Originally published 2021-08-16.

On 12 August 2021 Elon Musk posted a one-line joke that summed up the bitter fight over NASA's Moon lander: if lobbying and lawyers could put you in orbit, he wrote, Jeff Bezos would already be on Pluto. The target was Blue Origin, the space company Bezos founded, which was challenging NASA's decision to give the lander contract for its Artemis programme to Musk's SpaceX alone.
The quip was funny to Musk's fans and irritating to Bezos's, but behind it sat a serious dispute about billions of dollars of public money, how NASA buys spacecraft, and who gets to carry astronauts back to the lunar surface.
What Musk said, and when
The tweet went out on 12 August 2021. In the abbreviated style Musk often uses on the platform, it read:
If lobbying & lawyers could get u to orbit, Bezos would be on Pluto rn
— Elon Musk (@elonmusk) August 12, 2021
The timing was not random. A day later, on 13 August, Blue Origin took its complaint to the US Court of Federal Claims, after an earlier protest to the Government Accountability Office (GAO) had failed. Musk was mocking the idea that a rival could win in court what it had not won in the competition itself.
The jab also landed during a summer when Bezos was very visible in space news. On 20 July 2021 he had flown on his own New Shepard rocket, a suborbital hop that lasted about ten minutes from launch to capsule landing and reached roughly 107 km. Musk's line about "orbit" was a pointed reminder that New Shepard does not go into orbit; it goes up and comes straight back down.
The contract behind the insult
NASA's Artemis programme aims to land astronauts on the Moon for the first time since Apollo 17 in 1972. To do that it needs a Human Landing System (HLS): a craft that carries crew from lunar orbit down to the surface and back up again.
NASA first funded three competing concepts. According to CNBC, the early design contracts were worth nearly $1 billion in total: about $579 million to Blue Origin, $253 million to Dynetics and $135 million to SpaceX. Each team then submitted a full proposal.
The prices were far apart. SpaceX, offering a lunar version of its Starship, bid about $2.9 billion. Blue Origin, leading a "National Team" that included established aerospace firms, bid about $5.99 billion, roughly double. Dynetics asked for about $8.5 billion.
NASA had hoped to pick two landers so that it would not depend on a single supplier. But Congress gave the programme far less money than requested, and in April 2021 NASA announced it would make only one award, to SpaceX.
Blue Origin's protest and why it failed
Both losing bidders protested to the GAO, the congressional watchdog that rules on disputes over federal purchases. Blue Origin's filing was a lengthy document, and its central argument was that NASA had changed the terms late in the process, notably by choosing one winner instead of two and by letting SpaceX adjust its payment schedule, without giving the other bidders the same chance to revise their offers.
On 30 July 2021 the GAO denied both protests. Kenneth Patton, its managing associate general counsel for procurement law, said NASA had acted within the rules when it made a single award and had evaluated all three proposals reasonably. Blue Origin replied that the GAO's limited jurisdiction meant its deeper concerns had not been addressed, and said it would keep pushing for two providers.
Days before that ruling, Bezos had sent NASA an open letter offering to cover up to $2 billion of the agency's costs over the current and next two fiscal years if Blue Origin received a contract too. NASA did not take up the offer.
The lawsuit Musk was mocking did not go much better. NASA paused work on the SpaceX lander while the case ran, but on 4 November 2021 the court dismissed Blue Origin's suit and the work resumed.
A long-running rivalry between two billionaires
The Pluto line was only one episode in years of public sniping. Musk and Bezos have traded places at the top of the world's rich lists, and their companies compete for rocket launches, satellite internet and government contracts.
Some of the friction goes back to reusable rockets. When New Shepard landed upright after a suborbital flight in November 2015, Musk responded on Twitter that SpaceX's experimental Grasshopper vehicle had already made six suborbital flights about three years earlier. His point was that landing after a straight up-and-down flight is far easier than recovering a booster that has sent a payload to orbit, which SpaceX first managed with a Falcon 9 a few weeks later, in December 2015.
Musk's online habits have often drawn criticism beyond his feud with Bezos. In 2018 he called Vernon Unsworth, a British caver who helped in the Thai cave rescue, a "pedo guy" without evidence. Unsworth sued for defamation, and in December 2019 a Los Angeles jury found Musk not liable. In July 2020 Musk replied to a critic with "We will coup whoever we want! Deal with it", a remark widely read as a reference to the 2019 removal of Bolivian president Evo Morales and lithium interests; Musk later said he had been joking.
Was the criticism of Blue Origin fair?
Supporters of Musk saw the protest and lawsuit as a sore loser delaying America's return to the Moon. Supporters of Blue Origin argued that relying on one company, and on a lander as unproven and unusual as Starship, was risky, and that challenging the decision was a normal use of the legal channels open to any contractor.
Both views have some basis. Bid protests are routine in US government purchasing; companies file them regularly and many fail. At the same time, the GAO found that NASA had not broken the rules, and the court case cost the programme several months of work on the lander.
The question of a second supplier did not go away. Congress and NASA kept pressing for competition, and in May 2023 NASA selected Blue Origin's Blue Moon lander as a second crewed lander, intended for a later Artemis mission. In other words, Blue Origin eventually got part of what it had argued for, not through lawyers but through a new competition.
Space tourism and the wider debate
The feud played out against a broader argument about billionaires in space. Bezos's July 2021 flight, with his brother Mark, aviation pioneer Wally Funk and 18-year-old Oliver Daemen, was celebrated by many as a milestone for commercial spaceflight. Others questioned whether money spent on short tourist flights would be better used on problems on Earth, especially during the pandemic.
It helps to separate the two things. Suborbital tourism is largely a private business. Lunar landers for Artemis are paid for mostly by NASA, which means the public has a direct interest in how the contract is awarded and whether the hardware works.
Key takeaways
- The joke: Musk's 12 August 2021 tweet mocked Blue Origin for fighting the lander decision through protests and lawsuits.
- The contract: SpaceX won NASA's roughly $2.9 billion HLS contract in April 2021, bidding about half of Blue Origin's price.
- The outcome: The GAO rejected the protests on 30 July 2021, and a federal court dismissed Blue Origin's lawsuit on 4 November 2021.
- The sequel: In 2023 NASA added Blue Origin as a second lander provider for a later mission.
The insult made headlines, but the bigger story was a government agency choosing price and speed over redundancy, then slowly building the redundancy back in.
Sources: CNBC: Government denies Bezos' protest over NASA lunar lander contract (30 July 2021); Wikipedia: Artemis program; Wikipedia: Blue Origin NS-16; Elon Musk on Twitter (12 August 2021); original story via The Independent.

COMMENTS