Originally published 2021-04-24.

In April 2021, a hand-made notice at the entrance to George Floyd Square in Minneapolis set out how visitors should behave at the memorial. Most of it asked everyone for respect, masks and care. One section, headed "For White people in particular", asked white visitors to step back, listen and avoid taking up space. When a video of the sign spread online, conservative commentators called it racist and hypocritical, while supporters said it was simply etiquette for a place of grief. This article explains what the notice said, where it stood, why it drew such a strong reaction, and what happened to the square afterwards.
What the notice asked of visitors
The sign opened with three general requests addressed to every "invited guest". Visitors were asked to come with humility and openness, to wear masks and encourage others to do the same (this was still the COVID-19 period), and to treat the space as somewhere to connect and mourn. The first line set the tone: "Enter with reverence, humility, and openness."
The longer, second part was addressed to white visitors. In summary, it asked them to:
- put their own feelings aside and come to listen, learn, grieve and bear witness, and to remember they were there to give support rather than receive it;
- pay attention to how loud and fast they were, and how they moved through the space;
- add to the atmosphere rather than drain it, and work through their own emotions with other white people instead of with Black, Indigenous and other visitors of colour;
- think twice before photographing and posting, and never photograph people without consent;
- gently challenge other white visitors behaving badly, so that the burden did not fall on Black visitors, and aim for a calm conversation rather than a confrontation.
The individual authors of the notice were not named in reporting at the time. It stood at the barricaded entrance to the occupied intersection, so it is usually described as guidance from the community of protesters and caretakers who had held the space since 2020.
Where George Floyd Square is and why it matters
George Floyd Square is the stretch of Chicago Avenue around its junction with East 38th Street, in the Powderhorn area of south Minneapolis. It is the spot where George Floyd died on 25 May 2020 after police officer Derek Chauvin knelt on his neck for about nine and a half minutes while he was held on the ground. Bystander video of his death set off protests across the United States and around the world.
Within days, residents and activists closed the intersection to traffic with barricades. It became a mix of memorial, gathering place and protest site, filled with murals, flowers, sculptures and handwritten messages. The occupation lasted for more than a year. In September 2020 the city gave the two blocks the name George Perry Floyd Jr. Place, and the curators now known as Rise and Remember have preserved thousands of the offerings left by visitors.
Timing explains part of the attention the sign received. It was filmed in the same week that a jury found Chauvin guilty of murder, on 20 April 2021, when visitors and media crews were streaming to the square and city leaders were openly discussing when to reopen the street.
How the sign became a national story
The notice reached a wide audience after Jorge Ventura, a field reporter for the Daily Caller, filmed it and posted the clip on Twitter. Conservative outlets, including TheBlaze on 22 April 2021, then wrote it up, focusing on the race-specific section.
The online response split along familiar lines. Critics argued that any public sign giving separate instructions by race would be condemned if the roles were reversed, and several asked how people would react to a notice aimed at Black visitors in particular. Others insisted that, in a public space, they would behave as they liked within the law. A third group of commenters saw the notice as one more sign of a divided country.
Defenders read it differently. To them it was a request, not a rule anyone could enforce, written for a place where a man had been killed and where Black residents were grieving. Similar guidance appears at many memorials and sacred sites, which routinely ask visitors to keep their voices down, dress respectfully or avoid photographing mourners.
Guidance, not law
A useful point that often got lost is legal status. The notice was informal. It was not issued by the city of Minneapolis, the police or any court, and it could not bar anyone from a public street. Under US civil rights law, public authorities cannot restrict access to public spaces based on race. What the sign could do was express the expectations of the people looking after the memorial, in the same way a family might ask visitors to a funeral not to film.
That distinction helps explain why both sides felt strongly. Critics heard a racial rulebook in a public place. Supporters heard a plea for sensitivity from mourners who felt the site was being treated as a tourist attraction. Reading the whole notice, rather than a single cropped line or a few angry replies, gives a fairer picture: much of it is ordinary memorial etiquette, and its race-specific parts are phrased as requests to listen and support.
What "decentering" means
The word that puzzled many readers was "decenter". It comes from anti-racism workshops and writing popular around 2020. In that usage, to decentre yourself means to stop making a situation about your own feelings or opinions and to focus on the people most affected. At a memorial for a Black man killed by police, the authors were asking white visitors not to make the moment about their own guilt, anger or need for reassurance.
Whether one agrees with that framework or not, knowing the meaning makes the notice less mysterious. It was asking for a listening posture, the kind of behaviour most people would expect at any vigil, with an extra request aimed at a specific group.
What happened to the square afterwards
The square did not stay closed for long after the debate. City crews reopened the intersection to vehicles on 20 June 2021, although many of the memorials remained in place and caretakers continued to welcome visitors. Chauvin was sentenced to 22 and a half years in prison in June 2021.
The area was later renamed George Perry Floyd Square, with a dedication on 25 May 2022, the second anniversary of Floyd's death. Minneapolis designated the East 38th Street corridor a cultural district, bought the former Speedway gas station at the corner, and began a long community process to plan a permanent memorial, with construction expected from 2026 onwards. The square has also faced real problems, including gun violence nearby and disagreement among local businesses about the long street closure.
For visitors today, the practical advice is simple and close to what the original notice asked: come quietly, read the messages, ask before photographing people, and remember that many neighbours still see the square as a place of mourning rather than a sightseeing stop.
Sources: TheBlaze, 22 April 2021; George Floyd Square (Wikipedia). Original video of the notice: Jorge Ventura, Daily Caller.

COMMENTS