First published July 27, 2021.

Are Jeff Bezos and Richard Branson officially astronauts? The short answer is yes, at least as far as the US Federal Aviation Administration is concerned. In July 2021, just as both billionaires flew to the edge of space, the FAA tightened the rules for its Commercial Space Astronaut Wings, and many headlines concluded that neither man would qualify. A few months later the agency changed course, closed the programme and awarded wings to everyone who had flown that year, Bezos and Branson included.
Here is how the confusion arose, what the rules actually said, and why the word "astronaut" has never had one single definition.
Two billionaires, two different flights
Branson went first. On 11 July 2021, Virgin Galactic's carrier aircraft VMS Eve lifted the rocket plane VSS Unity to high altitude over New Mexico and released it. Unity's rocket motor fired and carried six people to about 86 km (53.5 miles) before gliding back to the runway. The flight, called Unity 22, had two pilots, Dave Mackay and Michael Masucci, an astronaut instructor, Beth Moses, and three passengers: Branson, Colin Bennett and Sirisha Bandla.
There are no words to describe the feeling. This is space travel. This is a dream turned reality https://t.co/Wyzj0nOBgX @VirginGalactic #Unity22 pic.twitter.com/moDvnFfXri
— Richard Branson (@richardbranson) July 12, 2021
Nine days later, on 20 July 2021, Bezos flew on New Shepard, the reusable rocket and capsule built by his company Blue Origin. The NS-16 mission lifted off from West Texas and reached about 107 km (66 miles) in a flight lasting just over ten minutes. With him were his brother Mark Bezos, 82-year-old aviation pioneer Wally Funk and 18-year-old Oliver Daemen, the oldest and youngest people to reach space at the time.
The vehicles were very different. Unity is flown by pilots in the cockpit. New Shepard is fully automated, with no one at the controls.
What the FAA changed in July 2021
The FAA had run its Commercial Space Astronaut Wings programme since 2004, when test pilot Mike Melvill flew SpaceShipOne. Originally the badge went to pilots and crew who flew above 50 statute miles on a licensed commercial launch.
On 20 July 2021, the same day as the Bezos flight, the agency issued an updated order. Besides reaching 50 miles, a recipient now had to be a member of the flight crew and to have carried out activities during the flight that were essential to public safety or contributed to human spaceflight safety. The order also said the FAA could refine the criteria at any time to protect the prestige of the award.
Bezos, Branson may not get official astronaut status after FAA changes policy https://t.co/wuqCGO9jOT pic.twitter.com/yMIuKNPuJJ
— The Hill (@thehill) July 25, 2021
Read literally, that seemed to exclude paying or invited passengers. Media outlets quickly asked whether the two founders had missed out.
Jeff Bezos went to the edge of space. Does that make him an astronaut? https://t.co/CGBYFhHP01 pic.twitter.com/YvrnsTuwV1
— SPACE.com (@SPACEdotcom) July 25, 2021
Why many said Bezos and Branson did not qualify
For Bezos the argument looked straightforward. New Shepard flies itself, and Blue Origin chief executive Bob Smith was quoted before the flight as saying: "There's really nothing for a crew member to go do." On that reading the passengers had no safety-critical role.
Branson's case was slightly different. Virgin Galactic presented his flight as a test of the customer experience before commercial service, with Branson's role framed as evaluating the experience future customers would have. Still, the pilots were the ones flying the vehicle, so most observers concluded that only Mackay and Masucci, who had already earned wings on earlier flights, clearly met the new standard.
There was also an escape clause. The updated rules allowed honorary wings for people whose contribution to commercial human spaceflight the FAA judged worthy of special recognition. That left the door open for founders whose companies had built the vehicles.
How the story actually ended
In December 2021, the FAA announced that it would stop issuing astronaut wings after 1 January 2022. Commercial spaceflight was becoming routine enough that a special badge no longer made sense. As a final step, the agency gave wings to all 15 people who had made their first private US spaceflight in 2021. Bezos and Branson were among them, along with the crew of SpaceX's Inspiration4 orbital mission and passengers such as William Shatner and Michael Strahan.
FAA associate administrator Wayne Monteith explained the decision: "Now it's time to offer recognition to a larger group of adventurers daring to go to space." In total the programme awarded 30 sets of wings, and the FAA's recognition list marks both founders as recipients.
Since 2022, anyone who flies above 50 miles on an FAA-licensed launch is simply added to a public list on the agency's website, without a pin.
Where does space begin?
The wings debate is tangled up with an older question: what altitude counts as space? There are two common answers.
- 50 miles (about 80 km). Used by the US Air Force, NASA and the FAA. Both Unity 22 and NS-16 passed this line.
- The Kármán line at 100 km (about 62 miles). Used by the Fédération Aéronautique Internationale, which keeps aviation records. New Shepard crossed it; Unity did not.
Blue Origin made a point of this during the rivalry between the companies, suggesting its flight was the "real" spaceflight. In practice both are suborbital hops of a few minutes of weightlessness, very different from orbiting the Earth for days or months.
Common myths about the "astronaut" title
Myth: The FAA decides who is an astronaut. It does not. The FAA wings were one agency's award for commercial flights. NASA, the military and other space agencies each have their own badges and definitions, and NASA astronauts still receive their pins from NASA.
Myth: Bezos and Branson were officially refused astronaut status. The July rules raised questions, but no one was formally rejected, and both men ended up on the official recipient list.
Myth: Paying customers are just tourists. Training for these suborbital flights is short compared with a career astronaut's, but passengers still undergo safety briefings and medical checks, and the risks are real. Companies such as Virgin Galactic and Blue Origin issue their own commemorative wings to everyone who flies.
A sensible way to describe the 2021 flyers is as commercial or private astronauts who made short suborbital flights. That is accurate without overstating what they did or dismissing it.
Sources: FAA: Commercial Human Space Flight Recognition; FAA Order 8800.2; KCRG / Associated Press, 11 December 2021; Wikipedia: Blue Origin NS-16; Wikipedia: Virgin Galactic Unity 22. Embedded posts: The Hill, Space.com and Richard Branson on Twitter.

COMMENTS