Switzerland's 2021 Face Covering Ban: Vote, Law and Exceptions

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-03-09.

Switzerland's March 2021 Vote on Public Face Coverings

On 7 March 2021 Swiss voters approved a nationwide ban on covering the face in public places. The popular initiative, widely called the "burqa ban", passed with 51.2% of the vote and a majority of cantons, and the law finally came into force on 1 January 2025. Anyone breaking it can be fined CHF 100 on the spot, and refusing to pay can lead to a penalty of up to CHF 1,000.

The vote was close, emotional and much debated abroad. Below is a clear account of who proposed the ban, what the arguments were on each side, what the law actually says, and how Switzerland compares with the rest of Europe.

The result in numbers

The initiative was titled "Yes to a ban on full facial coverings". Under Swiss direct democracy a popular initiative changes the constitution only if it wins both a majority of voters nationwide and a majority of cantons. This one cleared both hurdles:

  • Popular vote: 51.19% yes, 48.81% no.
  • Turnout: 51.42%.
  • Cantons: 18 cantonal votes in favour (16 full cantons and 4 half-cantons) against 5 (4 full cantons and 2 half-cantons).

On the same day voters rejected a proposed electronic identity law and narrowly approved a free-trade agreement with Indonesia.

Who was behind the initiative

The proposal came from the Egerkingen Committee, a conservative group close to the Swiss People's Party (SVP). The SVP is the largest party in parliament and holds seats in the multi-party Federal Council, Switzerland's seven-member government, but the government as a whole did not support the initiative. The same committee had earlier been behind the 2009 vote that banned the construction of new minarets.

The government and most members of parliament recommended a no vote. Instead they offered an indirect counter-proposal, a law that would apply if the initiative failed: people would have to show their faces to officials when asked to confirm their identity, for example at borders or on public transport.

Two cantons, Ticino and St Gallen, already had local bans before the national vote, while voters or parliaments in Glarus, Schwyz and Zurich had rejected similar ideas.

The case made for the ban

Supporters framed the vote in several ways at once. Their posters and slogans spoke of stopping radical Islam, and campaigners described the burqa and niqab as symbols of the oppression of women that, in their view, had no place in Swiss society.

Others argued from integration: a woman whose face is fully covered, they said, faces barriers in education, at work and in daily dealings with officials and neighbours. Security was a third theme. Because the legal text covers face coverings generally, backers pointed out that it also applies to rioters and hooligans who hide their faces, not only to religious dress.

The case made against it

Opponents said the measure tackled a problem that barely existed. The Federal Council estimated that fewer than 100 women in Switzerland wore a full face veil, out of a Muslim population of around 5% of residents, the great majority of whom never wear one.

Muslim groups described the vote as stigmatising. Ines Al Shikh of Les Foulards Violets, a Muslim feminist collective, told The Guardian the result was "clearly an attack against the Muslim community in Switzerland", and argued that it damaged Swiss values as a whole. Some feminists and liberals made a related point: a law that tells women what they may not wear limits their freedom just as surely as one that tells them what they must wear.

The tourism industry raised a practical worry. A group of hoteliers and restaurant owners warned that a ban "would damage our reputation as an open and tolerant tourism destination", and that visitors from Muslim-majority countries could choose other places.

What the law says now

After the vote, the federal government and parliament had to write the detailed rules. The nationwide rule, which applies in public spaces and in buildings open to the public, took effect on 1 January 2025. Violations are handled through a simple administrative fine to keep bureaucracy low: CHF 100 settled immediately, while anyone who refuses goes through the regular procedure and risks as much as CHF 1,000.

The law includes a list of exceptions. Face coverings remain allowed:

  • on aircraft and in diplomatic and consular premises;
  • in places of worship and other sacred sites;
  • for reasons of health or safety, and because of the weather;
  • for local customs, such as carnival masks;
  • in artistic and entertainment performances and in advertising;
  • at demonstrations or other gatherings where freedom of expression or assembly is at stake, if the authorities approve it in advance and public order is not at risk.

The health exception means medical masks, which became familiar during the pandemic months before the vote, are not affected.

Switzerland and the rest of Europe

Switzerland joined a group of European countries with national restrictions on face coverings. France passed its law in 2010, and in 2014 the European Court of Human Rights upheld it in the case S.A.S. v. France, accepting the French government's argument about "living together", although two judges dissented. Belgium also has a ban, which the same court upheld in 2017.

Other national measures followed in Bulgaria (2016), Austria (2017) and Denmark (2018). The Netherlands introduced a partial ban in 2019 that covers specific places such as schools, hospitals, public transport and government buildings rather than all public space. In 2025 lawmakers in Italy and Portugal also moved forward with proposals for nationwide bans.

Critics of these laws, including a 2018 view by the UN Human Rights Committee on the French ban, argue that they restrict religious freedom and fall hardest on a small group of women. Supporters reply that open faces are part of how people communicate and trust one another in public life. The Swiss vote showed how evenly divided opinion can be: a shift of little more than one percentage point would have produced the opposite result.

Sources: Swissinfo, November 2024: Swiss ban on face covering will apply from 2025; Wikipedia: 2021 Swiss referendums; Wikipedia: Burqa ban; The Guardian, 7 March 2021: reactions to the vote; originally reported via I Heart Intelligence.

COMMENTS