15,000-Year-Old Viruses Found in Tibetan Glacier Ice: What It Means

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-08-10.

Ancient Viral Material Found in Ice: A 2021 Report

Yes, scientists really did find ancient viruses in Tibetan glacier ice. In July 2021 a team led by Ohio State University reported genetic traces of 33 virus groups, 28 of them new to science, locked inside ice laid down roughly 15,000 years ago on the Guliya ice cap in western China. What they did not find is a live virus that can make people sick. The viruses were identified from DNA alone, and nearly all of them appear to infect bacteria rather than humans, animals or plants.

The discovery still matters. Glaciers and permafrost work like natural freezers that store a record of past climates and past microbial life, and both are thawing. Below is what the Guliya team actually did, what they learned, how this connects to the wider worry about "zombie" microbes coming out of the ice, and where the real risks lie.

What the researchers found in the Guliya ice

The Guliya ice cap sits in the far north-west of the Tibetan Plateau, in China's Xinjiang region. Its summit is about 6,710 metres (around 22,000 feet) above sea level, high enough that snow builds up year after year without melting away. In 2015 a team from Ohio State's Byrd Polar and Climate Research Center drilled a core from the summit, part of a decades-long programme of sampling tropical and mountain glaciers led by glaciologist Lonnie Thompson.

The new study, titled "Glacier ice archives nearly 15,000-year-old microbes and phages", was published in the open-access journal Microbiome on 20 July 2021. Its first author was microbiologist Zhi-Ping Zhong, with Thompson as senior author and virus ecologist Matthew Sullivan among the co-authors.

The researchers analysed two virus samples from the summit core. One was about 355 years old; the other, from deeper ice, was dated to roughly 14,400 years ago, near the end of the last ice age. From the DNA they recovered, they assembled 33 distinct viral populations. Almost none matched anything in existing databases: they represent about 28 genera that had never been described, and only four could be given a formal classification.

Several of the viruses appear to infect Methylobacterium, a group of bacteria involved in the methane cycle, and others were linked to the bacteria Sphingomonas and Janthinobacterium. Their closest relatives came from soil and plant environments, which fits the idea that they arrived on the ice in windblown dust.

Zhong explained the process simply in comments reported by ScienceAlert: "These glaciers were formed gradually, and along with dust and gases, many, many viruses were also deposited in that ice."

How do you keep ancient ice clean?

The hardest part of this kind of work is not finding DNA. It is proving that the DNA belongs to the ice rather than to the drill, the freezer or the scientist. Ice cores are handled by people and machines and stored for years, so their outer surface is badly contaminated with modern microbes.

To deal with this, the team developed a clean sampling method and tested it on artificial ice cores seeded with known bacteria and viruses. Working in a cold room, they cut away the outer layer of each section with a band saw, rinsed it with sterile water, and kept only the inner ice, removing about 1.5 cm of the core's radius in total. Because the "fake" contaminants on the test cores were all stripped off, the researchers could be confident that what remained inside the real cores was original.

Even then, the amount of viral material was tiny. Viral particles in the samples were below the detection limit of standard counting methods, so the team relied on metagenomics: sequencing all the DNA in a sample and piecing viral genomes together with software. That is why the study describes viruses as genetic records, not as living organisms that were cultured or revived.

Why glacier viruses are useful to science

Mountain glaciers are layered archives. Each year's snow traps dust, gases, chemicals and microbes from the air, and the layers can be dated, much like tree rings. Comparing what lived in colder and warmer periods can show how microbial communities responded to past climate shifts.

The Guliya team chose its two samples partly because they formed under different conditions, one during a colder period and one during a warmer one, based on oxygen-isotope measurements in the ice. The virus communities in the two samples were very different, which hints that the ice records environmental change in its biology as well as its chemistry.

The study also found that about 42% of the viruses were likely "temperate" phages, viruses that can sit quietly inside a host bacterium instead of killing it right away. That share is higher than in gut, soil or ocean samples, and the authors suggest that lying low may have been a good strategy on a harsh, frozen glacier surface.

Thompson summed up the motivation: "We know very little about viruses and microbes in these extreme environments, and what is actually there." The team also warned that melting glaciers mean these archives could be lost before they are studied.

Glacier ice is not permafrost

Many news stories, including this one when it first ran, blended the Guliya discovery with stories about thawing permafrost. They are related but different. A glacier is a mass of compressed snow and ice that builds up over time. Permafrost is ground (soil, rock and sediment) that stays frozen for at least two years in a row, and it covers large parts of Siberia, Alaska and northern Canada.

Permafrost has produced some remarkable finds as it thaws. Well-preserved Ice Age animals, including woolly mammoths and wolves, have been recovered in Siberia. Mosses buried under ice for centuries have been regrown in the lab. In 2023 researchers described a tiny roundworm, later named Panagrolaimus kolymaensis, that they said had been revived after about 46,000 years in Siberian permafrost, although some scientists questioned the dating.

Viruses have been revived from permafrost too, but only ones that infect amoebae. In 2014 French researchers Chantal Abergel and Jean-Michel Claverie reported reviving Pithovirus sibericum, a giant virus around 30,000 years old, from a Siberian permafrost sample. It is harmless to humans; it was revived precisely because amoebae make a safe test host.

Could melting ice release a pandemic?

This is the question most people searching for this topic want answered, and the honest answer is that the risk is real but often overstated.

The clearest real-world example involves bacteria, not viruses. In the summer of 2016 a heatwave on Russia's Yamal Peninsula thawed ground that, according to the leading explanation, held the carcass of a reindeer that died of anthrax decades earlier. Anthrax spores spread across the tundra; more than 2,000 reindeer were infected, dozens of people were hospitalised and a child died. Anthrax spores are famously tough, so this was an unusual case rather than proof that every frozen microbe can come back.

Scientists disagree about how much to worry beyond that. Some, including Claverie, argue that permafrost preserves microbes extremely well and that mining and drilling in the Arctic could expose old pathogens. Others point out that most ancient microbes are adapted to long-gone hosts and environments, that viruses usually degrade over time, and that the germs that cause modern pandemics overwhelmingly come from living animals today, not from ice.

For the Guliya viruses in particular, there is no sign of a threat: they were detected as DNA, were not revived, and their likely hosts are soil and plant bacteria.

Myths and facts at a glance

  • Myth: Scientists woke up 15,000-year-old viruses. Fact: The Guliya study read viral DNA; nothing was revived or grown.
  • Myth: The viruses are dangerous to people. Fact: Their predicted hosts are bacteria, not humans.
  • Myth: The ice came from Siberian permafrost. Fact: It came from a high glacier on the Tibetan Plateau.
  • Myth: Bacteria tens of millions of years old have been brought back to life. Fact: Such claims exist but are heavily disputed because contamination is so hard to rule out, which is exactly why the Guliya team put so much work into clean sampling.

Why this still matters

The more useful lesson is about loss rather than danger. Tropical and mountain glaciers are shrinking fast, and the records stored inside them, from dust and pollen to microbes and viruses, melt away with them. Thompson's group has spent decades drilling these glaciers precisely because some may not survive the century.

Studies like this one also give microbiologists a baseline. By knowing what lived in the ice before modern human influence, researchers can better judge how climate change is reshaping microbial life today, and they can keep an informed eye on what thawing ice and soil might release.

Sources: Zhong et al., Microbiome, 20 July 2021: Glacier ice archives nearly 15,000-year-old microbes and phages; ScienceAlert: 15,000-year-old viruses from melting Tibetan glaciers; Wikipedia: Pithovirus; Wikipedia: Panagrolaimus kolymaensis; NPR via HPPR, 3 August 2016: Anthrax outbreak in Russia thought to be result of thawing permafrost.

COMMENTS