Elon Musk's Birth Rate Warning: What Population Data Shows

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-12-12.

Elon Musk Warns Falling Birth Rates Could Make Civilisation “Crumble”

In December 2021, speaking at a Wall Street Journal CEO Council event, Elon Musk said that falling birth rates were one of the biggest risks facing civilisation and that, without more children, "civilization is going to crumble". It was not a passing comment: Musk has repeated the warning many times since and describes population decline as the greatest threat humanity faces.

Is he right? The short answer is that birth rates really are falling almost everywhere, and many countries will shrink, but the world's population is still growing and is expected to keep growing for decades. Whether lower fertility leads to collapse or simply to a different kind of society is a question demographers and economists still debate.

What Musk said and why

Musk argued that the public has the problem backwards: many people, including well-educated ones, worry that the world is overpopulated, while he believes the real danger is too few births. He urged people to look at the numbers. Asked about his own family, he said he was trying to set an example; at the time he was reported to have six living children, and he has since had many more, with at least 14 children by more recent counts.

His concern centres on what happens when each generation is smaller than the last: fewer workers to support retirees, slower innovation, and in the long run shrinking societies. Supporters of this view are often called pronatalists.

What the Lancet study projected

The figures most often quoted alongside Musk's warning come from a 2020 study in The Lancet by Stein Emil Vollset and colleagues at the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation (IHME) at the University of Washington. Its reference scenario projected that:

  • world population would peak at about 9.73 billion in 2064;
  • it would then fall to about 8.79 billion by 2100, which would be the first sustained global decline in centuries;
  • the global total fertility rate would drop from 2.37 children per woman in 2017 to about 1.66 by 2100.

The authors linked the fall in fertility mainly to better access to modern contraception and more education for girls and women. They also projected that a number of countries, including Japan, Spain, Italy and South Korea, could see their populations roughly halve by the end of the century, while sub-Saharan Africa would continue to grow.

Other projections tell a different story

The Lancet forecast sits at the low end of the major projections. The United Nations, whose World Population Prospects are the most widely used figures, expects later and higher numbers:

  • UN 2022 revision: a peak of about 10.4 billion in the 2080s, then a very slight decline.
  • UN 2024 revision: about 8.2 billion people in 2024, a peak of roughly 10.3 billion in the mid-2080s, and about 10.2 billion in 2100, some 700 million fewer than the UN had projected a decade earlier.
  • Wittgenstein Centre (Vienna): a peak of about 9.4 billion around 2070, falling to roughly 9 billion by 2100.

The differences come mostly from assumptions about how quickly fertility falls in countries where it is still high, especially in Africa. All the major forecasts agree on the direction: growth is slowing and a peak is likely this century. They disagree on timing and on how steep any decline would be.

Fertility rates explained

The total fertility rate (TFR) is the average number of children a woman would have over her lifetime at current birth rates. In countries with low child mortality, a TFR of about 2.1 is considered replacement level: enough for each generation to replace itself, with the extra 0.1 covering children who die young and the slightly higher number of boys born than girls. Where child mortality is high, the replacement rate is higher.

Globally, the TFR stayed around five children per woman until the 1960s and has fallen to about 2.3 today. Some countries are far below replacement. South Korea recorded about 0.72 in 2023, the lowest of any country that year, and Taiwan, Italy, Spain and Japan are also well under 1.5. Because populations have momentum, a country can keep growing for years after fertility drops below 2.1, as large younger generations move through their childbearing years, and then decline quickly once that cohort ages.

Will civilisation "crumble"?

There are real challenges. A population with fewer young people and more older people means more pensioners for each worker, higher health and care costs, and pressure on public finances. Japan, Italy and South Korea are already dealing with shrinking towns, labour shortages and strained pension systems.

But many researchers dispute the word "collapse". A smaller population still includes billions of people, and productivity, automation, later retirement, higher participation of women and older people in work, and migration can all offset a falling workforce. Fewer people can also mean less pressure on climate, land and resources. The Lancet authors themselves framed falling fertility as largely good news, the result of women gaining education and choice, while urging governments to plan for ageing and avoid restricting reproductive rights in the name of raising birth rates.

Common myths about population decline

  • "The world population is already shrinking." No. It passed 8 billion in the early 2020s and is still rising. Declines so far are national, not global.
  • "There is one agreed forecast." Projections differ by more than a billion people for 2100. The Lancet figures are lower than the UN's.
  • "Paying people to have children fixes it." Baby bonuses and family benefits in countries such as South Korea and Hungary have had modest effects at best; affordable housing, childcare and work flexibility appear to matter as much.
  • "Overpopulation and underpopulation can't both be concerns." They can, in different places and on different timescales: rapid growth in some regions and rapid ageing in others.

Musk's warning points at a real trend, but the future it describes is one possibility among several. The more useful conversation is about how societies adapt: supporting families who want children, planning for older populations, and making the most of every working life.

Sources: Vollset et al., The Lancet (2020): Fertility, mortality, migration, and population scenarios for 195 countries; Wikipedia: Projections of population growth; Wikipedia: Total fertility rate; Wikipedia: Elon Musk; Arab News/AFP, 12 July 2024: UN says world population to peak at 10.3 billion in the 2080s. Musk's remarks as reported by LADbible.

COMMENTS