2022
(This post is no longer available on X.)
The Memorial answered that using the suffering of the regime's victims in a debate about vaccines and pandemic limits was a sad sign of moral and intellectual decline. Historians make a related point: public health measures, however contested, are not comparable to a state programme of exclusion, imprisonment and genocide, and blurring the two cheapens the memory of the dead.
How to visit Auschwitz respectfully
Very large numbers of people tour the memorial every year, and the vast majority do so with great care. A few simple points help:
- Remember it is a cemetery. The ashes of victims lie in the grounds of Birkenau. Quiet behaviour and modest dress are expected.
- Think before you photograph. Photos are allowed in most outdoor areas, but posed selfies, jokes and gestures are deeply offensive and, as this case shows, can be criminal.
- Go with a guide. Guided tours, offered in many languages, put the buildings in context and keep groups focused on the history.
- Prepare beforehand. Reading survivor testimony or a short history in advance makes the visit more meaningful, especially for teenagers.
- Allow time to reflect. Many visitors find it helps to plan a quiet hour afterwards rather than rushing on to the next stop.
Why cases like this matter
A single tourist's stunt may seem minor next to the scale of what happened at Auschwitz, but memorial staff see such incidents as a test of whether the lessons of the site are still understood. Prompt enforcement sends a clear signal that the place is not a backdrop for provocation. At the same time, the Memorial's wider message is educational: every visitor, including those who misbehave, has a chance to leave knowing more about the people who were murdered there and the ideology that made it possible.
Sources: Polish Radio (PAP), 24 January 2022; FOX 5 New York (AP), 23 January 2022; Wikipedia: Auschwitz concentration camp; earlier reporting by LADbible.

COMMENTS