Army Lt Caron Nazario's Lawsuit Over Windsor, Virginia Traffic Stop

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-04-13.

A US Army Lieutenant's Lawsuit Over a Virginia Traffic Stop

In April 2021, US Army Second Lieutenant Caron Nazario sued two police officers from the small town of Windsor, Virginia. During a traffic stop on 5 December 2020, they had pointed their guns at him, pepper-sprayed him repeatedly and forced him to the ground while he was in uniform. Bodycam video from the stop spread online, and within days one officer was fired and the governor ordered a state police investigation. In January 2023 a federal jury found largely for the officers, but awarded Nazario $3,685 for an assault and an illegal search.

What happened at the gas station

Nazario, who is Black and Latino, had recently been commissioned through Virginia State University's ROTC programme and was driving a recently purchased SUV. After dark in Windsor, officers Daniel Crocker and Joe Gutierrez signalled him to pull over. Instead of stopping on the unlit roadside, he drove on slowly for a short distance and pulled into a well-lit gas station. He later explained that he did this for officer safety and out of respect for the officers, not to run away.

The officers treated it as a "high-risk" stop. They got out with guns drawn and ordered him out of the car. Nazario kept his hands visible, asked repeatedly what was going on and said he was afraid to step out. One officer answered that he should be. Gutierrez also told him he was "fixing to ride the lightning". The phrase is slang for execution in the electric chair, though Gutierrez later said he meant his Taser.

Gutierrez then pepper-sprayed Nazario several times through the open window, knocked him to the ground and handcuffed him. In the end the officers let him go without charges. According to his lawsuit, they warned him that complaining could cost him his Army career.

Why he was stopped

The officers' reports gave three reasons: no visible rear licence plate, very dark tinted windows, and the time he took to pull over. Nazario's car was new and carried temporary tags, and his complaint said they were displayed inside the vehicle where the officers could see them.

Many early reports said the plates were "clearly visible". The court's later findings were more mixed. A federal judge ruled that the officers did have probable cause to stop the car for an improperly displayed plate, while still letting other parts of Nazario's case go forward. Having a lawful reason to stop a car does not settle how the stop is handled once the driver has been pulled over, and that question became the heart of the lawsuit.

The lawsuit and the backlash

Nazario filed suit in federal court in early April 2021. He argued that the officers violated his constitutional rights through excessive force, an unlawful search and seizure, and retaliation against his right to speak. Reports at the time said he was seeking at least $1 million in damages.

Once the bodycam footage spread, the response came quickly:

  • Windsor fired Gutierrez. The town said an internal investigation had found that department policy was not followed. It said this led to discipline and department-wide training starting in January 2021, and later to Gutierrez's dismissal. Crocker stayed on the force.
  • Governor Ralph Northam called the video disturbing and directed the Virginia State Police to carry out an independent investigation.
  • Attorney General Mark Herring called the stop unacceptable and demanded full transparency from the Windsor department.
  • The Virginia Legislative Black Caucus said the officers must be held accountable.

The case drew particular attention because it came only months after the 2020 protests over the killing of George Floyd. It also involved a serving officer in uniform, so it was hard to dismiss as a misunderstanding about who the driver was.

The 2023 verdict

Before trial, US District Judge Roderick C. Young ruled that qualified immunity protected the officers from Nazario's federal claims of excessive force, unreasonable seizure and free-speech retaliation. That doctrine shields government officials from personal liability unless they violated clearly established law. The judge did find Crocker liable for an illegal search of the SUV, and he sent the state-law claims of assault, battery and false imprisonment to a jury.

On 17 January 2023, the jury in Richmond returned a mixed result:

  • Gutierrez was found liable for assault, with $2,685 in compensatory damages.
  • For the illegal search, the jury awarded $1,000 in punitive damages against Crocker.
  • The other claims against both officers, including battery and false imprisonment, were rejected.

Crocker's lawyer said the jury had reached the correct decision. Supporters of Nazario saw the small award as an example of how hard it is to win large damages against individual officers, especially once federal claims have been removed by qualified immunity.

What drivers should know about traffic stops

The Nazario case is often used in discussions of what drivers should do when signalled to stop. A few widely shared points:

  • Signal that you have seen the police. Turning on hazard lights and slowing down tells officers you intend to stop, even if you are looking for a safer, brighter place.
  • Make the delay as short as possible. Nazario's short drive to a lit station was presented in court as part of the officers' reason for treating the stop as high-risk.
  • Keep your hands visible and say what you are doing before you reach for documents or a seatbelt.
  • Keep new-car paperwork and temporary tags easy to see. In Nazario's case, much of the dispute was over where his plate was displayed.
  • Record calmly if you can. In most states you may film police doing their jobs in public, and video is often what decides a later complaint.
  • Raise disputes afterwards, not at the roadside. Complaints, lawyers and the courts are the place to challenge a stop you believe was unlawful.

None of these points shifts responsibility for how force is used, which rests with the officers. They are simply habits that lower the risk of a stop escalating.

Sources: NPR via WLRN: Officer who handcuffed and pepper-sprayed Black Army lieutenant is fired (12 April 2021); Military Times: Army lieutenant sues police (10 April 2021); AP via ClickOnDetroit: Jury mostly backs police sued by soldier over a traffic stop (17 January 2023).

COMMENTS