Originally published 2021-12-31.
Two days before Christmas 2019, a white-bearded 65-year-old man robbed a bank in downtown Colorado Springs, Colorado. Witnesses said he then tossed cash from the bag onto the pavement, called out "Merry Christmas" and walked to a nearby coffee shop to wait for officers. Police arrested David Wayne Oliver soon afterwards, but they never confirmed the money-throwing or the festive greeting.
The story spread around the world within hours, mostly because of the suspect's Santa Claus look. Here is what the reliable reporting actually established, what remained unconfirmed, and why stories like this travel so fast.
What happened at Academy Bank
The robbery took place shortly before 12:30 p.m. on Monday 23 December 2019 at Academy Bank, 1 South Tejon Street, in the heart of downtown Colorado Springs. According to the Associated Press, the man told staff he had a weapon in his pocket and left with cash. Officers later found no evidence that he had been armed.
Outside the bank, according to witnesses, he began pulling money out of the bag and scattering it. A local man, Dion Pascale, told the TV station KKTV what he saw: "He robbed the bank, came out, threw the money all over the place." Pascale added that the man then went next door to a Starbucks and simply sat down to wait for police.
Officers arrived and took him into custody without reported injuries to anyone.
What police confirmed and what they did not
Here is where the viral version and the official record part ways. Colorado Springs Police Department spokesman Sgt. Jim Jeffcoat declined to confirm, according to the Denver Post as quoted by AP, either that money had been thrown in the air or that the suspect had shouted "Merry Christmas." The festive detail came from bystanders, not from investigators.
Police did publish a short notice on Twitter the next day, naming the suspect and sharing his booking photo:
On December 23, David Oliver was booked into the El Paso County Criminal Justice Center following a bank robbery in the 00 block of Tejon Street. Police Blotter #27498 https://t.co/CjbvRoi0Lc
— Colorado Springs Police Department (@CSPDPIO) December 24, 2019
Mugshot: David Oliver, 65 pic.twitter.com/lNCJAwS9jE
El Paso County jail records listed his bail at $10,000, with a first court appearance set for later that week. At the time of the AP report, it was not clear which charges had been formally filed.
Did people really hand the money back?
Partly. Pascale said passers-by gathered up the notes and returned them to the bank teller, which became the feel-good heart of many headlines. Police painted a less tidy picture: some of the cash had been recovered, but thousands of dollars were still missing.
Both things can be true. Some honest bystanders clearly did walk money back inside, while some of it apparently disappeared. The bank never disclosed how much had been taken in total, so the exact figure remains unknown.
Why the internet called him Santa
The combination was almost designed to go viral: a white beard, the days just before Christmas, a bag of cash spilling into the street, and a man who seemed in no hurry to escape. International outlets from the BBC to papers in Italy, Brazil and Argentina ran the story within a day or two, usually under a "Santa" headline.
Online, commenters split roughly into two camps. Some cast him as a Robin Hood figure taking from a bank and giving to the street. Others worried that a 65-year-old who robs a bank and then waits calmly for arrest might be in crisis, perhaps homeless or unwell, and looking for shelter in custody during a cold Colorado winter.
Neither theory was supported by anything police released. No motive was made public, and guessing about a stranger's mental health or housing situation from a mugshot is unfair to him. The honest answer is that we do not know why he did it.
How bank robbery is treated under US law
Bank robbery is unusual in the US because it can be prosecuted by both state and federal authorities. Most banks are insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, which brings robberies of them under federal law as well as state criminal codes. The FBI often joins local police in investigating them.
Giving the money away afterwards does not change the nature of the offence. What matters legally is the taking of money from a bank by force, threat or intimidation. Telling a teller you have a weapon, even if you do not, generally counts as intimidation. Any recovered cash, however, can affect restitution later.
Public records we checked did not report the final outcome of the case, so we are not able to say whether Oliver was convicted or what sentence, if any, he received.
Lessons for reading viral crime stories
This case is a tidy example of how a local crime becomes a global anecdote. The most shareable details came from a single eyewitness, while the people with the fullest information, the police, said less. Headlines then rounded "witness says he shouted Merry Christmas" up to "Santa robs bank and gives cash away."
A few habits help when the next story like this lands in your feed:
- Check who is speaking. Is a detail confirmed by police or a court, or does it come from one bystander?
- Look for the date. This story kept circulating years later as if it were new.
- Notice what is missing. Motive, charges and outcome are often unknown at first.
- Be kind to the people involved. A suspect is still a real person, and speculation about health or poverty can follow someone for years.
The Colorado Springs robbery remains a strange, memorable pre-Christmas moment. It is just not quite the heart-warming Santa fable that the most-shared versions made it.
Sources: Associated Press via Khaosod English, 27 December 2019; KKTV 11 News; Colorado Springs Police Department on Twitter; BBC News.

COMMENTS