First published March 27, 2021.
In March 2021 Utah became, by most accounts, the first US state to write into law that a biological father must pay half of a mother's pregnancy costs. The measure, House Bill 113, was signed by Governor Spencer Cox on 16 March 2021 and took effect on 5 May 2021. It covers the mother's health insurance premiums during pregnancy and her out-of-pocket medical costs, including the birth, but it comes with conditions about paternity and abortion that are easy to miss in headlines.
What HB113 requires
The core rule is short: a biological father has a duty to pay 50% of the mother's "pregnancy expenses". The bill defines those expenses as:
- the mother's health insurance premiums while she is pregnant, unless an employer or a government programme pays them; and
- pregnancy-related medical costs from conception to the end of the pregnancy, including the delivery.
Only costs the mother actually bears count. Anything already paid by insurance or by a public programme such as Medicaid falls outside the duty. A court can also reduce the amount if fairness requires it, based on the overall circumstances, and the rule does not apply where a court is already dividing pregnancy costs in a divorce case. The father does not need to have been billed directly by a hospital for the obligation to exist.
Paternity and the abortion exception
If paternity is disputed, the father owes nothing until it is legally established, usually through genetic testing. Once it is, the duty applies, so a man whose paternity is confirmed after the birth can still be ordered to pay his share of costs from the pregnancy.
The bill also contains an abortion clause. If the mother has an abortion without the father's consent, he owes nothing, unless the abortion was needed to prevent the mother's death or the pregnancy resulted from rape, rape of a child or incest. Some early coverage simplified this to "fathers pay nothing if there is an abortion", which leaves out both the consent condition and the exceptions.
Claims go through the courts: a parent seeking payment submits records of premiums and medical bills, and the district court orders the father to pay his half. Supporters suggested Utah's existing child-support system could help with collection; the bill text itself relies on the courts rather than naming a specific collection agency.
Who backed it and why
The bill was sponsored by Republican Representative Brady Brammer, with Senator Dan McCay carrying it in the Senate. It passed the House 57 to 13 and cleared the Senate without a single vote against (22 to 0 on final passage, after a floor amendment), before the House agreed to the change 59 to 12.
Supporters, including the governor, presented it as a pro-life measure: if men share the financial burden of pregnancy, fewer women might feel pushed toward abortion by cost. That argument helped it win Republican support. But it also drew backing across the aisle from people who simply saw it as fair. Democratic Senator Luz Escamilla acknowledged reservations but supported it, telling reporters it was ultimately "about sharing costs when both parties are involved".
Concerns raised by critics
Not everyone welcomed it. The most serious worry came from advocates for survivors of domestic violence: a law that encourages a woman to pursue the father for money might keep her in contact with an abusive partner, or expose her to retaliation. Supporters answered that claims are handled by courts and state agencies rather than by direct contact, and that a woman is not forced to file one.
Others questioned how much difference it would make. Most births in the US are paid for largely by private insurance or Medicaid, so the remaining out-of-pocket share, while sometimes several thousand dollars, is only part of the cost of having a child. Reproductive-rights groups argued that if the aim was to support pregnant women, broader measures such as paid leave or expanded health coverage would do more. Some fathers' rights advocates, meanwhile, objected to a duty that begins before birth.
How it fits with child support law
Utah, like other states, already allowed courts to order fathers to contribute toward birth costs as part of a child-support case after a baby was born. What HB113 changed was making the 50% split an explicit, standalone duty that starts at conception, covers insurance premiums during pregnancy and applies whether or not the parents are married or in a relationship.
Since 2021, a few other states have discussed or passed laws extending support obligations into pregnancy, often framed in similar pro-life terms. Utah's version remains one of the simplest to understand: half of the mother's out-of-pocket pregnancy costs, once paternity is clear.
The changed abortion landscape
When HB113 was passed, abortion was protected nationwide by the Supreme Court's 1973 Roe v. Wade decision, although Utah and other conservative states already imposed many restrictions. In June 2022 the Supreme Court overturned Roe in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization, returning abortion law to the states. Utah's own abortion laws have since been tied up in state court litigation, so anyone needing current information should check with official Utah sources or a lawyer rather than relying on reporting from 2021.
Practical takeaways
- The duty covers the mother's own out-of-pocket pregnancy costs and premiums, not costs already paid by insurance or Medicaid.
- Nothing is owed while paternity is disputed; once it is established, the duty applies.
- The abortion exception applies only to an abortion without the father's consent, and not where the mother's life is at risk or the pregnancy resulted from rape or incest.
- Claims are decided by a court, which can adjust the amount if the circumstances make a straight 50/50 split unfair.
- For an individual case, a family-law attorney or Utah's legal aid services can explain how the rule applies.
Sources: Utah Legislature: H.B. 113 Shared Medical Costs (status and votes); Utah Legislature: H.B. 113 bill text; original reporting via Upworthy.

COMMENTS