XPRIZE Carbon Removal: Musk’s $100 Million Prize and Its Winners

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published May 1, 2021.

The $100 Million XPRIZE Carbon Removal Competition Launched in 2021

XPRIZE Carbon Removal was a four-year, $100 million competition funded by Elon Musk’s charitable foundation to find practical ways of pulling carbon dioxide out of the air or oceans and locking it away for the long term. It launched on Earth Day, 22 April 2021, and ended in April 2025, when the $50 million grand prize went to Mati Carbon, a company that spreads crushed basalt rock on farmland.

At the time it was billed as the largest incentive prize in history. This page covers how the competition worked, why carbon removal gets so much attention, who won, and the caveats scientists attach to the whole idea.

How the competition worked

XPRIZE, the non-profit known for the space-flight prize that helped launch commercial spaceflight, designed the challenge. Teams could compete in any approach, but they had to meet hard targets:

  • Remove at least 1,000 tonnes of CO2 in the real world during the competition, not just in a lab.
  • Show a credible model of how their method could reach megatonne scale (a million tonnes a year) and point towards gigatonne scale.
  • Aim for a cost below $100 per tonne removed.
  • Account for how long the carbon stays stored, plus land and water use, energy inputs and full life-cycle emissions.

Removals had to be net: if a machine burned fossil energy to run, those emissions were subtracted. Judges also weighed transparency and the potential to scale quickly.

XPRIZE’s own pitch for open competitions is that good solutions can come from anywhere. As its website put it, “The world needs crazy ideas.”

How the $100 million was split

The purse was spread over several stages rather than paid as a single cheque:

  • Student awards, $5 million: announced in November 2021, with $250,000 grants for 18 student demonstration teams and $100,000 for five teams working on measurement technology.
  • Milestone awards, $15 million: fifteen $1 million awards announced on Earth Day 2022 to help promising teams build their demonstrations.
  • Grand prize, $50 million, plus $30 million shared among the runners-up.

Some early reports in 2021 suggested each runner-up would get $30 million. In fact the $30 million was a pool divided among the three runners-up, with the largest share, $15 million, going to second place.

Why carbon removal matters

Carbon dioxide is the main greenhouse gas released by human activity. It lets sunlight in but traps some of the heat that the Earth radiates back, so rising concentrations warm the planet. That warming drives more intense heatwaves and heavy rain, rising seas and loss of ice.

Cutting emissions is the first priority, but climate scientists widely expect that some CO2 will also need to be removed from the atmosphere to meet the goals of the Paris Agreement. Some industries, such as aviation and cement, are hard to decarbonise fully, and removal could balance what remains. The problem is that today’s removal methods are small and often expensive, which is exactly the gap the prize targeted.

The field of competitors

Interest was huge. By the milestone stage, 1,133 teams had registered, 287 met the eligibility criteria and 60 reached final review. Over the full competition more than 1,300 teams from 88 countries took part.

The milestone winners were grouped into four tracks, which give a good overview of the main approaches:

  • Air: direct air capture machines, including 8 Rivers Capital, Carbyon, Heirloom with Carbfix, Project Hajar, Sustaera, and Verdox with Carbfix.
  • Land: biological methods such as biochar and algae, including NetZero, Global Algae Innovations, PlantVillage, the Bioeconomy Institute team, and Takachar with Safi Organics.
  • Ocean: methods using seawater or marine plants, including Captura, Marine Permaculture SeaForestation and Planetary.
  • Rocks: mineralisation that turns CO2 into stable carbonates, represented by Carbin Minerals.

The 2025 winners

XPRIZE announced the results on 23 April 2025.

  • Grand prize ($50 million): Mati Carbon. It uses enhanced rock weathering. Finely ground basalt is spread on farm fields, mainly on smallholder farms in India. Rainwater carrying dissolved CO2 reacts with the rock and turns it into bicarbonate, which eventually washes into the ocean, where it can stay stored for around 10,000 years. The rock dust also releases nutrients that can improve soil and crop yields. Chief executive Shantanu Agarwal said the low-cost approach could help small farmers who bear the brunt of climate change.
  • First runner-up ($15 million): NetZero, which turns crop waste such as coffee husks into biochar, a charcoal-like material that holds carbon in soil.
  • Further runners-up: Vaulted Deep, which injects organic waste deep underground, and UNDO Carbon, another rock-weathering company.
  • Special awards: Planetary (ocean track) and Project Hajar (air track) received XFACTOR awards.

Caveats and common misunderstandings

The prize was sponsored by the Musk Foundation, and Musk announced the funding, but XPRIZE says it is not formally affiliated with the foundation. A few clarifications are worth keeping in mind:

  • Removal is not a replacement for cutting emissions. The competition’s technical lead, Michael Leitch, said, “It’s important that we not promote carbon dioxide removal as a replacement for emissions reduction.”
  • Winning is not the same as scaling. Leitch also noted that methods such as direct air and ocean capture, which did not win, may have advantages at very large scale but take much more time and money to build.
  • Measurement is hard. For rock weathering in particular, confirming exactly how much CO2 was removed in open fields is an active area of research.
  • Carbon capture and carbon removal differ. Capturing CO2 at a smokestack prevents new emissions; removal takes out CO2 that is already in the air.

Former NOAA administrator Rick Spinrad, quoted by AP, said the best path will likely combine several technologies. The prize showed that a wide range of approaches can remove real carbon at the thousand-tonne level. The open question for the coming decade is which of them can reach millions and then billions of tonnes at an affordable price, while emissions themselves fall.

Sources: XPRIZE: Carbon Removal prize page; XPRIZE, 22 April 2022: $15M milestone awards; AP via News4Jax, 23 April 2025: $50 million prize goes to Mati Carbon; Entrepreneur (original tip)

COMMENTS