Asiah Kudi's Death: Verphy Kudi's Case and What the Review Found

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-04-02.

Verphy Kudi Pleaded Guilty After Her Daughter Asiah's Death

Asiah Kudi was 20 months old when she died in December 2019, alone in a supported-housing flat in Brighton, England. Her mother, Verphy Kudi, had gone out on 5 December, her 18th birthday, and did not come back until 11 December. In March 2021 Kudi admitted manslaughter, and on 6 August 2021 Lewes Crown Court jailed her for nine years.

That is the short answer most readers are looking for. The longer story matters too, because the case raised a hard question that the criminal trial could not settle: how did a toddler who lived in staffed accommodation, with professionals around her family, go unseen for almost a week? Below we set out what the court, the police, the coroner and the local safeguarding review established, and what has changed since.

What happened to Asiah

Verphy Kudi and her daughter lived in a self-contained flat at Gochers Court on Islingword Road, Brighton. The block of eight flats offered supported housing for young families. Brighton and Hove City Council had commissioned the service, and the charity YMCA DownsLink had been running it since 1 September 2019, a few months before Asiah died.

According to Sussex Police and the Crown Prosecution Service, Kudi left the flat on 5 December 2019 and travelled to London, then to a friend's birthday party in Coventry, before returning to Brighton through London. Coventry is roughly 150 miles from Brighton. She got back on 11 December and called 999 to say her daughter was unresponsive. Asiah was taken by ambulance to the Royal Alexandra Children's Hospital and was confirmed dead shortly after arriving.

A post-mortem and further forensic tests led police to conclude that Asiah had died through neglect. At the inquest in June 2023, the coroner recorded that she died of flu, a lung infection and starvation, and that she had been unlawfully killed.

The investigation and the lies that unravelled

Kudi did not tell the truth at first. When police interviewed her, she said she and Asiah had both been in the flat, feeling unwell. She later admitted to one trip to London but claimed her daughter had been with her. CCTV evidence gathered by the Surrey and Sussex Major Crime Team showed otherwise.

The footage also revealed a pattern. Local reporting of the sentencing hearing said CCTV showed Kudi had left Asiah alone on 11 earlier occasions, five of them for extended periods, the longest about two and a half days in late October 2019. The court also heard that she waited almost three hours after returning on 11 December before calling for an ambulance.

Prosecutors from CPS South East described a young mother who put partying ahead of her child's safety, and pointed to the earlier absences as evidence that she knew the risk. Detective Chief Inspector Andy Wolstenholme led the police investigation.

The plea and the nine-year sentence

Kudi pleaded guilty to manslaughter at a hearing in March 2021. Sentencing was delayed so that the judge could consider psychiatric and other reports. On 6 August 2021, at Lewes Crown Court, Judge Christine Laing sentenced her to nine years.

The judge noted that Kudi had key workers and a social worker she could have asked for help, and told her: "you simply chose to prioritise your desires over the needs of your child." She added that the lies Kudi told showed she had known it was wrong to leave Asiah alone.

Reports from the sentencing also described Kudi's own background. She had come to the attention of children's services as a teenager and had experienced serious trauma in her childhood. None of that was presented as an excuse, but it helps explain why the case was treated as a failure of protection for two young people, not only as a crime by one.

Why a toddler in supported housing went unseen

Many readers asked the obvious question at the time: where were the staff? The early press coverage suggested that workers knew Kudi had gone out but did not realise the baby had been left behind. YMCA DownsLink's own account was different. It said the extended absences only came to light after police examined CCTV following Asiah's death, and that staff had previously seen Kudi step out briefly to smoke, warned her of the risks and been promised it would not happen again.

The charity also said it had alerted social services to a safeguarding incident in mid-October 2019. The council said that, when Asiah died, she had no social worker of her own and was not on a child protection plan. She had been on such a plan from birth, but it had later been removed.

The accommodation was described as "medium support" housing for young families. That level of support assumes parents can manage day-to-day care with some guidance. A child safeguarding practice review later found that Kudi was getting only around two hours of support a week.

What the safeguarding review and the inquest found

The Brighton and Hove Safeguarding Children Partnership opened a child safeguarding practice review in 2020. These reviews, which replaced the older "serious case reviews" in England, are not about blame. They look at how agencies worked together and what should change.

The review, published in 2022, made two headline recommendations. First, the children of young parents should have a social worker of their own whose job is to focus on the child, not only on the parent. Second, vulnerable parents in supported accommodation need more intensive help than a couple of hours a week. It also concluded that professionals and relatives should have asked more questions and checked Kudi's accounts of where she was.

The partnership said work had already begun: in Brighton and Hove, the child of any young parent who has a social worker now has a separate social worker of their own. The council said it has implemented the review's recommendations.

At the inquest in June 2023, the Brighton and Hove coroner, Penelope Schofield, reached a narrative conclusion of unlawful killing. She found that professionals could not have predicted Asiah's death and that nothing services did or failed to do would have prevented it. The review and the inquest therefore asked slightly different questions: the review looked for lessons, while the coroner looked at cause.

Lessons for anyone who works with young families

Cases like this tend to produce outrage and very little else. The people closest to the review drew more practical conclusions that apply well beyond Brighton:

  • Keep the child in view. When support is built around a young parent, the baby can become a background detail. A worker whose focus is the child is more likely to notice when that child has not been seen.
  • Check the story. Kudi's accounts were accepted at face value more than once. Professional curiosity, politely asking who, where and when, is now a standard theme in safeguarding training.
  • Match support to need. A teenager with a history of trauma and earlier child protection involvement may need far more than a light-touch tenancy model.
  • Speak up early. Neighbours, friends and relatives who notice a baby crying for long periods, or a parent repeatedly away, can call the police or their local children's services. In an emergency, call 999.

Remembering Asiah

Asiah's relatives said after the plea that the case had broken their family and asked for privacy while they grieved, adding that they still had many unanswered questions. Kudi had been estranged from them for some time before her daughter died.

Behind the headlines is a little girl who should have been fed, held and kept safe. The value in retelling her story lies in the changes it prompted, so that children of very young parents are seen in their own right.

Sources: Sussex Express: sentencing report with Sussex Police and CPS statements; Brighton and Hove News: sentencing hearing; Brighton and Hove News: review launched; Children and Young People Now: background to the review; Children and Young People Now: review recommendations; Brighton and Hove News: inquest conclusion; Daily Mail: original report of the plea.

COMMENTS