Equality Can't Wait Challenge: French Gates and Scott's $40M Awards

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-08-02.

On 29 July 2021, Melinda French Gates, MacKenzie Scott and the family foundation of Lynn Schusterman announced $40 million in awards from the Equality Can't Wait Challenge, a competition designed to expand women's power and influence in the United States. Four projects received $10 million each, and two finalists shared a further $8 million.

Much of the coverage at the time focused on the fact that both women had recently divorced two of the world's richest men. The more useful story is what the competition was, who won, and how it fits into the two donors' very different styles of giving.

Melinda French Gates and MacKenzie Scott's 2021 Equality Awards

What the Equality Can't Wait Challenge was

The challenge was launched in June 2020 by Pivotal Ventures, the investment and incubation company Melinda French Gates founded in 2015 to work on problems facing women and families in the US. It was run by Lever for Change, a nonprofit affiliate of the MacArthur Foundation that organises large open grant competitions.

The brief was broad: propose a project that would accelerate women's progress towards equal power and influence in the US. More than 500 proposals arrived from across the country. Rather than a closed process where donors pick favourite charities, applicants were scored and narrowed down to finalists before the winners were chosen.

It is worth correcting one detail that many early reports got wrong. The $40 million did not come from French Gates and Scott alone. Lynn Schusterman's family philanthropy was the third funder, and all three had supported gender-equality work before.

The four winning projects

Each of the four winners received $10 million. Their focus areas show how many different routes there are towards the same goal:

  • Building Women's Equality through Strengthening the Care Infrastructure – a coalition working to change how society values caregiving, from child care to elder care, work that falls disproportionately on women and is often unpaid or poorly paid.
  • Changing the Face of Tech – an effort to open more routes for women into technology careers, a sector where women remain under-represented in technical and leadership roles.
  • Girls Inc.'s Project Accelerate – support to help young women through college and into their first jobs.
  • The Future is Indigenous Womxn – backing for businesses owned by Native American women.

Two finalists split the remaining $8 million: one working against intimate-partner violence and another helping young women become politically active.

Why the donors said the timing mattered

The awards came during the COVID-19 pandemic, which hit women's employment hard in the US. Many women left work to look after children when schools and day-care centres closed, and sectors with large female workforces, such as hospitality and retail, suffered heavy job losses. The donors presented the challenge as a way to back organisations that could help reverse those losses.

Announcing the winners, French Gates said that "we can break the patterns of history and advance gender equality," provided there is a commitment to organisations ready to lift up women and girls. Scott praised the winners as teams working on the front lines and from within communities to help women build power in their lives and careers.

Nicole Bates of Pivotal Ventures, who helped manage the challenge, described the collaboration as a collective statement about the importance of gender equality.

Melinda French Gates and Pivotal Ventures

French Gates is best known for co-founding what was then the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, the world's largest private foundation, which works on global health, poverty and vaccines. Pivotal Ventures is a separate vehicle. Because it is set up as an investment company rather than a traditional charity, it can fund for-profit ventures, take on higher risk and engage more directly in policy, though it does not have to disclose every group it supports.

In 2019 she committed $1 billion to expanding women's power and influence in the US, and the Equality Can't Wait Challenge was one of the first large public results of that pledge. Her divorce from Bill Gates was finalised on 2 August 2021, the same week the winners were announced.

She remained co-chair of the Gates Foundation for a time after the divorce, but in May 2024 she announced her resignation, which took effect on 7 June 2024. As part of the agreement she received $12.5 billion for her own philanthropy focused on women and families, and the foundation was renamed the Gates Foundation.

MacKenzie Scott's different approach

MacKenzie Scott, a novelist and former Amazon employee, received a large share of Amazon stock when her marriage to Jeff Bezos ended in 2019: 25 per cent of the couple's holdings, roughly 4 per cent of the company. Its value has risen and fallen with Amazon's share price, and estimates of her fortune in mid-2021 were around $60 billion.

She signed the Giving Pledge in May 2019, promising to give away most of her wealth during her lifetime or in her will. Her pace of giving quickly became the story. By the time of these awards she had already announced more than $8 billion in donations in three rounds since 2020, far more than the $1.6 billion figure that circulated in some reports.

Scott is known for large, unrestricted gifts with few reporting requirements, often to organisations led by and serving people from under-resourced communities: groups working on racial equity, LGBTQ rights, public health, education and climate. In 2022 she launched Yield Giving to organise this work, and by the end of 2025 she had given away about $26.3 billion to more than 1,600 organisations.

She married Seattle science teacher Dan Jewett in 2021; they divorced in early 2023.

What the Giving Pledge does and does not mean

The Giving Pledge was launched in 2010 by Warren Buffett and Bill and Melinda Gates. Signatories, who include figures such as Buffett and Mark Zuckerberg, make a public moral commitment to give away the majority of their wealth. It is not a legal contract and there is no enforcement, so the true measure is what each signatory actually gives over time.

That is why competitions like this one are worth watching beyond the headline. A $10 million grant is a large sum for a coalition or a nonprofit, and the more interesting questions come later: what each project built, how many women it reached, and whether its results lasted after the money was spent.

For readers who want to compare, Scott's open, trust-based giving and French Gates's structured challenge model represent two quite different answers to the same question of how a very large fortune can be put to work.

Sources: AP via News4JAX, 29 July 2021: MacKenzie Scott, French Gates join to fund gender equality; Melinda French Gates (Wikipedia); MacKenzie Scott (Wikipedia); Al Jazeera, 15 June 2021: MacKenzie Scott donates another $2.7bn; CNN, 29 July 2021.

COMMENTS