Dog Ace Lies on the Grave of His Owner, Will Warner, 22

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-12-13.

A Dog Photographed at Its Owner's Grave

In 2021 a photograph from Tennessee moved people around the world: a black-and-white dog named Ace, reported to be a border collie, lying stretched out on the fresh grave of his owner, 22-year-old Will Warner. Will's mother, Christy West Warner, shared the picture on Facebook, and the family said Ace kept going back to the grave after the funeral, as if he knew exactly where his friend was.

Behind the image is a family tragedy, and a question many pet owners ask when they see pictures like this: do dogs really grieve, and what do they understand about death? Here is what is known about Will and Ace, and what research says about mourning in dogs.

Who Will Warner was

James William Warner, known as Will, grew up in a farming family in Tennessee. His family raised chickens for Tyson Foods, and he spent his childhood helping with row crops and cattle, surrounded by working dogs. His father is James Robert Warner, his brother is Mason, and his uncle, Todd Warner, is a member of the Tennessee House of Representatives.

Relatives described Will as outgoing, friendly and full of life. His mother told The Tennessean in August 2021 that losing him felt like an out-of-body experience and that her "whole world was broken into a million pieces". Among all the dogs on the farm, Ace was the one Will was proudest of.

What happened to him

Will died in the summer of 2021 in circumstances police treated as a suspected homicide. According to reports at the time, a 25-year-old man, described as the son of a judge, was arrested after an alert was issued for him. By the time Will's body was returned to his family it was badly decomposed, and the burial had to take place without delay. His mother said the family had been robbed of any chance to say a proper goodbye. Full details of the case were not public when the photo spread, and this article does not name the suspect, who had not been convicted at the time of the reports.

The photo of Ace at the grave

After the burial, Christy posted the picture of Ace lying on the newly dug soil. The family said he returned again and again and was reluctant to leave. For a grieving family, the image said what words could not: the loss was felt by everyone who loved Will, including his dog.

It is worth being careful about what the photo shows. We see a dog lying on a grave; we cannot see what he is thinking. Dogs have an extraordinary sense of smell, and a grave dug days earlier carries the scent of the soil, the funeral and the people who stood there, possibly including Will's family and belongings. Ace may also have been drawn to the place where his family kept gathering. None of that makes the moment less touching. It simply means the most honest description is that Ace behaved in a way that looked like grief.

Do dogs grieve? What researchers say

Scientists who study animal emotion increasingly accept that many animals show changes that resemble mourning. Anthropologist Barbara J. King, one of the best-known writers on the topic, lists dogs among the domestic animals in which mourning-like behaviour has been observed. Typical signs include:

  • eating less or losing interest in food,
  • sleeping more, or sleeping at unusual times,
  • searching for the missing person or animal, waiting at doors or favourite spots,
  • becoming quieter, more clingy, or withdrawn,
  • losing interest in play.

What researchers cannot say is whether dogs understand death as a permanent end in the way adults do. Their reaction may be closer to the stress of a sudden absence and a broken routine. Either way, the distress is real, and the people around the dog are often grieving at the same time, which dogs are very good at noticing.

Famous loyal dogs, and the doubts about them

Ace's story recalls two dogs whose loyalty became legend.

Hachikō, an Akita in Tokyo, used to meet his owner, university professor Hidesaburō Ueno, at Shibuya Station every evening. Ueno died suddenly at work in May 1925, yet Hachikō kept coming to the station for about nine and a half years, until his own death in March 1935. A bronze statue of him was unveiled at the station in 1934, while he was still alive, and it remains a famous meeting point.

Greyfriars Bobby, a Skye Terrier in Edinburgh, is said to have guarded the grave of his owner, police nightwatchman John Gray, for 14 years after Gray's death in 1858. Bobby died in 1872, and a statue and drinking fountain near Greyfriars Kirkyard commemorate him. Historians question parts of the legend: the writer Jan Bondeson found more than 60 documented "graveyard dogs" in 19th-century Europe and argued that the Edinburgh story was exaggerated, even speculating that the original Bobby died around 1867 and was quietly replaced by a younger dog. The doubts do not erase the bond, but they are a reminder that famous animal stories are often polished in the retelling.

Helping a dog after its person dies

When a dog loses its main person, the family usually has to care for the animal while grieving themselves. Vets and behaviourists commonly suggest:

  • Keep the routine. Regular walks, feeding times and bedtimes give a dog a sense of stability.
  • Allow familiar things. A blanket or piece of clothing that smells of the person can comfort some dogs.
  • Offer gentle activity. Exercise, short training sessions and play help reduce stress.
  • Watch appetite and health. If a dog stops eating for more than a day or two, or seems unwell, talk to a vet, because grief-like behaviour can also hide a medical problem.
  • Be patient. Most dogs adjust over weeks or months, especially when they stay with people they know.

For the Warner family, Ace became a living link to Will. Pictures like the one Christy shared travel so far because they capture something people recognise: the loss of a young man, felt by everyone who loved him, including the dog who waited for him.

Sources: photo by Christy West Warner on Facebook; family interview in The Tennessean (15 August 2021); reporting by Positive Outlooks; Wikipedia: Grief in animals; Wikipedia: Hachikō; Wikipedia: Greyfriars Bobby.

COMMENTS