Laurel Hubbard at Tokyo 2020: What Happened and the Fairness Debate

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published August 4, 2021.

Transgender Olympic Weightlifter Becomes The Focus Of Inclusion And Fairness Debate

On 2 August 2021, New Zealand's Laurel Hubbard became the first openly transgender woman to compete at an Olympic Games, in the women's over-87kg weightlifting event in Tokyo. She did not complete a lift. After three failed snatch attempts, one at 120kg and two at 125kg, she was out of the competition and recorded no total. The gold went to China's Li Wenwen with an Olympic record total of 320kg.

Her result was brief, but her presence made the event one of the most debated of the Games. This article sets out what happened, the rules she competed under, what both sides argued and how policy has moved since.

What happened on the platform in Tokyo

The over-87kg final took place at the Tokyo International Forum. Hubbard, then 43, opened in the snatch with 120kg and lost the bar. She then twice attempted 125kg and missed both times. In weightlifting, an athlete who fails all three snatch attempts cannot continue to the clean and jerk, so her competition ended there.

Li Wenwen won comfortably. Emily Campbell of Great Britain took silver with 283kg and Sarah Robles of the United States won bronze with 282kg. Afterwards Hubbard acknowledged the attention around her. She said she was not entirely unaware of the controversy which surrounds my participation at these Games, as reported by Inside the Games, and thanked the International Olympic Committee and the International Weightlifting Federation for supporting her right to take part.

Who is Laurel Hubbard?

Hubbard was born in Auckland in 1978. She competed in men's weightlifting as a junior before stepping away from the sport, and she transitioned in 2012, when she began hormone therapy. Her father is Dick Hubbard, a former mayor of Auckland City and founder of the cereal company Hubbard Foods.

She returned to competition in the women's category and won silver in the heavyweight division at the 2017 World Championships in Anaheim. At the 2018 Commonwealth Games she was leading the field when an elbow injury forced her to withdraw, and she won two gold medals at the 2019 Pacific Games in Samoa. New Zealand selected her for Tokyo in June 2021. After the Games she hinted that her age had caught up with her.

The rules she competed under

The IOC first allowed transgender athletes to compete in 2004, initially requiring surgery, legal recognition and around two years of hormone therapy. Its 2015 guidance dropped the surgery requirement. Under those rules, a transgender woman had to show that her serum testosterone had stayed below 10 nmol/L for at least 12 months before her first competition and remained below that level throughout her eligibility.

Hubbard met those criteria, and the weightlifting federation accepted her entry. Even before Tokyo, however, the IOC itself described the 2015 consensus as outdated and said it was preparing a new framework that would not rely on testosterone alone.

The case made by critics

Critics argued that going through male puberty brings lasting physical advantages, such as greater height, bone density, muscle mass and strength, that hormone therapy does not fully reverse. In strength sports, they said, even a small edge matters.

Katherine Deves, co-founder of the campaign group Save Women's Sport Australasia, told Reuters that Hubbard's selection could cost a female athlete a podium place. Former New Zealand weightlifter Tracey Lambrechs said she had felt unable to speak openly while competing and stressed that her concern was about fair competition for women, not hostility to transgender people.

Some research supports parts of this concern. A 2021 systematic review found that strength and lean mass fell after a year of hormone therapy but remained above the levels seen in other women, even after 36 months.

The case made by supporters

Supporters pointed out that Hubbard was competing under rules set by the sport's governing bodies and had followed them. They noted that she was 43 in Tokyo, older than almost every rival, and that the result itself undercut predictions that she would dominate.

Joanna Harper, a medical physicist and researcher on transgender athletes who is herself a transgender woman and distance runner, told Reuters that there was a lack of firm data on both sides of the argument, and dismissed the idea that inclusion would ruin women's sport. A 2026 meta-analysis in the British Journal of Sports Medicine later reported that transgender women had higher average lean mass but comparable fitness to other women, and its authors argued the evidence did not support blanket bans.

How the policy picture has changed since Tokyo

The debate did not end with Hubbard's three missed lifts. In November 2021 the IOC published a non-binding framework built on ten principles, including fairness, inclusion and "no presumption of advantage", and left eligibility rules to each sport's federation. Several federations then tightened their rules. World Athletics, for example, excluded transgender women who had gone through male puberty from female world-ranking competitions from March 2023.

According to the Wikipedia summary of IOC policy, in March 2026 the IOC went further and barred transgender women and some intersex athletes from female events from the 2028 Los Angeles Games onwards, introducing a one-time genetic (SRY) screening for the female category. That decision remains contested by athletes, scientists and human rights groups, and the evidence base is still developing.

Why one competition settles very little

It is tempting to treat Hubbard's result as proof for one side or the other. It is neither. A single athlete in a single event, affected by age, injury history and nerves, cannot show how a rule works across a whole sport. Useful discussion keeps three questions apart: what the rules were at the time, what the scientific evidence says for a given sport, and how every athlete, including Hubbard herself, is treated with dignity while that evidence is weighed.

Sources: Inside the Games, Tokyo 2020 report on Laurel Hubbard; Reuters, 1 August 2021: inclusion vs fairness debate; Wikipedia: Laurel Hubbard; Wikipedia: Weightlifting at the 2020 Olympics, women's +87kg; Wikipedia: Transgender people in sports.

COMMENTS