Minneapolis Plan to Pay Influencers During the Chauvin Trial

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-03-08.

Minneapolis Proposed Paying Influencers for Trial Information in 2021

In late February 2021 the City of Minneapolis approved a plan to pay six social media influencers $2,000 each to share city-approved information during the trial of former police officer Derek Chauvin, who was charged in the death of George Floyd. The plan was meant to reach communities that rarely follow mainstream news or do not get their information in English. After a wave of criticism, the city dropped it on 1 March 2021, a week before jury selection began. No influencers were ever named or paid under the scheme.

The short life of the proposal says a lot about the pressure Minneapolis was under, and about how hard it is for a government to communicate during a trial the whole world is watching.

What the city actually proposed

According to FOX 9, the city's Neighborhood and Community Relations department recommended recruiting six "trusted messengers" with large followings. They would pass on messages written and approved by the city about the trial: court dates, road closures, safety information and where to find help. The influencer budget was $12,000, part of a $69,500 community engagement strategy. The City Council voted 13-0 on Friday 26 February 2021 to authorise the contracts.

The city's own statement at the time framed it as a matter of access. It promised that communities and elected leaders would get real-time information before, during and after the verdict, with enhanced services aimed especially at non-English speakers, Black, Indigenous and other communities of colour, and small businesses that do not rely on traditional media.

The goal, officials said, was to get accurate information out quickly and to counter rumours that could spread online and inflame an already tense city.

Why it was dropped within days

The plan was first reported by the Minnesota Reformer and then by The New York Times, which noted it was likely to meet deep skepticism from residents. Critics across the political spectrum objected. Some saw it as paid propaganda. Others, including community activists, felt it treated Black residents as an audience to be managed rather than people with legitimate anger about the case.

At a public safety briefing on 1 March 2021, Neighborhood and Community Relations director David Rubedor announced the reversal in a single sentence: "We will not pursue the cultural social media partners." City Coordinator Mark Ruff added that when the city makes a mistake, it will acknowledge it and do better. Officials did not give a fuller explanation.

Council Member Steve Fletcher had defended the broader effort as a way to prepare residents for a painful process, saying he hoped the city could do more support "on the front end and rely less on riot shields on the back end".

The trial the city was preparing for

George Floyd, a 46-year-old Black man, died on 25 May 2020 after Chauvin knelt on his neck for 9 minutes and 29 seconds while he lay handcuffed and face down on a Minneapolis street. Early reports, including the original version of this story, said "over 8 minutes"; the 9:29 figure was established by prosecutors at trial. Bystander video of the arrest spread around the world.

All four officers at the scene were fired the next day. Chauvin was charged with second-degree unintentional murder, third-degree murder and second-degree manslaughter. The three other officers, Tou Thao, J. Alexander Kueng and Thomas Lane, were charged with aiding and abetting. In January 2021 Judge Peter Cahill ruled that Chauvin would be tried separately.

Jury selection began on 8 March 2021 and opening statements followed on 29 March. Livestreamed in full, the proceedings drew millions of viewers.

A city braced for unrest

Minneapolis had good reason to be nervous. The protests that followed Floyd's death in 2020 spread to cities across the United States and around the world, and parts of Minneapolis and St. Paul were badly damaged, including a police precinct that was set on fire. Many commentators compared the scale of the unrest to the late 1960s.

Ahead of the trial, officials surrounded the Hennepin County Government Center with fencing, concrete barriers and barbed wire, and spent roughly $1 million on barricades for government buildings and police stations. Governor Tim Walz activated the Minnesota National Guard in February 2021. Reports at the time spoke of plans for up to 2,000 Guard members and about 1,000 officers from other agencies; the exact numbers shifted over the following weeks.

Against that backdrop, the influencer plan was one small part of a much larger effort to keep the city calm. Its failure showed how quickly a well-meant idea can backfire when trust between a city and its residents is low.

The verdict, the sentence and what followed

On 20 April 2021 the jury found Chauvin guilty on all three counts. On 25 June 2021 Judge Cahill sentenced him to 22 and a half years in prison, a decade above the presumptive guideline sentence. The city did not see the widespread unrest many had feared after the verdict.

The other three officers were later convicted in federal court of violating Floyd's civil rights, and each also resolved the state charges against him, by plea or by a judge's verdict. In December 2021 Chauvin also pleaded guilty to federal civil rights charges.

Lessons for public communication

Governments increasingly try to reach people where they are, and that often means social media rather than press releases. The Minneapolis episode suggests a few ground rules:

  • Be open about who is paying. Paid messages should be clearly labelled so audiences can tell official information from independent opinion.
  • Stick to facts people can use. Court schedules, road closures and safety resources are easier to defend than messaging about how people should feel.
  • Work with communities, not around them. Trusted local groups, translators and community radio can extend reach without the appearance of buying influence.
  • Explain decisions. A one-line reversal leaves room for speculation; a short public explanation builds more trust.

The underlying goal, getting accurate information to every community during a crisis, was widely shared. The argument was about the method.

Sources: FOX 9: Minneapolis drops plan to hire social media influencers for Chauvin trial; Wikipedia: Trial of Derek Chauvin; AP via Anchorage Daily News: Chauvin sentenced to 22 1/2 years; earlier coverage via UNILAD and I Heart Intelligence.

COMMENTS