Chiapas Kindergarten Won the Plane Raffle, Then Families Fled

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-11-29.

A Chiapas Community's Reported Threats After a School Lottery Win

In September 2020 a tiny kindergarten in Chiapas, southern Mexico, won 20 million pesos (roughly US$940,000 at the time) in the national raffle linked to the sale of Mexico's presidential plane. Instead of transforming the community, the prize brought months of threats. Families from El Nacimiento, an Indigenous village in the municipality of Ocosingo, said an armed group known as Los Petules demanded the money, partly to buy weapons. After the parents refused, at least 28 families whose children attended the school fled their homes in October 2021.

Below is what happened, how the raffle worked, who Los Petules are, and why publicly named winners can become targets in regions where criminal groups operate freely.

The raffle behind the prize

Mexico's President Andrés Manuel López Obrador wanted to get rid of the luxury Boeing jet bought for his predecessors, calling it a symbol of waste. When no buyer appeared quickly, his government turned the idea into a raffle run by the Lotería Nacional. The plane itself was never handed to a winner; it was replaced with cash prizes.

The draw took place on 15 September 2020 in Mexico City. Tickets cost 500 pesos, about 4.2 million had been sold by the final days, and there were 100 winning tickets of 20 million pesos each. The federal government bought around a million tickets on behalf of public hospitals, and many prizes went to schools and health facilities. Because Mexico's state lottery publishes the names of winners for transparency, the winning institutions became publicly known.

A kindergarten in El Nacimiento wins

One winning ticket belonged to the José María Morelos y Pavón kindergarten in El Nacimiento, a small school with only around 20 pupils. Parents were put in charge of deciding how to use the money. According to InSight Crime, the plan was to put a new roof on the school and to donate 14 million pesos (about US$660,000) to the wider community.

For a rural Indigenous village in one of Mexico's poorest states, it was a life-changing sum. It also became widely known, and that turned out to be the problem.

Threats from Los Petules

Melesio López Gómez, who represented the affected families, said Los Petules wanted the prize and claimed it was needed to buy weapons. The families refused. What followed, as described in reports from November 2021, included months of death threats and attacks:

  • A resident, Marcelo Santiz López, said he was shot by a member of the gang.
  • The group allegedly took the bank card for the account that held the prize money, as well as a large amount of cash.
  • Families reportedly lost more than 250 head of cattle, along with their corn and bean harvests.

In October 2021 the families left their land. The case was first reported in Mexican media on 21 November 2021 and was then picked up by international outlets, including the BBC. Community members said they had filed complaints with the Chiapas Attorney General's Office and with prosecutors for Indigenous affairs in Ocosingo but had received no response. Displaced residents said they could not go home safely unless the group was disarmed.

Who Los Petules are

Los Petules are not a classic drug cartel. According to InSight Crime, citing the Mexican outlet La Silla Rota, the group began in the 1990s as a paramilitary unit formed to resist left-wing organisations in Chiapas, including the Zapatista Army of National Liberation (EZLN), whose 1994 uprising made Chiapas internationally famous. Over the years the group has been linked to extortion, killings, illegal land seizures, and drug and human trafficking.

Chiapas has a long history of land disputes and armed groups operating in rural areas, and forced displacement of whole communities is a recurring problem there. The El Nacimiento case fits a familiar pattern: an armed group that controls a territory treats any new source of money in it as something it can claim.

Why public winners became targets

InSight Crime's analysis pointed to a design flaw. State-run lotteries in Mexico must disclose winners to prevent fraud, while many private lotteries let winners stay anonymous. The plane raffle was one of the most publicised events of 2020, so the winners' identities were national news. Extortion had grown sharply in Mexico during the COVID-19 pandemic, and criminal groups had already targeted schools for robbery, extortion and the recruitment of children.

Put together, a poor community with a large, publicly known sum of money and little police protection was an obvious target. Similar risks apply anywhere that a windfall, whether a prize, a grant or compensation, lands in a place where the state is weak.

What the case teaches about community windfalls

  • Protect identities where the law allows. Publishing the name of a school or village can be enough to expose it to extortion.
  • Move money out of reach quickly. Funds held in a single account, controlled by a few named people, are easy to pressure. Paying contractors directly for agreed projects reduces that risk.
  • Involve authorities early. Where threats appear, formal complaints create a record, even when the response is slow.
  • Treat security as part of the gift. Governments that hand out prizes in high-risk regions share responsibility for the safety of the recipients.

Mexico has recorded more than 30,000 murders a year in recent years, and violence varies sharply from one region to another. The families of El Nacimiento were not hurt by bad luck so much as by the absence of protection. Whether they were ever able to return home, and what became of the prize money, has not been clearly reported.

Sources: InSight Crime, Chris Dalby, 24 November 2021; raffle details: CNN, 16 September 2020; national crime figures: Wikipedia, Crime in Mexico. The story was also reported by the BBC.

COMMENTS