Russian Be-200 Firefighting Plane Crash in Turkey, August 2021

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-08-16.

Eight people died on 14 August 2021 when a Russian Beriev Be-200 water bomber, on loan to Turkey during the worst wildfire season in the country's modern history, came down in the mountains of the south. Five of the dead were Russian military personnel and three were Turkish servicemen. Nobody on board survived, and no cause was announced at the time.

Russian Firefighting Plane Crashes in Turkey, Killing All Eight Aboard

The plane had been helping Turkish crews tackle fires in Kahramanmaraş province. Its loss came at the end of a punishing three weeks for Turkey, in which hundreds of blazes, a record heatwave and then deadly floods in the north stretched emergency services to their limit.

What happened on 14 August 2021

The aircraft went down on a Saturday after a firefighting sortie. Reports placed the crash in a mountainous area of southern Turkey, but they differed slightly on the exact spot. Turkish officials and search teams focused on Kahramanmaraş, where a fire, reportedly started by lightning striking trees, was burning. Russia's Defence Ministry said the plane crashed as it was trying to land, and described the location as near Adana province, which borders Kahramanmaraş.

Kahramanmaraş governor Ömer Faruk Coşkun told reporters that his office had sent the plane to the area and that contact was then lost. In his words: "We lost communication with the plane a while ago and it crashed." Search and rescue units were sent at once, but there were no survivors.

The Russian Defence Ministry confirmed that all eight people aboard had died: five Russian servicemen and three Turkish officers who had been flying with them. Moscow said a special commission and staff from the Russian embassy were travelling to the site to investigate. Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlüt Çavuşoğlu said he was deeply saddened and promised that the crew's sacrifice would be remembered, and President Vladimir Putin sent condolences to President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan.

The Be-200: a jet-powered flying boat

The Beriev Be-200 is an unusual machine. It is an amphibious jet that can take off from runways or water, and it was designed with firefighting, search and rescue and maritime patrol in mind. The first prototype flew in 1998, and Russia's emergencies ministry (EMERCOM) and its naval aviation are the main users.

Its key trick is scooping. Skimming the surface of a lake or the sea at close to take-off speed, the aircraft fills its tanks through four retractable scoops, taking on about 12 tonnes of water in roughly 14 seconds. It can then climb away and drop the load on a fire front, repeating the cycle many times a day if a suitable body of water is nearby.

The aircraft lost in Kahramanmaraş was one of two Be-200s Turkey had hired from Russia. According to Turkish reporting, it was attached to the country's General Directorate of Forestry and had already worked on fires in Antalya province before being moved east. Low-level flying over steep, smoky terrain is among the most dangerous work in aviation, and water-bomber crews around the world accept serious risks every season.

Why Turkey was relying on borrowed aircraft

The fact that a Russian plane was flying Turkish missions was itself a political story. As the fires spread in late July, it emerged that Turkey had very few working firefighting planes of its own. Agriculture and Forestry Minister Bekir Pakdemirli said at one point that three planes, 38 helicopters and about 4,000 firefighters had been deployed, figures critics said were far too small for fires of that scale.

For years Turkey had relied on aircraft operated by the Turkish Aeronautical Association (THK). The opposition argued that the government had sidelined the association, and Kemal Kılıçdaroğlu, leader of the main opposition Republican People's Party (CHP), accused ministers of leaving the country without planes. Meral Akşener of the Good Party said she had warned about the shortage a year earlier. The government replied that new aircraft would be bought and that the association needed to modernise.

The anger was sharp. Al-Monitor reported that the government faced calls to step down once it became clear the country had no usable firefighting planes of its own, and that Ankara had at first turned down outside help before accepting it. Mayors of eleven CHP-run metropolitan municipalities even offered to cover the cost of hiring firefighting planes themselves.

In the end, Turkey accepted help from a long list of countries. Planes came from Russia, Ukraine, Belarus, Azerbaijan, Croatia, Spain, France, Israel, Iran and Romania, helicopters arrived from Kazakhstan, Poland and the United States, and the European Union's civil protection system sent support. Azerbaijan alone sent hundreds of firefighters and dozens of fire engines.

A summer of fire, then flood

The first major blaze broke out near Manavgat in Antalya province on 28 July 2021, in temperatures of around 37°C. Within days, fires were burning across the Mediterranean and Aegean coasts, with Muğla, Antalya, Mersin, Adana and Kahramanmaraş among the worst hit. Thousands of tourists were evacuated by boat from hotels near Bodrum, villages were emptied, and a coal-fired power plant in Muğla had to be cleared as flames approached.

By mid-August, Pakdemirli said firefighters had brought 299 fires under control in 16 days. Nine people, including firefighters and villagers, were killed in the wildfires, and the burned area was later put at well over 1,500 square kilometres of forest, the worst season ever recorded in the republic.

Just as the southern fires were easing, the opposite disaster struck the north. Torrential rain from 10 to 12 August caused flash floods in the Black Sea provinces of Bartın, Kastamonu and Sinop. The town of Bozkurt was devastated, and the confirmed death toll eventually rose to more than 80 people. For many Turks, the crash of the Be-200 came in the middle of a week of almost continuous bad news.

Heat, people and climate: what drives these fires

Wildfires need three things: fuel, dry conditions and a spark. In 2021 Turkey had plenty of all three. May had been the hottest in more than half a century, drought had dried out pine forests, and parts of the country ran up to 12°C above normal in late July. Satellites from Europe's Copernicus programme measured the heat released by the Turkish fires at roughly four times the previous national record.

The spark is usually human. Studies of Turkish forest fires suggest around nine in ten start through people, mostly carelessness such as burning stubble, dropped cigarettes or litter, while faults in power lines also play a role. Lightning, as in Kahramanmaraş, accounts for a smaller share.

Climate change does not light fires, but it loads the dice. Scientists broadly agree that a warming Mediterranean brings longer, hotter and drier summers, which lengthen the fire season and make blazes harder to control once they start. The UN's climate panel published a major report in August 2021, during these very fires, warning that such extremes would become more frequent as warming continues.

Lessons from a deadly mission

Three practical points stand out from the 2021 season. First, aerial firefighting capacity cannot be improvised in the middle of an emergency; planes, pilots and maintenance take years to build up. Second, shared European and regional pools of aircraft can make a real difference when one country is overwhelmed. Third, prevention on the ground, from clearing dry undergrowth to strict rules on burning, saves more forest than any number of water drops.

No detailed public findings on the cause of the Be-200 crash were released in the reporting we reviewed, so questions about mechanical failure, weather or terrain remain open. What is clear is that eight people from two countries died trying to protect Turkish forests and villages, during a summer that showed how vulnerable the region has become to fire.

Sources: Euronews, 14 August 2021; Hürriyet Daily News, 14 August 2021; Al-Monitor, August 2021; Wikipedia: Wildfires in Turkey (2021 season); Wikipedia: Beriev Be-200; Wikipedia: 2021 Turkey floods.

COMMENTS