Chinese Party Weibo Post Mocking India's Covid Crisis Deleted

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-05-03.

The 2021 Controversy Over a Chinese Post About India's COVID-19 Crisis

On the afternoon of Saturday 1 May 2021, as India was recording more new Covid-19 infections each day than any country had ever reported, a Weibo account run by a body of the Chinese Communist Party posted two pictures side by side: a Chinese rocket lifting off, and funeral pyres burning in India. The caption contrasted China "lighting a fire" with India "lighting a fire". The post was deleted after a wave of criticism, much of it from Chinese internet users and from a prominent state-media editor.

Here is what the post showed, who was behind it, why it caused anger even inside China, and the wider context of India's devastating second wave and the strained relationship between the two countries.

What the post showed

The image paired a photograph of a Long March 5B rocket, which had just launched the core module of China's Tiangong space station at the end of April 2021, with a night-time photograph of mass cremations in India, watched by workers in protective suits. A hashtag noted that India's daily cases had passed 400,000.

The juxtaposition hit a particular nerve. Cremation is a central rite in Hinduism, the faith of most Indians, and in spring 2021 crematoriums in cities such as Delhi were so overwhelmed that families faced long waits and extra pyres had to be set up in open ground. Using those scenes as a punchline for a national-pride message struck many readers as cruel.

Who posted it, and why that mattered

The account belonged to the Central Political and Legal Affairs Commission, the Communist Party organ that oversees the police, the courts and prosecutors. That is not a fringe nationalist blogger; it is an official account of a powerful party body. Several other government accounts run by local police and courts reportedly shared the same pictures.

The source matters for fairness, too. The post reflected the judgement of whoever ran one institutional account, and the reaction that followed showed that it did not speak for Chinese people in general. Treating it as the voice of a whole nation would repeat the same mistake the post made about India.

Backlash inside China

Many Weibo users criticised the post, asking why a government account would use other people's suffering to boast about national achievements, and some called it a disrespect for human life. The most notable critic was Hu Xijin, then editor-in-chief of the Global Times, a state-run tabloid known for its nationalist tone. He argued that it was not appropriate for official accounts to mock India at such a moment, and urged China to raise the banner of humanitarianism and show sympathy for India.

The post and a related hashtag were removed. Analysts read the deletion as a sign of disapproval from higher up in the party, at a time when Beijing was trying to present itself as a helpful neighbour. Commentators also linked the episode to the combative online style of Chinese officials often called "wolf warrior" diplomacy, which had produced several earlier controversies, including a doctored image of an Australian soldier in 2020.

India's second wave in spring 2021

India had come through its first wave in 2020 with a lower death toll than many had feared, and by early 2021 there was a sense that the worst had passed. Then infections exploded. On 30 April 2021 India became the first country to record more than 400,000 new cases in a single day, and official figures showed roughly 3,500 deaths a day at the start of May. By late May the official death toll had passed 300,000.

The figures understated the true scale. The World Health Organization later estimated about 4.7 million excess deaths in India from the pandemic, direct and indirect, far above the official count of a little over half a million.

Hospitals ran short of beds and, critically, of medical oxygen. Shortages of liquid oxygen were made worse by a lack of cryogenic tankers to move it. Queues of vehicles carrying sick people formed outside full hospitals, and families turned to social media to find oxygen cylinders. A newly identified variant first detected in India, later named Delta by the WHO, helped drive the surge and soon spread worldwide.

Other countries responded in two ways. Many, including Britain, imposed strict travel restrictions on arrivals from India. Many also sent help: France, Germany, Taiwan, the UK, the US and others shipped oxygen plants, concentrators, ventilators and medicines, and India had received millions of aid items by early May.

Diplomacy, aid and a tense border

The timing of the post was awkward for Beijing. Only a day earlier, President Xi Jinping had sent a message of condolence to Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and offered help. China's Foreign Ministry said it was supporting India's pandemic response, that more supplies would follow, and that many donations and purchases were moving through unofficial channels. Asked about the post, the ministry said it could not find it on Weibo.

Relations were nevertheless at a low point, and standoffs continued at several points along the frontier. On 15 June 2020 Indian and Chinese soldiers had fought a brutal hand-to-hand clash in the Galwan Valley in Ladakh, along the disputed Line of Actual Control in the Himalayas. India said 20 of its soldiers were killed; China acknowledged four deaths. It was the first deadly clash on that border in decades, and both sides had poured troops into the area before a partial disengagement in February 2021.

There were also cyber tensions. A study by the security firm Recorded Future in early 2021 reported Chinese state-linked malware in Indian power-grid systems after the border clash. Some reports connected this to a major blackout in Mumbai in October 2020, but that link was not confirmed, and China denied the accusations.

Reading the episode carefully

Three lessons stand out. First, attribution matters: the post came from a specific party commission's account, not from China as a whole, and the strongest condemnation came from Chinese voices. Second, the deletion suggests that even within a tightly controlled media system there are limits on what official accounts are expected to say when another country is in crisis. Third, grief is a poor subject for point-scoring; images of funerals carry meaning for real families, whatever the political rivalry between their governments.

India's second wave eased by mid-2021 as infections fell and vaccination expanded, but the images from those weeks, and this post, became part of how both countries remember the pandemic.

Sources: CNN via KTVZ, 3 May 2021: A Chinese Communist Party-linked account mocked India's Covid crisis on social media. It backfired; Scroll.in: China mocks India's coronavirus crisis on social media, deletes post after backlash; Wikipedia: COVID-19 pandemic in India; Wikipedia: 2020–2021 China–India skirmishes. The story was first reported in English by the BBC.

COMMENTS