
Little penguins disappeared from Maria Island, off Tasmania's east coast, after Tasmanian devils were released there in 2012 as a disease-free "insurance" population. BirdLife Tasmania reported in 2021 that a colony once estimated at about 3,000 breeding pairs, roughly 6,000 adult birds, could no longer be found, and its convenor, Dr Eric Woehler, blamed predation by the devils. The case has become a textbook example of how a well-meant rescue of one threatened species can harm others.
To understand how this happened, it helps to look at why the devils were moved, what kind of place Maria Island is, and what ecologists have learned about introducing predators to islands.
Why the devils were sent to Maria Island
The Tasmanian devil, the world's largest surviving carnivorous marsupial, has been devastated by devil facial tumour disease (DFTD). This is one of very few known contagious cancers: tumour cells pass from one animal to another, mainly through bites during feeding and mating. The disease is thought to have emerged in the mid-1980s, was first described in 1996 in north-eastern Tasmania, and is almost always fatal. Over about two decades the wild population fell by around 80 percent overall, and by more than 90 percent in some areas. A second, unrelated tumour line, known as DFT2, was detected in 2014 in southern Tasmania.
Conservationists responded with an "insurance population", a backup of healthy devils kept away from the disease. Most were held in zoos and wildlife parks on the mainland, but scientists also wanted a free-living population that would keep its wild behaviour. Maria Island, separated from Tasmania by a channel only about 4 km wide at its closest point and free of DFTD, looked ideal. Starting in November 2012, devils were released there, and the population grew from 28 founders to around 90 animals.
Maria Island and its birds
Maria Island covers about 115 square kilometres and the whole island is a national park, proclaimed in 1971. Its convict settlement at Darlington is part of the Australian Convict Sites World Heritage listing. Because it had no foxes, and no devils before 2012, it was considered a refuge for ground-nesting birds. Several animals, including Cape Barren geese, eastern grey kangaroos and red-necked wallabies, were introduced there in the late 1960s and early 1970s when the park was being created.
The little penguin (Eudyptula minor) is the smallest penguin species, standing about 30 to 33 cm tall and weighing around 1.5 kg. It lives along the coasts of southern Australia and New Zealand and nests in burrows, rock crevices and under vegetation close to the shore. On land, especially at night when the adults come ashore and when eggs and chicks sit in burrows, these birds are extremely vulnerable to mammal predators.
What BirdLife Tasmania reported
In June 2021, a BirdLife Tasmania survey found that the Maria Island colony had gone. The decline had reportedly been visible since the devils arrived. Dr Woehler told the Guardian, as quoted by IFLScience, that every time mammals have been introduced to oceanic islands, the outcome has been a catastrophic impact on one or more bird species, and he called the loss of 3,000 pairs from a national park "a major blow".
He also described indirect effects. According to reports reaching BirdLife, Cape Barren geese were trying to nest in trees, apparently to keep their eggs away from the devils. In his words, the devils had a "catastrophic ecological impact on the bird fauna on Maria Island".
It is worth being precise about the figure in many headlines. "6,000 penguins wiped out" is an estimate based on the number of breeding pairs before the release, not a count of birds known to have been eaten. Some birds may have died, others may have failed to breed or moved elsewhere. What is clear is that the breeding colony no longer exists, and devils are the most likely main cause.
A familiar pattern on islands
Woehler's point reflects one of the best-established findings in conservation science. Island birds often evolve without ground predators, so they nest in the open or in shallow burrows and have weak escape behaviour. When cats, rats, foxes, stoats or other mammals arrive, losses can be rapid. Introduced predators are a leading cause of bird extinctions on islands worldwide.
New Zealand is the standard example. Common brushtail possums were brought over from Australia in the mid-19th century to start a fur trade; the first release is often dated to 1837, while some records point to around 1840. Possums browse native forest heavily and eat birds' eggs and chicks. Kiwi have suffered even more from stoats, cats and dogs, and the combined pressure of introduced mammals has pushed many native birds into decline. Little penguins themselves are listed as "at risk, declining" in New Zealand, even though the species as a whole is rated Least Concern by the IUCN.
The Maria Island case is unusual only in that the predator was introduced deliberately, by conservationists, to save a threatened native species.
Was the relocation a mistake?
There is no simple answer. The island population did what it was meant to do for the devils: it gave them a healthy, wild-living reserve while the disease spread on the main island. Captive-born devils released there survived well. On the other hand, the loss of a large penguin colony inside a national park is a real cost, and critics argue that the risk to ground-nesting birds should have been weighed more heavily and monitored more closely from the start.
The lesson most ecologists draw is that a translocation should be judged by its effect on the whole receiving ecosystem, not only on the species being rescued. That means surveying the existing wildlife before a release, setting clear warning signs that would trigger action, and being ready to manage or remove animals if those signs appear.
What this means for future rescues
- Check the neighbours first. Before moving a predator, find out which local species have never lived alongside it.
- Monitor both sides. Track the released animals and the species that might be affected.
- Plan an exit. Decide in advance what would happen if the impact proves too high.
- Report numbers carefully. Distinguish estimated colony size from confirmed losses, so that public debate rests on solid figures.
The Tasmanian devil still needs help, and DFTD remains a serious threat. The penguins of Maria Island show that saving one species is rarely a single-species decision.
Sources: The Guardian (21 June 2021); IFLScience, Rachael Funnell (21 June 2021); Wikipedia: Maria Island; Wikipedia: Devil facial tumour disease; Wikipedia: Little penguin; Wikipedia: Common brushtail possum in New Zealand.

COMMENTS