First published October 10, 2021.
In autumn 2021 Brentwood Borough Council in Essex agreed to test a hidden, AI-assisted camera called LitterCam on the A12, the busy trunk road that runs past the town between London and Chelmsford. The aim was to spot people throwing rubbish out of vehicle windows, match the incident to the vehicle's number plate and pursue the registered keeper for a fine. Local reporting said offenders could face a £150 penalty.
The trial was short and cheap by council standards: 14 days, with the camera costing £4,500. But it was part of a wider change in how English councils tackle roadside litter, made possible by a 2018 law that lets them fine a vehicle's keeper rather than having to prove exactly who threw the rubbish. Here is how the system works, why Brentwood tried it, and what drivers should know.
What Brentwood decided
The decision was taken on 30 September 2021 by the council's Policy, Resources and Economic Development Committee. Its record describes a proposed 14-day trial of a camera that detects litter being thrown from moving or stationary cars. The approved budget covered £4,500 for the camera itself and £850 for safety checks on the lamp columns it would be mounted on, paid from an earmarked reserve. Councillors asked for a further report on the results once the trial ended.
The council chose not to reveal the exact location. Keeping the site secret is common with enforcement cameras, since the point is to change behaviour along the whole stretch rather than at one spot drivers learn to avoid.
Why the A12 near Brentwood
The council's report said litter was a particular problem on the major trunk roads around and through Brentwood. Councillors pointed to the section between Ingatestone and Brook Street, where laybys collect everything from drinks cans and fast-food bags to dumped mattresses and kitchen appliances.
Liberal Democrat councillor David Kendall described the amount of rubbish there as "horrendous", and told local reporters the fly-tipping was so bad it was "literally criminal". He added that similar cameras had proved fairly successful elsewhere, and that anything able to reduce the problem was worth trying.
Roadside litter is more than an eyesore. Clearing verges on fast dual carriageways usually means lane closures and traffic management to keep crews safe, which makes it slow and expensive. Litter also blocks drains, harms wildlife that eats or gets trapped in it, and tends to attract more dumping once a layby looks neglected.
How LitterCam works
LitterCam is a commercial product sold to councils. It combines a roadside camera with software trained to recognise an object leaving a vehicle, and with automatic number plate recognition to capture the registration. Clips flagged by the software are then passed on so the incident can be checked and linked to the vehicle's keeper through official records.
It is worth being clear about what the artificial intelligence does and does not do. The software flags a likely incident; it does not issue the fine by itself. A council still has to review the footage, decide whether an offence took place and send a penalty notice through the proper legal process. Some early news coverage gave the impression that drivers would be fined automatically and instantly, which overstated what the technology does.
Brentwood was not the first to try it. Maidstone Borough Council in Kent had begun a year-long pilot earlier in 2021, at the time described as the first of its kind in the country. Coverage of that scheme quoted lower fines than Essex, starting at £90 and rising to £120 if unpaid, which reflects the fact that each council sets its own amount.
The law behind fining the keeper
For years the main obstacle to tackling litter thrown from cars was proof. Under the Environmental Protection Act 1990, a fixed penalty went to the person who dropped the litter, and a camera image of a car rarely shows who in it threw a bottle.
The Littering From Vehicles Outside London (Keepers: Civil Penalties) Regulations 2018 changed that in England. They allow a council that has reason to believe litter was thrown from a vehicle on its land to send a penalty notice to the vehicle's registered keeper. The council sets the amount; if it sets none, the default is £100. An unpaid penalty doubles, councils may offer a discount for early payment, and keepers have a right to challenge the notice. London has its own, older rules.
In practice this means the keeper is responsible for what passengers throw out, much as with a parking ticket. Some councils have since raised their amounts considerably. Wiltshire Council, for example, set its fine for littering from a vehicle at £750 from September 2026, so the £150 quoted for Essex in 2021 should not be read as a current national figure.
Do litter cameras work?
Evidence is still patchy, because most trials are short and councils measure different things. A useful trial report would answer a few questions: did the amount of litter on the monitored stretch fall, how many flagged clips turned out to be genuine offences, how many fines were paid or successfully challenged, and what the scheme cost compared with the clean-up it saved.
Supporters argue that the main value is deterrence. If drivers believe a hidden camera could be watching any stretch of road, fewer will risk it. Critics raise questions about privacy, about the accuracy of automated detection, and about whether a two-week trial can say much about long-term behaviour. Both points are reasonable, and the answer probably depends on how carefully each council reviews the footage and publishes its results.
What drivers can do
- Keep a bag in the car for wrappers, cups and bottles, and empty it at home or at a service station bin.
- Talk to passengers. Under the keeper rules, a penalty can land on the registered keeper even if someone else threw the litter.
- Check your council's rules. Penalty amounts and enforcement methods vary between councils and have changed since 2021.
- Report fly-tipping rather than ignoring it. Councils use reports to decide where cameras and clean-ups are most needed.
Whatever one thinks of surveillance cameras, the underlying problem is simple. Every item thrown from a window has to be picked up by someone, often at real risk beside fast traffic, and paid for by local taxpayers.
Sources: Brentwood Borough Council: Litter Enforcement decision, 30 September 2021; Gazette: Drivers on A12 targeted for throwing litter; BBC News (Local Democracy Reporting Service); Road Safety News, March 2021: fines for litterbug drivers caught on camera; legislation.gov.uk: Littering From Vehicles Outside London (Keepers: Civil Penalties) Regulations 2018; Wiltshire Council: littering penalties increased.

COMMENTS