Originally published 2021-05-14.
In May 2021 the British Museum handed a looted ancient marble statue back to Libya at the Libyan Embassy in London. The hooded female figure, believed to show the goddess Persephone or her mother Demeter, had been dug illegally out of a tomb at Cyrene, near the modern town of Shahhat, in about 2012, and was seized by UK Border Force at Heathrow Airport. After a British court ruled in 2015 that it belonged to the state of Libya, the museum cared for it until it could be returned. It was valued at around £1.5 million.

The statue and how it reached London
The sculpture is a three-quarter-length marble figure, roughly four feet (1.2 m) tall, that ends at the hips. The woman is veiled, wears bracelets in the shape of snakes and holds an offering. British Museum curator Peter Higgs described it as one of the best examples of its type and extremely rare. Only a handful of these figures exist outside Libya; most remain in the Cyrene Museum and the National Museum in Tripoli.
Its age is given differently in different reports. Some coverage dated it to the third or fourth century BC, about 2,300 years ago, while the Museums Association described it as around 2,000 years old. Either way, it belongs to a long tradition of funerary statues made in Cyrenaica, the eastern region of Libya.
The statue arrived in Britain as an illegal import and was seized at Heathrow. In 2013 British Museum staff were asked to help identify it. They noticed that its surface looked fresh, suggesting it had been out of the ground for only a few years, probably since the upheaval of 2011, and they alerted HM Revenue and Customs. In 2015 museum experts gave evidence for the prosecution, and the judge ruled that the sculpture was the property of Libya. Contrary to some headlines, the museum never bought it or held it as part of its collection.
Who was Persephone, and why Demeter too
In Greek myth, Persephone was the daughter of Zeus and Demeter, goddess of grain and the harvest. Hades, ruler of the underworld, carried her off to be his queen, and Demeter's grief made the earth barren until a compromise let Persephone return for part of each year. The Greeks used the story to explain the seasons.
The two goddesses were worshipped together across the Greek world, and their cult was closely tied to farming, fertility and the cycle of life and death. That link to the afterlife made them natural figures for tombs. Because mother and daughter were often shown in similar ways, experts cannot always tell which one a statue like this represents, which is why the British Museum named both.
Cyrene: a Greek city in Libya
Cyrene was one of the most important Greek cities in Africa. According to Greek tradition, settlers from the island of Thera, today's Santorini, led by a man named Battus, founded it in 631 BC on a fertile plateau a few miles from the Mediterranean coast. It became the leading city of the Pentapolis, a group of five Greek cities that gave the region of Cyrenaica its name.
The city grew rich partly on silphium, a plant valued as a medicine and seasoning that appeared on its coins and was harvested to extinction by Roman times. It also produced thinkers: Aristippus founded the Cyrenaic school of philosophy, which taught that pleasure is the highest good; the poet Callimachus and the scholar Eratosthenes, who first estimated the Earth's circumference, were born there.
Cyrene came under Roman rule in 96 BC. It was badly damaged during a Jewish revolt in AD 115 and later by earthquakes, including the great quake of AD 365 that destroyed its Temple of Zeus. Its ruins, including the Sanctuary of Apollo, a theatre and one of the largest Greek cemeteries known, were declared a UNESCO World Heritage Site in 1982.
Looting after 2011
The fall of Muammar Gaddafi in 2011 and the conflict that followed left many of Libya's archaeological sites without protection. Cyrene's vast necropolis, with thousands of rock-cut and built tombs, proved an easy target for looters searching for statues and other objects to sell abroad. Parts of the cemetery were also bulldozed in 2013 as the modern town of Shahhat expanded. UNESCO has since placed Cyrene on its List of World Heritage in Danger.
Looted antiquities are a particular loss because they are ripped out of their setting. An archaeologist who excavated this statue properly would have recorded which tomb it came from, who was buried there and what was found with it. Once an object is dug up in secret, that information is usually gone for good, even if the object itself is later recovered.
The return, and the wider debate
The handover took place at the Libyan Embassy in London, where a Libyan diplomat and British Museum curator Peter Higgs signed a handover document. Museum director Hartwig Fischer said: "The British Museum is absolutely committed to the fight against illicit trade and damage to cultural heritage."
The case shows how museums can help in the fight against trafficking: specialist curators can recognise a recently looted object, alert customs and support a prosecution. It also sits within a much larger argument about objects that museums do hold in their collections, such as the Parthenon Sculptures that Greece has long asked the British Museum to return. The Libyan statue was a clearer case, since it was never part of the collection and a court had already ruled on its ownership.
For readers, the takeaway is simple: buying antiquities without a documented history can fund this kind of looting. Reputable dealers and auction houses publish an object's provenance, and any piece said to come from a conflict zone such as Libya, Syria or Iraq should be treated with great caution.
Sources: Museums Association, May 2021: illegally excavated statue returned to Libya; Greek Reporter, 10 May 2021; Wikipedia: Cyrene, Libya.

COMMENTS