Pope Francis Admitted Priests and Bishops Abused Nuns: What We Know

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published December 20, 2021.

Pope Francis Acknowledged That Clergy Abused Nuns

Yes. In February 2019 Pope Francis publicly confirmed that Catholic priests, and even some bishops, had sexually abused religious sisters, and he said he believed the problem had not stopped. It was the first time a pope had spoken openly about the abuse of nuns by clergy, and it came after decades in which reports on the subject had stayed largely inside church offices.

This piece explains what Francis actually said, which cases he was referring to, what had been known before, and what the Church did, and did not do, in the years that followed.

What Pope Francis said, and when

The remarks came on 5 February 2019, during the in-flight press conference on the papal plane returning to Rome from Abu Dhabi. A reporter asked about an article in the Vatican's own women's magazine describing the abuse of nuns. Francis did not dodge the question. According to the Associated Press, he answered: "It is true ... there have been priests and even bishops who have done this."

He added that the Church was working on the problem and that it was probably continuing, because awareness alone does not end abuse. He also said he was committed to doing more.

Francis pointed to one specific precedent. His predecessor, Benedict XVI, had dissolved a small women's religious community in 2005 because what Francis described as a form of slavery, including sexual slavery, had taken hold there, imposed by clerics or by the founder. The Pope did not name the group. The Vatican spokesman at the time, Alessandro Gisotti, later identified it as the Contemplative Sisters of Saint-Jean, a small French community linked to the Saint-Jean family of religious orders.

The date matters. The comments were made in 2019, not in December 2021 when this story first circulated widely on social media. Older news often resurfaces as if it were new, so it is worth checking when a quote was first reported.

The magazine article that prompted the question

The question on the plane was triggered by Donne Chiesa Mondo ("Women Church World"), a monthly supplement of the Vatican newspaper L'Osservatore Romano. Its founding editor, the historian Lucetta Scaraffia, had written that nuns had been abused by clergy and that some had been pushed into abortions or had given birth to children their fathers would not recognise.

Scaraffia argued that unless church leaders stopped looking away, nothing would change for women in the Church. The AP summarised her warning that the oppression of women in the Church "will never change" if the scandal kept being ignored.

A few weeks later, in March 2019, Scaraffia and the magazine's mostly female editorial board resigned. They said they were being placed under closer male control by the newspaper's new leadership and felt their independence was being undermined. The Vatican disputed that account, but the episode showed how sensitive the subject remained.

This was not a new problem

Church authorities had been warned long before 2019. In the 1990s, religious sisters working in Africa, including the medical missionary Maura O'Donohue, wrote internal reports for Church leaders describing priests who sought out nuns for sex, in some cases because they assumed nuns were free of HIV. Those reports reached the Vatican but drew little public action until journalists published them years later.

In 2018 an Associated Press investigation found cases of clergy abusing nuns in Europe, Africa, Asia and South America. The reporters described the problem as global and pervasive, and found that many sisters stayed silent because they feared retaliation, depended on clergy for their positions, or worried about damaging the Church. Nuns in Chile and India also spoke out publicly that year.

The International Union of Superiors General (UISG), which represents the leaders of hundreds of thousands of Catholic sisters worldwide, issued a statement in November 2018 condemning what it called a culture of silence and secrecy and urging sisters to report abuse to church and civil authorities.

A case that drew global attention: Kerala

One of the most widely followed cases came from India. A nun in Kerala accused Bishop Franco Mulakkal of Jalandhar of raping her repeatedly during visits to her convent between 2014 and 2016. He was arrested in 2018 and charged with rape, illegal confinement and intimidation, and the Vatican temporarily relieved him of his duties. In January 2022 a trial court acquitted him. The nun appealed to the Kerala High Court, and in June 2023 Pope Francis accepted Mulakkal's resignation as bishop. The case highlighted how hard such allegations can be to prove, and how isolated complainants can become inside their own communities.

Why abuse of nuns stays hidden

Researchers and sisters who have spoken publicly point to several reasons the abuse of adult women in religious life has been slow to surface:

  • Power imbalance. Priests often act as confessors, spiritual directors or employers for communities of sisters. Saying no, or reporting, can carry real costs.
  • Dependence. Sisters, especially in poorer regions, may rely on a diocese for housing, work, visas or education.
  • Blame and shame. Adult victims have often been treated as partners in a "relationship" rather than as people abused by someone with authority over them.
  • Protecting the institution. As with child abuse, the instinct to avoid scandal frequently outweighed concern for victims.

Church law itself was part of the problem. For a long time, sexual offences against adults were treated mainly as violations of a priest's vow of celibacy, not as abuse, unless the victim was a minor.

What changed after 2019

Acknowledging a problem is not the same as solving it, but some concrete steps did follow. In May 2019, three months after the flight from Abu Dhabi, Francis issued Vos estis lux mundi, a church law requiring clergy and members of religious orders to report suspected abuse and cover-ups to church authorities. Importantly for nuns, it covers sexual acts with adults that are forced through violence, threats or the abuse of authority, and it allows bishops to be investigated for covering up. In 2023 the rules were made permanent.

The law has limits that critics point out. Reports go to church authorities rather than automatically to police, though any obligations under national law still apply. Survivors' groups argue that enforcement has been uneven and that outcomes are rarely made public.

The wider abuse crisis, with the facts checked

The abuse of nuns is one part of a much larger crisis. In October 2021 an independent commission in France, chaired by Jean-Marc Sauvé, estimated that about 216,000 children had been sexually abused by Catholic priests and other clergy since 1950. The figure rose to about 330,000 when abuse by lay people working for the Church was included. The commission estimated the number of abusive clergy at roughly 3,000, higher than the "over 2,000" figure that circulated in early coverage.

Some social media posts linked this story to the unmarked graves reported at former residential schools in Canada in 2021. Those findings, based mainly on ground-penetrating radar, are serious and important, but they identify possible burial sites rather than confirmed killings, and they should be discussed on their own evidence rather than folded into an unrelated story.

Where to get help

Anyone affected by abuse in a religious setting can contact police, a local sexual-assault support service or a survivors' network. Many dioceses now publish reporting contacts, but survivors are not required to go through the Church first. If the experience is affecting your health, talk to a doctor or a qualified counsellor.

Sources: GBH News / Associated Press, 5 February 2019; Reuters, February 2019; The Mind Unleashed (original report); Wikipedia: Vos estis lux mundi; Wikipedia: Catholic Church sexual abuse cases in France; BreakingNews.ie / AP, 1 June 2023.

COMMENTS