Black Fungus in India: Why Mucormycosis Hit Covid Patients

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-05-10.

In May 2021, at the height of India's devastating second Covid-19 wave, doctors in Mumbai, Delhi, Gujarat and other places began reporting a sharp rise in mucormycosis, a rare and aggressive fungal infection that the Indian media nicknamed "black fungus". It mostly struck people who had Covid-19 or had just recovered from it, especially those with diabetes and those treated with steroids. The infection can destroy tissue around the nose, eyes and brain, and without fast treatment it kills about half of people with the sinus form. It is not contagious.

Mucormycosis Cases During India's 2021 COVID-19 Wave

What doctors saw in spring 2021

Before the pandemic, many specialists in India saw only a handful of mucormycosis cases a year. During the second wave, ear, nose and throat surgeons and eye specialists said they were suddenly treating them every week. Dr Akshay Nair, an eye surgeon in Mumbai, told the BBC in early May that he had already seen around 40 patients with the infection, several of whom reportedly needed an eye removed to stop the infection spreading. Doctors in other cities described similar clusters.

The cases arrived on top of a health system already at breaking point. India became the first country to record more than 400,000 new Covid-19 infections in a single day on 30 April 2021, hospitals ran short of beds and medical oxygen, and by 24 May the official death toll had passed 300,000. In late May the central government asked states to make mucormycosis a notifiable disease so that every case would be reported, and several states declared it an epidemic. By July, officials reported more than 4,300 deaths linked to it.

What mucormycosis is

Mucormycosis is caused by moulds of the order Mucorales, most often species of Rhizopus and Mucor. These moulds are everywhere: in soil, compost, rotting fruit and the air. Most people breathe in their spores every day without any harm, because a healthy immune system clears them.

Trouble starts when the immune defences are weakened. The spores then germinate, usually in the sinuses or lungs, and the fungus invades blood vessels. That blocks blood supply, so the surrounding tissue dies and turns black, which is where the nickname comes from. The main forms are named by where the infection takes hold:

  • Rhino-orbital-cerebral: sinuses, eye socket and brain. This was the dominant form in India's Covid-linked cases.
  • Pulmonary: the lungs.
  • Cutaneous: skin, often after wounds or burns.
  • Gastrointestinal and disseminated, when it spreads through the bloodstream.

Why Covid-19 patients were vulnerable

Doctors pointed to a combination of three factors, summed up in a widely quoted line from Dr Nair: Diabetes lowers the body's immune defences, coronavirus exacerbates it, and then steroids which help fight Covid-19 act like fuel to the fire.

Diabetes

Poorly controlled diabetes, and especially diabetic ketoacidosis, is the biggest known risk factor for this infection. High blood sugar and acidic blood make it easier for the fungus to grow and harder for white blood cells to fight it. India has one of the largest populations of people with diabetes in the world, many of them undiagnosed.

Steroids

Corticosteroids such as dexamethasone save lives in severe Covid-19 by calming the immune system's overreaction. But they also raise blood sugar and suppress immunity. Doctors and the WHO warned that steroids were sometimes being given to people with mild illness, at high doses or for too long, which increased the risk without the benefit.

Covid-19 itself

The virus damages the lining of the airways and disrupts immune responses, and very sick patients spend long periods in hospital. Researchers also examined factors such as reused oxygen equipment and humidifier water, but these remained less clearly established than diabetes and steroids.

India also had a higher baseline rate of mucormycosis than most countries even before the pandemic, estimated at many times the rates reported in Europe or the United States.

Warning signs to know

Early recognition matters because the infection moves fast. Health authorities listed signs including:

  • pain, swelling or numbness on one side of the face;
  • blocked or bloody nose, or black-coloured discharge;
  • headache, fever and pain around the eyes or cheeks;
  • blurred or double vision, drooping eyelid or a bulging eye;
  • dark patches on the bridge of the nose or the roof of the mouth, or loosening teeth;
  • cough, chest pain or coughing up blood when the lungs are involved.

Anyone who has had Covid-19 and notices these symptoms, especially with diabetes or after steroid treatment, should talk to a doctor straight away rather than wait.

Treatment and outcomes

Mucormycosis is treated in hospital, usually with three things at once: an intravenous antifungal drug, most often amphotericin B; surgery to remove all dead and infected tissue; and control of the underlying problem, such as bringing blood sugar down. Isavuconazole and posaconazole are alternative antifungals.

The surgery can be disfiguring. Surgeons sometimes have to remove part of the jaw, the palate or an eye to stop the fungus reaching the brain. Even with treatment, about half of people with the sinus form die, about two-thirds with the lung form, and nearly all when it has spread through the body. During the 2021 surge, demand for amphotericin B far exceeded supply, and the government moved to increase production and imports.

Myths and misunderstandings

  • "It spreads from person to person." It does not. The spores come from the environment, not from other patients.
  • "Black fungus is a new disease caused by Covid." It has been known for well over a century. Covid-19 created the conditions for more cases, not a new organism.
  • "White fungus" and "yellow fungus". These labels circulated in Indian media in 2021 for other fungal infections. They are not separate, more dangerous strains, and colour-based names caused confusion.
  • "Home remedies can treat it." They cannot. It needs urgent hospital care.

The best protection is the advice doctors repeated throughout 2021: keep diabetes under control, use steroids only when a doctor prescribes them for the right patients, and seek help quickly if warning signs appear.

Sources: BBC News, May 2021 (Dr Akshay Nair); Wikipedia: Mucormycosis; WHO India: Mucormycosis; CDC: About mucormycosis; Wikipedia: COVID-19 pandemic in India.

COMMENTS