UN Report on Torture and Disappearances in Syria’s Prisons, 2021

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-03-05.

A UN Report on Torture During Syria's War

On 1 March 2021, the United Nations Commission of Inquiry on Syria published a report on a decade of detention during the country’s civil war. Its conclusion was stark: tens of thousands of civilians had been arbitrarily detained and forcibly disappeared, and thousands more had been tortured or subjected to sexual violence. The Commission found that the government of Bashar al-Assad was responsible for detention on a massive scale and for war crimes and crimes against humanity in that context. It also documented unlawful detention and abuse by armed groups on other sides.

What the investigators found

The report, presented to the UN Human Rights Council on 11 March 2021, was based on 2,658 interviews with victims and witnesses carried out between 2011 and the end of 2020, along with photographs, video, satellite imagery and official documents. Investigators examined more than 100 specific detention sites.

According to press coverage of the report, the Commission described at least 20 methods of torture used in government facilities. They reportedly included electric shocks, burning, pulling out nails and teeth, mock executions, forcing detainees into a car tyre, and hanging people by one or two limbs for long periods, often alongside severe beatings. Men, women and children were among the victims.

Commissioners said the parties had largely failed to investigate their own forces, and that efforts seemed aimed at hiding what happened in detention rather than holding anyone to account. They also urged the release of prisoners because overcrowded, unhygienic jails risked spreading COVID-19.

Who was responsible

The government and its security agencies carried out the great majority of the abuses documented, and they alone were found to have committed crimes against humanity in detention. But the report did not treat other parties as blameless. It recorded arbitrary detention and abuses by Turkey-backed opposition groups, other rebel factions, the US-backed Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Forces, Hayat Tahrir al-Sham, and the Islamic State group, the last two designated as terrorist organisations by the UN.

That distinction matters. A fair account of the war needs to name who did what, rather than blaming every abuse on a single side or spreading the blame so thinly that no one is accountable.

The disappeared

The most lasting harm described in the report is uncertainty. The fate of tens of thousands of people taken by government forces, many of them nearly a decade earlier, remained unknown. Many were presumed dead or executed; others were believed to be held in inhuman conditions. The Commission called on Damascus to reveal what had happened to them.

The Commission’s chair, the Brazilian scholar Paulo Sérgio Pinheiro, said: “Hundreds of thousands of family members have a right to the truth about their loved ones’ fate.”

Earlier evidence pointed the same way. In 2014, photographs smuggled out by a military photographer known as “Caesar” showed thousands of bodies of detainees bearing signs of starvation and torture. In 2017 Amnesty International estimated that around 13,000 people, mostly civilians, had been executed at Saydnaya military prison near Damascus.

How the war began, and what it cost

The conflict started in March 2011, when peaceful protests inspired by the Arab Spring called for reform and the release of political prisoners. The government met them with lethal force, and the uprising became an armed insurgency and then a full civil war by 2012. Over time the opposition fragmented, and jihadist groups grew stronger. The Islamic State seized large parts of eastern Syria in 2014 before being defeated territorially by 2019. In the north-east, Kurdish-led forces set up a self-governing region often called Rojava, which seeks autonomy within Syria rather than independence.

Russia’s military intervention from September 2015 helped the government regain most major cities. By the time of the report, the country was divided between government-held areas, a Turkish-backed opposition zone in the north-west and the Kurdish-led administration in the north-east.

The human toll is enormous. The UN documented more than 350,000 identified deaths between 2011 and 2021 and said this was an undercount, while the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights estimated far more. Around half of Syria’s pre-war population of roughly 23 million was displaced, including millions of refugees in Turkey, Lebanon, Jordan and Europe.

What happened next

Assad’s government collapsed in December 2024. An offensive led by Hayat Tahrir al-Sham began on 27 November and reached Damascus on 8 December, when Assad fled to Moscow. As the regime fell, fighters and residents opened Saydnaya and other prisons, freeing thousands of detainees, some of whom had been held since the 2011 uprising or even earlier. Saydnaya, north of the capital, had been used by the Assad family to hold opponents for decades.

Some accountability had begun even before the regime fell. Using the principle of universal jurisdiction, a court in Koblenz, Germany, convicted former Syrian intelligence officer Anwar Raslan of crimes against humanity in January 2022 for abuses at a Damascus detention centre, drawing on witness testimony similar to that gathered by the UN.

For many, the search continues. The Commission’s 2021 report remains one of the most detailed records of what happened inside Syria’s detention system, and it is likely to matter for any future effort to identify the missing and bring those responsible to justice.

Sources: Associated Press via Bay News 9, 1 March 2021: UN: Arbitrary detentions in Syria conflict may be war crimes; Syrian civil war (Wikipedia); Al Jazeera, 10 December 2024: How al-Assad’s regime fell; original coverage via the Daily Mail.

COMMENTS