Originally published 2021-12-25.
In December 2021, Turkish and British media reported that Berfin Özek, a young woman left with badly damaged sight and facial scars after an acid attack in 2019, had married the man convicted of attacking her, Casim Ozan Çeltik. He had been sentenced to 13 years and six months in prison but was let out early under rules tied to the pandemic and changes in Turkey's sentencing law. The wedding shocked many people, including her own father. Here is what was reported, what the early release actually involved, and why cases like this are more common, and more complicated, than they first appear.
The attack and the trial
According to the reports, the attack took place in 2019 in Hatay province in southern Turkey, after Özek had ended her relationship with Çeltik, who was 23 at the time of the 2021 coverage. Before the attack he is said to have told her that if he could not have her, nobody else would. He then threw acid in her face. She was left with severe scarring and only around 30 percent of the sight in one eye.
Özek named Çeltik as her attacker and he was arrested. While he was in custody, he sent her a stream of letters apologising and declaring his love. At one point she withdrew her complaint, telling reporters that she did not want him locked up and that the two of them loved each other. After a public outcry on social media, she changed course and asked her lawyer to pursue the case again. A court in Hatay convicted Çeltik and handed down the sentence of 13 and a half years.
Why he was released early
Much of the anger online assumed that Çeltik had walked free because Özek agreed to marry him. Her lawyer, Ramazan Erdoğan, told reporters that this was not the case. His explanation, as reported by the Daily Mail, ran roughly as follows.
- Once the verdict became final, Çeltik became eligible, after a set period in a closed prison, to move to an open prison, a lower-security facility from which inmates may work or leave under conditions.
- During the COVID-19 pandemic, Turkey placed open-prison inmates on extended leave rather than keeping them inside. At the time of the wedding, that leave was set to run until 31 May 2022.
- In other words, he was outside prison because of the pandemic leave rules and the 2020 changes to how sentences are served, not because of the marriage. The lawyer stressed that the court's decision itself was final.
Turkey's 2020 sentencing reform, passed in April of that year, released or moved tens of thousands of prisoners to ease crowding during the pandemic. Women's rights groups criticised it at the time because some men convicted of violence against women benefited, while many journalists and political prisoners did not.
The wedding and her family's reaction
Çeltik reportedly proposed soon after his release, and the couple married shortly afterwards. Özek's father, Yaşar Özek, said the wedding happened without the family's knowledge and that years of fighting for his daughter had been "in vain". Özek herself, in earlier comments, had said she loved Çeltik very much and believed he loved her.
Nobody outside the couple can know exactly why she made this choice, and it would be wrong to speak for her. What can be said is that her decision fits a pattern that people who work with abuse survivors recognise, and that understanding that pattern is more useful than mocking or blaming her.
Why survivors sometimes return to the person who hurt them
Domestic violence specialists describe several reasons why victims stay with, forgive or even marry an abuser:
- Cycles of harm and apology. Abuse is often followed by intense remorse, promises and affection. That cycle can create a strong emotional bond with the abuser, sometimes described as trauma bonding.
- Isolation and dependence. Survivors of disfiguring attacks often face stigma, struggle to find work and depend heavily on others. The research summarised on acid attacks notes that many survivors lose jobs, marriage prospects and social standing.
- Social pressure. In communities where marriage is expected, and where a scarred woman may be seen as having few options, marrying the attacker can look, from the inside, like the only path to security or acceptance.
- Fear. Some survivors believe that reconciling is safer than living with the threat of further violence once an abuser is released.
None of this makes the original crime any less serious. It does explain why advocates focus on long-term support, from medical care to housing and counselling, rather than on a single court verdict.
Acid attacks and violence against women in context
An acid attack is designed to disfigure. The victim is usually targeted in the face, and survivors often face permanent scarring, loss of sight, repeated surgery and lasting psychological harm. According to Acid Survivors Trust International, around 80 percent of victims worldwide are women, and common motives include rejected relationships or marriage proposals, jealousy and revenge, exactly the pattern described in this case.
Several countries have cut the number of attacks by controlling the sale of acid and toughening penalties. Bangladesh introduced strict laws on acid sales in 2002 and has seen a steady decline, India made acid attacks a specific crime with a minimum ten-year sentence in 2013, and the United Kingdom restricted sales to under-18s and made carrying a corrosive substance in public without good reason an offence.
In Turkey, violence against women is a major public concern. Campaign groups record hundreds of killings of women every year, and the country's withdrawal from the Council of Europe's Istanbul Convention on preventing violence against women, which took effect in July 2021, a few months before this wedding, drew large protests. Cases like Özek's were widely shared by activists as an example of how leniency and social pressure can leave survivors exposed.
If you or someone you know is affected
If someone has thrown a corrosive substance on you or another person, rinse the area with large amounts of clean running water for a long time and call emergency services straight away. Do not put oil or creams on the burn, and see a doctor as soon as possible.
If you are in a relationship where you feel controlled or afraid, you are not alone. Local domestic violence helplines, women's organisations and your doctor can offer confidential advice, and in an emergency you should contact the police. Support from friends and family who listen without judgement also makes a real difference, especially when a survivor has mixed feelings about the person who hurt her.
Sources: Original reporting by the Daily Mail (December 2021, citing Turkish media); Wikipedia: Acid attack (figures from Acid Survivors Trust International and national laws).

COMMENTS