Originally published 2021-06-20.
In December 2020, Haim Eshed, the retired general who ran Israel's military space programme for nearly three decades, told the Israeli newspaper Yedioth Ahronoth that aliens from a "Galactic Federation" were in contact with the United States and Israel, had asked for their existence to be kept secret, and shared an underground base on Mars with American astronauts. He made the claims while promoting a new book of conversations with him.
There is no evidence for any of it. No government, space agency or astronaut has backed the story, and the head of Israel's space agency said Eshed had gone too far. Here is who Eshed is, exactly what he claimed, and why a distinguished career does not turn an extraordinary claim into a fact.
Who Haim Eshed is
Eshed, born in 1933, is a retired brigadier general from Israeli military intelligence and an engineer trained at the Technion, Israel's Institute of Technology, where he also taught. In 1979, as a colonel, he pushed for Israel to develop its own reconnaissance satellites. He went on to direct space programmes at the Ministry of Defense for close to 30 years and is often called the father of Israel's space programme, credited with overseeing the launch of around 20 Israeli-made satellites, including the Ofek spy satellites. He won the Israel Defense Prize three times and retired around 2010–2011.
That record is why the interview made headlines worldwide. It was not an anonymous internet post but a man who had held one of the most sensitive technical jobs in Israel's defence establishment.
What he actually claimed
In the Hebrew-language interview, later picked up by the Jewish Press and then by outlets around the world, Eshed made several connected claims:
- A "Galactic Federation" of extraterrestrials had been in contact with the U.S. and Israeli governments for years and had asked them to keep it quiet, because humanity was not ready.
- The U.S. government had signed an agreement allowing the aliens to carry out experiments on Earth. In his words, the aliens "want us as helpers" in understanding the universe.
- There was a joint underground base deep beneath the surface of Mars, staffed by alien representatives and American astronauts.
- Donald Trump, then U.S. president, knew all of this and had been on the verge of announcing it, but the aliens asked him to wait to avoid mass hysteria.
Eshed acknowledged how this sounded. He said that had he spoken out five years earlier, "I would have been hospitalized," and argued that academia was now more open to the subject and that, having already earned his degrees and awards, he had nothing to lose.
The book behind the interview
The timing was not random. In November 2020 a Hebrew book was published called The Universe Beyond the Horizon: Conversations with Professor Haim Eshed, written by Hagar Yanai. Besides the Galactic Federation story, it reportedly includes claims that aliens had stepped in to prevent nuclear disasters. Several commentators, including the British UFO writer Nick Pope, suggested the interview might be a joke, a publicity push for the book, or a genuine insider breaking ranks, and noted that only the last option would be news.
How officials and scientists responded
Isaac Ben-Israel, then chairman of the Israel Space Agency, said Eshed had gone too far. He added that Eshed had for a long time interpreted unexplained signals from space in unconventional ways that most specialists regard as natural phenomena. NASA, asked about the claims, said it had not found any signs of extraterrestrial life, while continuing to search for it. Neither the White House nor the Pentagon confirmed anything Eshed said, and Trump left office in January 2021 without any such announcement.
Science writers pointed out practical problems. Eshed had been retired for about a decade, so a cover-up would have had to hold for at least that long. A secret Mars base would require launches, supplies and crews that would be hard to hide from amateur astronomers, foreign intelligence agencies and the thousands of engineers who work on space programmes. And no astronaut has ever described such a mission.
Why credentials do not settle a claim
It is natural to trust experts, and Eshed is a genuine expert in satellites and defence engineering. But expertise in one field is not evidence in another, and a claim's truth depends on what can be checked, not on who makes it. Extraordinary claims need evidence that others can examine: documents, data, photographs, or confirmation from independent people with first-hand knowledge. Eshed offered none.
It is also worth separating two different things. Serious research into the possibility of life elsewhere is real science, from NASA's rovers searching for ancient microbial life on Mars to radio telescopes listening for signals. Claims of a hidden treaty with aliens are a different kind of statement, and they rest on personal testimony alone.
Common myths around the story
- "Israel's government confirmed aliens." No. Eshed was retired and spoke for himself; Israeli officials distanced themselves from his claims.
- "He was the head of Israel's space agency." He led the Defense Ministry's military space programme. The civilian Israel Space Agency is a separate body, and its chairman criticised him.
- "Trump was about to reveal everything." This comes only from Eshed. Nothing was announced, and no record supports it.
- "U.S. UFO reports prove him right." U.S. government reports on unidentified aerial phenomena describe objects that remain unexplained, which is not the same as confirming visitors from other worlds.
Eshed's story remains a curious footnote: a respected engineer making claims that no one has been able to support. Curiosity about life in the universe is healthy; it is best fed by evidence.
Sources: Wikipedia: Haim Eshed; IFLScience, 8 December 2020; The Week, 9 December 2020. Interview first published by Yedioth Ahronoth.

COMMENTS