First published October 14, 2021.
Photo: Shutterstock
Could the universe have existed forever, with no first moment at all? In 2021 physicist Bruno Bento of the University of Liverpool and Stav Zalel of Imperial College London showed that one approach to quantum gravity, called causal set theory, can at least mathematically describe a universe that stretches infinitely into the past. In such a picture the Big Bang would be a dramatic event in cosmic history rather than the start of time. It is an intriguing idea, but it is a framework and not a finished or tested theory, and it does not overturn the evidence that our universe expanded from a hot, dense state about 13.8 billion years ago.
Why physicists question the "beginning"
The standard Big Bang model rests on strong evidence. Distant galaxies are moving away from us faster the farther away they are, showing that space is expanding. The cosmic microwave background, discovered by Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson in 1964, is the cooled glow of an early hot universe. And the amounts of hydrogen, helium and other light elements broadly match what an early hot phase should have produced.
The trouble comes when the equations of general relativity are run backwards all the way. They point to a singularity, a point of infinite density and temperature, at a finite time in the past. Most physicists read this as a sign that the theory has reached its limit rather than as a literal description of reality. General relativity does not include quantum effects, and at such extreme conditions both gravity and quantum physics must matter at once.
In other words, the Big Bang model describes how the universe evolved from a very early state. It does not, on its own, tell us whether time itself began. Answering that needs a theory of quantum gravity, which physicists do not yet have.
What causal set theory says
Causal set theory is one of several candidate approaches to quantum gravity, alongside better-known efforts such as string theory and loop quantum gravity. It was developed from the late 1980s, with the physicist Rafael Sorkin as its main champion, and a key early paper was published in 1987 by Luca Bombelli, Joohan Lee, David Meyer and Sorkin.
The central idea is that spacetime is not smooth and continuous. Instead it is made of discrete elements, a kind of "atoms" of spacetime. The only thing these elements carry is order: which ones can causally influence which others. Sorkin summed up the approach with the slogan "Order + Number = Geometry". The causal order gives the shape of spacetime, and simply counting elements gives its volume.
Because spacetime has a smallest scale in this picture, matter cannot be crushed into an infinitely small point. That removes the kind of singularity that general relativity predicts at the start of the Big Bang.
Growing a universe with no first moment
Causal set theory also takes the passage of time seriously. In its best-studied dynamical models, known as classical sequential growth and developed by David Rideout and Sorkin, the universe grows by adding new spacetime elements one at a time. In the original models that growth starts from nothing, so there is a first element and therefore a first moment.
Bento and his colleagues asked whether growth could still make sense if there were no first element: if the causal set extended infinitely into the past. In a technical paper with Fay Dowker and Zalel, later published in Classical and Quantum Gravity in 2022, they adapted the growth rules so that a past-infinite causal set could also grow, and proposed what kinds of physical questions could meaningfully be asked of such a universe. A companion essay by Bento and Zalel, titled "If time had no beginning", explored what the result means for the nature of time.
Speaking to Live Science, Bento summed up the achievement modestly, saying the team "showed that a framework is indeed possible", and adding: "So at least mathematically, this can be done." In this picture, there would always be something earlier, and the Big Bang would be one stage in the history of an ever-growing causal set.
What the proposal does and does not show
Headlines in 2021 said the universe "had no beginning", but that goes much further than the work itself. Here is what it does and does not establish.
- It shows a possibility, not a fact. The result is that a consistent mathematical description of a beginningless causal set can be written down. It does not show that our universe actually is one.
- It makes no tested predictions yet. It is still unclear whether these growth models can produce the detailed physics of the early universe that observations require.
- It does not reject the Big Bang. The expanding hot early universe remains supported by evidence. The question is what, if anything, came before it.
- Causal set theory itself is unproven. Like every approach to quantum gravity, it has not been confirmed by experiment, and its dynamics are still an active research problem.
Other ideas about time before the Big Bang
Bento's work joins a long list of serious proposals about the earliest moments of the universe. Some cyclic models imagine the universe passing through repeated phases of expansion and contraction, so that each Big Bang follows an earlier collapse. Big Bounce models, including some inspired by loop quantum gravity, replace the singularity with a bounce from a previous contracting phase. Eternal inflation pictures our universe as one bubble in a much larger inflating space, with many separate "big bangs".
At the other end, the Hartle and Hawking "no-boundary" proposal suggests that time as we know it emerges at the Big Bang, so that asking what came before is a bit like asking what lies north of the North Pole. Some quantum gravity approaches go further and treat time itself as emergent rather than fundamental.
None of these ideas has been confirmed. Future evidence, such as detailed measurements of primordial gravitational waves or subtle patterns in the cosmic microwave background, may eventually help to rule some of them out.
Why the question matters
Whether the universe had a beginning is one of the oldest questions people have asked, debated by philosophers and theologians long before modern physics. What has changed is that it can now be approached with precise mathematical models that may one day be tested.
Work like Bento's is valuable because it shows that a beginningless universe is not ruled out by the internal logic of at least one quantum gravity approach. It also highlights a deeper theme in causal set research: the idea that the passing of time is a real physical process, not just an illusion produced by our brains. For now, the honest answer to "did the universe have a beginning?" remains: we do not know, and several promising theories point in different directions.
Sources: Live Science: What if the universe had no beginning? (October 2021); Bento and Zalel, If time had no beginning (arXiv, September 2021); Bento, Dowker and Zalel, Classical and Quantum Gravity 39, 045002 (2022); Wikipedia: Causal sets; Wikipedia: Big Bang; first reported via ScienceAlert.

COMMENTS