One Man, 19 Countries: How Designers Photoshopped Male Beauty

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
One Portrait, 19 Photoshop Interpretations of Male Beauty

What happens when designers from different countries are handed the same photo of an ordinary man and asked to make him "more attractive" for their own audience? In 2016, the UK pharmacy service Superdrug Online Doctor tried exactly that. The answer is not a single ideal body but a spread of very different edits, from a few smoothed edges to a full bodybuilder makeover.

The project, the men's half of a campaign called Perceptions of Perfection, used a self-portrait by a New York photographer credited as NYPhotoNY. He stands barefoot in black boxer briefs, hands on hips, with a full beard and a soft, heavier build. Nineteen freelance designers, eleven women and eight men, each received the image along with a short brief: retouch him so that people in their country would find him more attractive.

Below you will find the original and fourteen of those versions, with notes on what each designer changed. Read them as personal interpretations by one designer per country, not as a scientific poll of national taste. That limitation is part of what makes the set interesting: it shows how much of a "perfect" body is a design decision.

How the experiment worked

Superdrug ran a women's edition first, in 2015, and it spread widely online. The men's version followed early in 2016 and was picked up by sites such as My Modern Met. The designers were free to change any feature, from skin tone to muscle and hair, though they were discouraged from adding clothes that would simply hide his shape.

The company framed the campaign as a body-confidence project. Its stated aim was to encourage men to "prioritize health above appearance, and to promote body confidence around the world." It also quoted Denise Hatton, then chief executive of YMCA England, who pointed to the charity's own research finding that "40% of men in the UK felt pressure from television and magazines to have a 'perfect' body."

It is worth being clear about what the exercise can and cannot show. One designer per country is a tiny sample, and the designers were working for a commercial brand on a brief that invited dramatic changes. Some of the published versions also go uncommented in the source material, so any reading of them rests on what is visible in the image itself.

The starting point and the lightest touches

One Portrait, 19 Photoshop Interpretations of Male Beauty

Original. The untouched self-portrait shows a heavyset man with a dark beard, short hair and a soft stomach, standing square to the camera in plain boxer briefs. Every version that follows keeps this pose, background and framing, so any difference you notice was put there on purpose.

One Portrait, 19 Photoshop Interpretations of Male Beauty

Australia. The Australian designer left the body almost exactly as it was, with only light smoothing of the skin and a tidier, shorter hairstyle. Superdrug's own write-up singled this version out for keeping his original shape, which makes it one of the closest to the source.

One Portrait, 19 Photoshop Interpretations of Male Beauty

Colombia. This version is another near-copy of the original. The waistline looks a little trimmer and the skin a little more even, but the man is clearly the same size, a reminder that "more attractive" did not always mean "thinner" to the people taking part.

One Portrait, 19 Photoshop Interpretations of Male Beauty

Pakistan. The Pakistani edit makes only subtle changes, with a slightly slimmer middle and a cleaner complexion. His build, beard and hair stay recognisably his own, placing this version firmly in the group of designers who chose restraint.

One Portrait, 19 Photoshop Interpretations of Male Beauty

Spain. The Spanish designer kept his light skin tone and most of his natural shape, with a gentle reduction around the waist. Next to the dramatic makeovers further down, it looks almost untouched, yet it still counts as a deliberate choice about what to leave alone.

Slimmer, smoother, warmer

One Portrait, 19 Photoshop Interpretations of Male Beauty

China. Here the body is noticeably leaner, the torso narrower and the skin a warmer, tanned shade. The hair has been restyled into a taller, reddish-brown cut. The overall effect is of a slimmer, more athletic man without bulky muscle.

One Portrait, 19 Photoshop Interpretations of Male Beauty

Indonesia. The Indonesian version brightens and lightens the skin and trims the waist slightly while keeping his general proportions. Lighter skin is a widely discussed beauty preference in parts of Asia, and this edit seems to lean that way, though the designer's own reasoning was not published.

One Portrait, 19 Photoshop Interpretations of Male Beauty

Portugal. The Portuguese designer slimmed the stomach and smoothed the chest, producing a fit but not muscular look. The skin has a light tan, and the face stays close to the original, so the change reads as "healthier-looking" rather than a new person.

One Portrait, 19 Photoshop Interpretations of Male Beauty

United Kingdom. The British edit narrows the waist and gives the body a slimmer, straighter outline. Superdrug described this as a slimmed-down version. The skin has been warmed slightly, and the beard and hair have been tidied.

One Portrait, 19 Photoshop Interpretations of Male Beauty

Nigeria. The Nigerian version darkens and warms the skin tone and slightly reshapes the chest and waist, while keeping a solid, substantial build. It stands out as one of the edits where size was not treated as a flaw.

Muscle, tan and a new hairstyle

One Portrait, 19 Photoshop Interpretations of Male Beauty

Egypt. This is one of the boldest transformations: a sculpted six-pack, broad chest, much darker tanned skin, and fuller black hair and beard. Superdrug noted that the Egyptian designer gave him darker skin; the muscle work turns him into a gym-poster figure.

One Portrait, 19 Photoshop Interpretations of Male Beauty

Russia. The Russian designer added a long, golden mane of hair along with a muscular chest, thicker arms and visible abdominal definition. The hair is the most striking change in the whole series and shows how far beyond body shape these edits could go.

One Portrait, 19 Photoshop Interpretations of Male Beauty

South Africa. The South African edit produces a slim, deeply bronzed body with sharply defined abs and slicked-back hair. Of all the versions, it is one of the furthest from the source, to the point that only the face connects it to the original man.

One Portrait, 19 Photoshop Interpretations of Male Beauty

United States. The American version goes all the way to bodybuilder: huge shoulders and arms, a chiselled six-pack and a voluminous, gelled quiff. Superdrug's commentary picked out this chiselled, muscular look and the styled hair as the American designer's choices.

A change of clothes

One Portrait, 19 Photoshop Interpretations of Male Beauty

Bangladesh. The Bangladeshi designer swapped the boxer briefs for a checked wrap resembling a lungi, a traditional garment worn by many men in Bangladesh and across South Asia. The skin is lighter and pinker and the body a little slimmer. It is the only version in this set that changes what he wears.

What the set does and does not tell us

Superdrug's published series includes more countries than the fourteen shown here, among them Croatia, Macedonia, the Philippines, Serbia and Venezuela. Its write-up mentions, for example, that one version added a half-sleeve tattoo for Serbia. The images above are the ones originally shared in this gallery.

Several patterns stand out. Many designers trimmed the waist, several darkened or lightened the skin, and a few built dramatic muscle. Yet a sizeable group, including Australia, Colombia, Pakistan and Spain, changed very little. That spread is the most honest takeaway: there is no single global standard, and even within one country two designers would almost certainly make different choices.

The bigger lesson is about how easily bodies are reworked on screen. Almost every photo we see in advertising and on social media has been lit, posed, filtered or edited in some way, and the man in these images did not change at all in real life. If comparisons with edited images are affecting how you feel about your own body, eating or exercise, talking to a doctor or a qualified counsellor is a good first step.

Male body image beyond the gallery

Campaigns like this arrived at a time when health groups were paying more attention to men's body image. Pressure to look lean and muscular has been linked by researchers to over-exercise, extreme dieting and the misuse of supplements, although most of that work concerns specific groups and is still developing. Charities such as the YMCA used the campaign to argue that men are affected by appearance pressure too, not only women.

For anyone looking at the photos above, a useful habit is to ask what was changed and why, rather than which version "wins". The answer usually says more about the brief, the designer and the advertising culture around them than about what makes a person attractive.

Sources: Superdrug Online Doctor: Perceptions of Perfection Part II (Men); My Modern Met: Designers from 19 countries photoshop the same man. Original self-portrait by the New York photographer credited as NYPhotoNY; images by Superdrug Online Doctor.

Explore the related article: A 2018 Online List of Attractive Men: Reading the Poll.

COMMENTS