Putin on Biden's 'Killer' Remark: What He Said After Geneva 2021

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-06-18. Dates, ages and announcements in this article refer to June 2021.

Putin's 2021 Account of Biden's Explanation for a Remark

After meeting Joe Biden in Geneva on 16 June 2021, Vladimir Putin told reporters that Biden had phoned him after calling him a "killer" in a television interview, that the two had discussed it, and that he was satisfied with the explanation. That is Putin's account of a private call; the White House did not publish its own version of what Biden said, so the exact wording of the explanation is not on the public record.

The episode was a small part of a much larger diplomatic story. Here is how the "killer" remark came about, what it cost the two countries diplomatically, what happened at the Geneva summit, and how to read Putin's words.

The interview that started it

In March 2021, Biden gave an interview to ABC News' George Stephanopoulos. It came shortly after a US intelligence assessment concluded that the Kremlin had tried to influence the 2020 presidential election in favour of Donald Trump. Asked whether he thought Putin was a killer, Biden answered "Mm-hmm, I do," according to NPR's report, and said Putin would pay a price for the interference.

The question echoed accusations that had been building for years, including the poisoning of opposition politician Alexei Navalny in 2020, which Western governments blamed on Russian state agents. The Kremlin denied involvement.

Putin responded on Russian television with a schoolyard phrase, "it takes one to know one," and pointed to slavery and the treatment of Native Americans in US history. He also wished Biden good health and challenged him to a live, publicly broadcast conversation.

Ambassadors called home

The remark had concrete consequences. Russia's Foreign Ministry recalled its ambassador in Washington, Anatoly Antonov, to Moscow for consultations, saying it wanted to prevent an irreversible deterioration in relations. A month later, the US ambassador in Moscow, John Sullivan, also returned to Washington for consultations after Russian officials suggested he do so.

For several weeks in spring 2021, neither country had its ambassador in the other's capital, at a time when relations were already strained by sanctions, cyberattacks and a Russian military build-up near Ukraine.

The Geneva summit

The two presidents met on 16 June 2021 at Villa La Grange, an 18th-century villa in a park beside Lake Geneva. It was their first meeting as counterparts. The talks lasted roughly three and a half hours, less than had been scheduled, in two sessions, with Secretary of State Antony Blinken and Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov present at the first.

The results were modest but real:

  • Ambassadors would return to their posts in Washington and Moscow.
  • Talks on strategic stability, covering nuclear arms control, would begin.
  • Consultations on cybersecurity were agreed, after a wave of ransomware attacks on US companies. Biden said he warned Putin about the consequences of future attacks.
  • There was no breakthrough on Ukraine or on Navalny, who was in prison.

The two leaders held separate press conferences afterwards rather than a joint one, a choice the US side made to avoid giving Putin a shared stage.

What Putin said about the "killer" remark

At his own news conference, Putin was asked about the March interview. He said that he and Biden had spoken by phone after it and exchanged views. In Reuters' translation, he summed up the result simply: "These explanations suited me."

He then turned the subject around, as he often does when human rights come up. He accused US authorities of rights abuses at home, criticised the American response to the 6 January Capitol riot, and pointed to civilians killed in US military operations in Afghanistan and Iraq, asking who should be held responsible for those deaths and, in effect, who the real murderer was.

Biden, in his separate press conference, said he had raised human rights with Putin and that abuses were damaging Russia's international standing.

How to read Putin's account

Two things are worth keeping apart.

First, the phone call. Biden and Putin did speak by phone in spring 2021, and the White House publicly described calls between them. But Putin's statement that Biden explained the remark, and that the explanation satisfied him, is a description from one side. Biden never publicly withdrew the word.

Second, the accusations. Putin's comments about Iraq, Afghanistan and US policing were political statements made at a press conference. Some refer to well-documented events, such as civilian deaths in both wars, but they were offered as a counter-attack rather than as part of any agreed account of the summit.

Reading the exchange this way helps explain why Putin could say he was satisfied while relations stayed cold. Presenting the matter as settled allowed both sides to return their ambassadors without either one appearing to back down.

What came next

The calm after Geneva did not last. Within a year, Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. In March 2022, Biden called Putin a war criminal, and the Kremlin condemned the remark as unforgivable. The dialogue started in Geneva effectively collapsed, and relations sank to their lowest point since the Cold War.

Seen with hindsight, the June 2021 summit was a brief attempt to put a floor under a deteriorating relationship. Putin's remark about being satisfied with Biden's explanation is best understood as diplomatic positioning at that moment, not as a sign that the underlying disputes had been resolved.

Sources: Wikipedia: 2021 Russia–United States summit; NPR, 18 March 2021: "It takes one to know one," Putin says after Biden agrees he is a killer; Putin's press-conference remarks as reported by Reuters, 16 June 2021.

COMMENTS