
Brazil has experienced rare snowfall as temperatures plummeted around the country.
As a result of the falling temperatures and the snow, there are worries that one of the world's most powerful agricultural nations may be hit with crop failures, particularly in terms of coffee, sugar and fruit. However, many people made the most of the snow, taking pictures and throwing snowballs.
Prices on the stock exchange for coffee and sugar have already surged, meaning higher prices could be passed on to consumers around the world in order to make up for the shortfall.
The cold-snap was widespread, with 40 cities in the state of Rio Grande do Sul and 33 municipalities experiencing ice and snow.
Truck driver Iodor Goncalves Marques, of Cambara do Sul, said he had never seen snow before, telling TV Globo network:
"I am 62 years old and had never seen the snow, you know? To see nature's beauty is something indescribable."
Joselaine da Silva Marques told TV Globo:
"It was worth it. Actually, you almost do not feel the cold because of how exciting the snow is. It is marvellous, it is marvellous!"
It is thought that the cold weather will now move onto Sao Paulo and Minas Gerais which are major agricultural centres, bringing further problems for the sector. High winds are also to be expected.
The unusual cold weather in Brazil is just one of many highly unusual weather events across the world recorded in the last year. Earlier this year, Canada and the United States were hit with a massive heatwave that killed hundreds, and wildfires have ravaged many parts of the US and Australia. Russian parts of Siberia hit record temperatures and it is feared that a melt of permafrost could release huge amounts of carbon into the atmosphere.
A warming climate changes the likelihood and intensity of many extremes, but attributing any specific event requires evidence about that event rather than assuming every unusual condition has the same cause.
[h/t: Reuters]
The photographs and the harvest tell different stories
The snow delighted people in southern Brazilian towns, while concern about agriculture extended to other places and crops. Those two observations should not be collapsed into a claim that every photographed snowfall directly caused a worldwide price rise. Frost damage depends on where temperatures fell, how long the cold lasted and the crop’s stage of growth. Likewise, a market reaction at the time is not evidence of a permanent change in supermarket prices. The article is best read as a July 2021 event report, with its forecasts and quotations anchored to that date.
A cold day does not resolve a climate question
Weather describes particular conditions over a short period; climate concerns patterns across much longer periods. That distinction allows severe cold and a warming climate to be discussed without contradiction. It also means an article should not attribute every unusual event to human-caused warming without event-specific evidence. NASA’s explanation of weather and climate offers a useful starting point. The practical value of this story is in understanding regional exposure and preparedness, while leaving the cause and probability of this particular cold spell to appropriate meteorological and attribution research. NASA’s weather-and-climate explainer.
What the frosts did to coffee and sugar
Severe frosts struck Brazil’s coffee areas on 20 July 2021; one trader said it was the first such event since 1994. Brazil’s Conab estimated that 150,000 to 200,000 hectares, about 11 per cent of the arabica area, were affected, and estimates of the losses rose to 5.5 to 9 million 60-kg bags. On ICE, the September arabica contract peaked at $2.1520 a pound, the highest front-month price since October 2014, and arabica futures were up about 35 per cent from the end of June. In southern Minas Gerais, Brazil’s top coffee-producing state, frost discoloured large areas of coffee fields and output was expected to suffer for at least the next two crops; trees that have to be replanted take years to return to full production.
The frosts followed one of Brazil’s worst droughts in decades. Three frost events hit the centre-south sugar region in June and July, and the consultancy StoneX cut its sugar production forecast for the region to 34.6 million tonnes, from 35.7 million in May; New York sugar futures were near a four-year high.
Sources: Al Jazeera (Reuters), 27 July 2021: Unusual cold weather in Brazil sends coffee prices soaring The Western Producer (Reuters), 12 August 2021: Unusual frosts in Brazil injure coffee and sugar

COMMENTS