Originally published 2021-07-27.

The Analemma Tower is a speculative design, not a building under construction. Created by the New York studio Clouds Architecture Office (Clouds AO), it imagines a skyscraper that does not stand on the ground at all. Instead it hangs from an extremely strong cable attached to an asteroid parked in orbit high above Earth, and swings over the planet in a daily figure-eight path. The concept was first published in late 2016 and went viral in spring 2017, then resurfaced online again in 2021.
So what exactly did the architects propose, how would it supposedly work, and how close is any of it to reality? Here is a clear guide.
The idea in brief
Ordinary skyscrapers push down on foundations. The Analemma Tower flips that logic. Clouds AO calls its support a "Universal Orbital Support System": a space-elevator-style cable lowered from an anchor in orbit. In the design, that anchor is an asteroid captured and placed into an orbit over Earth. Many news reports at the time described the asteroid as sitting around 50,000 kilometres above the surface, though the studio's own project page does not give a figure.
Hanging from the cable would be a very tall, slender tower with homes, offices, restaurants and shops, much like a vertical city. The architects suggested the building could be put together over Dubai, which they chose because the city has deep experience of tall construction at lower cost than New York, and then moved into position.
Why it would trace a figure eight
The name comes from astronomy. An analemma is the figure-eight shape the Sun appears to trace in the sky if you photograph it at the same time of day across a year. The tower borrows that shape for its daily route.
Clouds AO proposed placing the asteroid in an eccentric geosynchronous orbit. A geosynchronous orbit takes the same time as one rotation of the Earth, so the anchor returns to the same position in the sky every day. Because this orbit would be tilted and stretched rather than perfectly circular, the tower would not stay fixed above one spot but would loop north and south each day, drawing a figure eight on the ground below.
At the top and bottom of the loop the tower would move most slowly. The studio calibrated its imagined orbit so that one of these slow points would be over New York City, letting people and goods transfer between the tower and the ground there. Reports described the route passing over the south-eastern United States, the Caribbean and parts of South America.
Living in a tower that hangs from space
The project sketches how daily life might work at extreme height:
- Power would come from solar panels mounted above the thick lower atmosphere, where sunlight is stronger and steadier than at ground level.
- Water would run through a semi-closed recycling loop, topped up by moisture collected from clouds and rain.
- Lifts would use cable-less electromagnetic systems, which the studio argues remove the height limits set by conventional lift cables.
- Daylight would last longer near the top. The project page mentions roughly 40 to 45 extra minutes of daylight at the highest levels, because the sun sets later the higher you are.
The designers were open about the harsh conditions at the top: near-vacuum air pressure and temperatures around minus 40 degrees Celsius, which would demand sealed, pressurised spaces. Coverage at the time also noted the tongue-in-cheek suggestion that residents could descend by parachute when the tower passed low over Manhattan.
How realistic is it?
Put simply, the Analemma Tower is a thought experiment. Several huge problems stand in the way:
- Materials. A space-elevator cable needs a strength-to-weight ratio far beyond steel. Carbon nanotubes and graphene are often mentioned, but nobody can yet make them in the lengths and quality required.
- Moving an asteroid. Capturing a large asteroid and placing it in a precise orbit near Earth is far beyond anything attempted so far, and would raise serious safety questions.
- Dynamics. A structure dragged through the atmosphere on a daily path would face winds, weather and enormous forces at its lower end.
- Safety and law. A falling cable or a drifting asteroid would be a disaster, and no legal framework exists for building anchored structures in orbit.
That does not make the project pointless. Speculative architecture like this helps designers and the public think about how cities might work in the far future, and it often borrows from real research. Clouds AO itself has worked on serious space concepts, including a Mars habitat idea called the Mars Ice House, developed for a NASA design competition.
The NASA asteroid mission the architects cited
The architects pointed to NASA's planned Asteroid Redirect Mission as a sign that moving asteroids was becoming realistic. That mission, proposed in 2013, would have robotically grabbed a boulder of up to about four metres from a near-Earth asteroid and moved it into orbit around the Moon, with a launch then targeted for December 2021.
It never flew. NASA's 2018 budget proposal called for cancelling it, and the agency announced its closeout on 13 June 2017. Some of its technology, notably the advanced solar-electric propulsion system, carried over into later lunar plans. So when the tower made the rounds again in 2021, the claim that NASA would redirect an asteroid that year was already out of date.
Asteroid science has moved on in other ways since then. In 2022 NASA's DART spacecraft deliberately crashed into the small moonlet Dimorphos and measurably changed its orbit, the first real test of nudging an asteroid. That is a planetary-defence experiment, a long way from hanging a city from a rock, but it shows the field is real.
What the Analemma Tower tells us
Concepts like this become popular because they combine a striking image with a question everyone can grasp: what if a building did not need the ground? Read them as invitations to imagine, not as construction plans. The engineering challenges are huge, but they point to genuine research fields, from ultra-strong materials to orbital mechanics and closed-loop life support.
If you enjoy designs like this, our pieces on floating ocean-cleanup towers and on the DART mission, linked below, explore other ambitious ideas, some purely imaginative and some already tested in space.
Sources: Clouds Architecture Office: Analemma Tower; 6sqft: Supertall skyscraper dangles from an asteroid (March 2017); Wikipedia: Asteroid Redirect Mission. Renderings and video © Clouds Architecture Office; story originally spotted via IFLScience.

COMMENTS