Clifford Owensby: Dayton Police Pull Paraplegic Man From His Car

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-10-13.

The 2021 Ohio Police Stop Involving a Man With Paraplegia

Image: still from Dayton Police Department body camera footage of the stop.

On 30 September 2021, police in Dayton, Ohio, stopped Clifford Owensby, a 39-year-old Black man who is paraplegic, as he drove away from a house officers suspected of drug activity. When he told them he could not get out of his car because he has no use of his legs, officers pulled him out by his arms and hair and dragged him to a police cruiser. No drugs were found. The body camera video caused national outrage, an internal review cleared the officers of excessive force, and in 2023 the city paid Owensby $125,000 to settle his lawsuit.

What happened during the stop

The stop took place shortly after noon at West Grand and Ferguson avenues. Officers said they had seen Owensby leave a suspected drug house, and because of his past felony drug and weapons record they wanted a police dog to perform a "free-air sniff" around the car. The stated legal basis for the stop was a window tint violation: the front passenger window was measured at 20 percent light transmission, well below Ohio's 50 percent limit.

Owensby's three-year-old child was in the back seat. Officers asked him to step out so the dog could work. He said he could not, told them he was paraplegic and asked for a supervisor, known in police slang as a "white shirt." One officer said a supervisor would be called only after Owensby was out of the car, and told him he could either cooperate or be dragged out.

Several officers then pulled him from the driver's seat, including by his hair, while he shouted for help. He was handcuffed and pulled across the ground to a cruiser with his legs trailing behind him.

The search and the citations

The dog alerted on the car, and officers found a bag containing about $22,450 in cash, which Owensby said was his savings. No drugs were found. He was cited for window tint and for failing to secure his child in a car seat. A police report also listed obstructing official business and resisting arrest, but he was not charged with either offence. Police seized the cash.

Public reaction

The footage, released in early October, spread rapidly online and was covered by the BBC, NPR and the Washington Post. Then-mayor Nan Whaley called it "very concerning" and said a thorough investigation was under way. The Dayton branch of the NAACP opened its own inquiry; a representative said pulling a paraplegic man out of a car by his hair was "totally unacceptable" and inhumane.

The local police union took the opposite view. Jerome Dix, president of Fraternal Order of Police Lodge 44, argued that arresting people who do not comply is sometimes ugly but necessary to keep the public safe.

The case arrived just over a year after the murder of George Floyd in Minneapolis. Former officer Derek Chauvin had been convicted in April 2021, and protests over policing and race were still fresh across the United States, which helped explain the strength of the response.

What the internal review found

In January 2022 Dayton released the findings of its Professional Standards Bureau. The review concluded that officers Wayne Hammock Jr. and Vincent Carter did not break department policy in making the stop, calling for the dog or physically removing Owensby. It described the force as minimal and justified, noted that he was not injured, and acknowledged that pulling his hair might look offensive to some people. It relied on court rulings that allow officers to order a driver out of a vehicle during a lawful traffic stop.

The officers were found to have broken rules on muting their body cameras, and one was written up for an unprofessional remark to a colleague. Both received a training memorandum and no other penalty. Carter told investigators he had never been trained on how to move a paraplegic person from the ground to a cruiser.

The review recommended new policy and training on interacting with people with disabilities, and Police Chief Kamran Afzal said the department would take part in Americans with Disabilities Act training and review how officers deal with people who have limited mobility. Mayor Jeffrey Mims Jr. said the incident fell short of the city's standard of treating every resident with dignity.

The lawsuit and the settlement

Owensby sued the city. In September 2023 the Dayton City Commission unanimously approved a $125,000 settlement that resolved all of his pending claims. The city admitted no liability, and the cash seized during the stop was returned to him as part of the agreement.

Disability and police encounters

The case highlighted a gap that disability advocates have raised for years. Officers are trained to treat refusal to follow orders as a threat, but some people physically cannot comply, whether because of paralysis, deafness, autism or other conditions. When that is not recognised, routine stops can escalate quickly.

Advocates generally point to a few practical changes:

  • Training on disability. Teaching officers how to recognise and safely assist people with mobility limitations, including how to move someone who cannot walk.
  • Calling a supervisor early. Many disputes ease when a senior officer arrives before force is used, which is what Owensby asked for.
  • Accommodation, not just compliance. The Americans with Disabilities Act applies to policing, and departments are expected to make reasonable adjustments.
  • Independent oversight. Dayton has since added an independent police accountability auditor and a non-police response option for some non-violent calls.

Owensby's stop was lawful on paper, and an internal review found the force within policy. Yet the city still paid to settle his case and changed its training. For many viewers, that gap between what the rules allowed and what looked right on camera is the real lesson of the video.

Sources: NPR via KPBS: Police dragged a paraplegic man from his car (10 October 2021); Spectrum News: Review finds Dayton officers didn't violate policy (11 January 2022); WDTN: Dayton paying Owensby $125K settlement (28 September 2023); BBC News (October 2021). Photo and video: Dayton Police Department body camera footage.

COMMENTS